Page 1 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 414

Competition Act, 2002 vis-à-vis MRTP Act, 1969

Nidhi Phatela

Assistant professor Swami Shraddhanand College, Department of Commerce, University of Delhi

e-mail Address: nidhi.phatela@gmail.com & nidhiphatela05@gmail.com

Abstract

We know that the focus of Competition Act,

2002 is on regulating the behavior of the

undertaking rather than regulating the size

of the undertaking, as was the case with

erstwhile MRTP Act, 1969 which prevented

undertakings from investing and growing.

This paper attempts to bring out if the shift

in focus of the new Competition law is

accompanied by the changes in the working

mechanism; and to determine if the changes

made are sufficient to bring about desirable

impact in the economy. In order to examine

the same, this paper discusses the

Competition Act, 2002 and the MRTP Act,

1969 in the light of organizational structure,

powers conferred upon and duties assigned

to the respective quasi-judicial bodies and

investigative offices/bodies and, the

procedures adopted to investigate the cases.

To facilitate lucid analysis, this paper quotes

and discusses some cases resolved under the

two enactments along with the procedure of

investigation adopted in those cases.

The research shows that there are

considerable changes in the technique of

investigation adopted under the new Act.

The research also shows that though the

quasi-judicial body (CCI) and investigative

officer enjoy wide powers under the new

Competition law, yet they are not sufficiently

empowered in some respects. Therefore, the

paper ends with some conclusive

suggestions proposing mainly the search

and seizure provisions along with other

small yet significant changes which would

further enhance the powers of CCI.

Key words: Anti-competitive; CCI;

Competition Act; Competition law, India;

Investigation Techniques; MRTP Act

Competition Act, 2002 vis-à-vis MRTP

Act, 1969

Investigative Techniques: A

Comparison.

INTRODUCTION

Competition Act, 2002 has been enacted

to replace MRTP Act, 1969 which had

become obsolete in several respects in the

light of international economic

developments relating to competition laws.

MRTP Act, 1969 came into force in the year

1970 when India had a strong regulatory

regime and there was a need to monitor the

shaping of industries and protect national

firms from domestic and international

Page 2 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 415

competition, at a time when there was a

need to not only curb anti-competitive trade

practices but also to regulate the

concentration of economic power.

Therefore, MRTP Act sought to achieve the

following five objectives - (a) prevention of

concentration of economic power to the

common detriment; (b) control of

monopolies; (c) prohibition of Monopolistic

Trade Practices (MTP); (d) prohibition of

Restrictive Trade Practices (RTP) and; (e)

prohibition of Unfair Trade Practices (UTP).

In the year 1991 when India decided to open

its economy by removing controls and

resorting to the policy of liberalization and

globalization, there was a need to gear up

the Indian market to face competition from

within the country and outside. There was a

need to shift focus from curbing monopolies

to promoting competition. Then arose need

to revamp a range of government policies

and, design and conduct them in a

complementary manner. “With the growing

complexity of industrial structure and the

need for achieving economies of scale for

ensuring higher productivity and

competitive advantage in the international

market, the thrust of the industrial policy

has shifted to controlling and regulating the

monopolistic, restrictive and unfair trade

practices rather than making it necessary for

certain undertakings to obtain prior

approval of the Central Government for

expansion, establishment of new

undertakings, merger, amalgamation, take

over and appointment of Directors.” These

are the excerpts from the Statement of

Objects and Reasons subjoining the MRTP

(Amendment) Bill, 1991. In 1991, the first

two objectives of the MRTP Act out of the

foregoing five were done away with, as the

provisions relating to the concentration of

economic power and pre-entry restrictions

regarding need to obtain prior approval of

the Central Government for establishing a

new undertaking, expanding an existing

undertaking, amalgamations, mergers and

take-overs of undertakings had become a

hindrance in the speedy implementation of

industrial projects under the new industrial

policy.

Besides, there were no clear cut

definitions in the MRTP Act for certain

restrictive trade practices like abuse of

dominance, cartel, collusion and price fixing,

bid rigging, boycott, refusal to deal and,

predatory pricing which caused obscurities

around the interpretation and application of

the Act and allowed different

interpretations by different courts of law

causing respondents (defendant parties) to

escape indictment. MRTP Act, 1969 was

then found to be limited in its scope and

hence insufficient to meet the challenges in

the age of growing liberalization and

globalization. Globally competitive laws and

regulations were needed for the Indian

industry to compete effectively on the

global front. It was also deemed important

to incorporate the "competition dimension"

within government decisions on policies.

Experience suggests that, in the process of

transition to a less regulated and more open

economy, the existence and application of

competition policy can usefully support

Page 3 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 416

other policy initiatives (APEC, 1999). The

government’s new competition policy could

be reflected through a range of executive

policies and approaches but a legislative

enactment was much needed to ensure

non-discriminatory application of the policy

and avoidance of abuse of discretion. This is

how the new Competition Act was born and

thus enacted in 2002.

Since MRTP Act belonged to the pre-reforms

era, it aimed to promote competition to

protect the interest of the consumers or the

public interest in general by prohibiting

monopolistic, restrictive and unfair trade

practices. Before 1991, there were also

provisions in the said Act to prohibit

monopolies and regulate the size of the

undertakings. The Competition Act, on the

other hand, seeks to ensure fair competition

in India by prohibiting trade practices which

cause appreciable adverse effect on

competition in the market within India and

for this purpose, the new Act provides for

the establishment of a quasi-judicial body

viz., the Competition Commission of India

(CCI). Also, the focus has now shifted from

regulating the size of the undertaking to

regulating the behavior of the undertaking.

The erstwhile MRTP Act prevented

companies from investing and growing,

while the Competition Act, 2002 is designed

to allow companies to grow while

preventing any abuse of market power. The

new Competition Act deals with three

aspects, namely, Prohibition of Anti- competitive Agreements, Abuse of

Dominant Position and Regulation of

Combinations. All the three aspects are

inquired into by the CCI on the touchstone

of ‘appreciable adverse effect on

competition’.

As we know both the enactments provide

for establishment of quasi-judicial bodies

[MRTP Act, 1969 provided for setting up of

Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices

Commission (MRTPC) and the Competition

Act, 2002 provides for setting up of

Competition Commission of India (CCI)] and

Director General’s offices to assist these

bodies. Certain powers and duties have

been given to both under the two Acts for

effective enforcement of the provisions of

the Acts. There also seems similarity in the

organizational structure under the two Acts,

though the focal points of interest of the

two Acts are very different.

As the new legislation (Competition Act,

2002) has now been fully enforced with its

new institutional framework and working

mechanisms, it is now time to study, discuss

and appreciate the impact that has been

brought about by the new competition law

in India. While doing so, we must also

appreciate the changes brought about in the

working mechanism under the new Act. This

paper is intended to bring out the changes

in the procedure of handling of cases under

the new Act and/or suggest changes,

wherever necessary. For this purpose, this

paper discusses both enactments with

reference to the changes in the powers and

functioning of the quasi-judicial bodies and

the Investigating offices/officer(s) and the