Page 1 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 355

It is ‘Monkey bread’ for Male Kenyan Teachers’

Workplace Comfort

Nickson Moseti Ongaki, John Fredrick Moerwa Omwoyo, Faith Wavinya Musa

Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology P.O Box 62000 Nairobi, Kenya

Correspondence E-mail: nickson.moseti@gmail.com

Abstract.

Contact with nature offers comfort, which in

turn has a strong and positive relationship

with workers health, safety, well-being and

productivity. The mechanisms involved

include lowered stress, improved social

interactions, faster recovery from illness,

reduced mental fatigue, increased attention,

higher productivity, reduced violence,

increased pain tolerance and lowered

perceptions of discomfort. Such benefits

have stimulated studies to explore tree

species that if brought to the workplace

could offer such comfort. The Savannah

hypothesis as advanced by Orians

postulates, that people like to see trees with

spreading forms that indicate strong

possibility for accessing water, food and

security, and the genetic basis of this

relationship has been clarified. Studies on

tree species from the Savannah from the

view point of workplace human comfort are

extremely limited yet stress at work is on the

rise forcing people to look for relaxation and

healing. Savannah species of trees may hold

the key to workplace human comfort

especially if carefully selected. The most

preferred form for these trees has also not

yet been established. The objective of the

study was therefore, to investigate this

hypothesis, among rural-based primary

school teachers, by identifying the most

preferred visually attractive Savannah

species of trees that would confer maximum

comfort for them, what form it should take

and determine ratings of four physical stress

comfort factors. Sixty-six teachers from

Nyakach District, Kenya, identified through

snowball sampling technique participated in

the cross sectional study. The attractiveness

of the 5 tree silhouettes and 5 form/context

types was determined using paired

comparison method with a 5-point rating

scale. The repeated measures analysis of

variance(ANOVA) of the paired- comparisons showed main effects in all

respondent categories while Student- Newman-Keuls (S-N-K) of multiple

comparisons revealed that, for teachers

workplace comfort, the highest rating of

attractiveness was for Cocos nucifera

(Palm) but for males, ‘monkey bread’ tree,

Adansonia digitata, an indigenous Savannah

species, was rated higher than all others.

There was also a higher positive preference

for 2m x 1m size photographs. Potted plants

were least desirable, as was Mango,

effectively lending credence to the Savannah

Hypothesis. Rating of workplace conditions

indicated possibility of the existence of high

stress levels occasioned by physical factors

in the teaching environment. Further study is

recommended to explain the determinants

Page 2 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 356

for gender differences in the observed

preferences and to also obtain empirical data

on physical comfort factors.

Keywords- Teachers Comfort, Stress,

Savannah Hypothesis, Baobab, Palm.

Introduction and Literature Review

The definition of workplace comfort is not

straight forward (Miller, 2008) although

extensive evidence available show that

comfort has a strong and positive impact on

safety, health wellbeing of workers and

productivity. He adds that the definition of

the word comfort is ‘as elusive as the blind

men’s elephant’ but concludes that it is a

‘positive feeling of ease and well-being’

(Miller, 2008). In her 1859 Notes on

Nursing, Florence Nightingale recognized

that patients who were comfortable tended

to regain health. Over a century later,

research by Kolcaba and Wykle (1996) has

verified “comfortable patients heal faster,

cope better, become rehabilitated more

thoroughly, and die more peacefully that do

the uncomfortable” (Kolcaba and Wykle,

1996). But comfort is subjective, dynamic,

changeable and filtered uniquely, it is also

holistic-the body is influenced by the mind,

which is affected by emotions. In her

Comfort Theory Model, Kolcaba (2003)

identifies three states of comfort: relief,

which is the alleviation of discomfort; ease

which is a neutral state of contentment; and

renewal (later changed to transcendence),

which refers to the active, hopeful aspect of

comfort in the sense of its root word,

confortare, which also means to strengthen

(Kolcaba, 2003). Vischer (2008) has defined

comfort as a tripartite continuum of

physical, functional and psychological

comfort while Tutton and Seers (2003)

reports that ‘comfort measures are not

comfort unless the patient perceives them as

comforting (Vischer, 2008; Tutton and

Seers, 2003). Tutton and Seers (2003)

concludes that comfort is “what the patient

or worker says it is” Tutton and Seers,

2003). The Concise Oxford English

Dictionary (2006) and

Random House Webster’s Unabridged

Dictionary (1997) define comfort as ‘state of

ease and freedom from pain or constraint;

consolation from grief or anxiety; cause to

feel happy’ (COED, 2006; RWHUD, 1997).

Longman Dictionary of Contemporary

English (2003) adds that comfort is a feeling

of being physically relaxed and satisfied or

if someone or something makes you feel

calmer, happier or more hopeful (LDCE,

2003). The aspect of psychological comfort

could mean pleasing architecture, visual

interest, art on the walls, or natural elements

such as a fountain, plants, or an aquarium.

The effect of beauty - the aesthetic element

of a work environment may be the most

unquantifiable contributor to psychological

comfort in the workplace (Miller, 2008). In

a paper by Bergs (2008), it is argued that

dissatisfaction with comfort has a 10%

negative influence on productivity (Bergs,

2008).

Several studies on psychophysiology have

suggested that a plant environment seems to

provide the preferred form of

physiologically measurable stress reduction

(Chang and Chen, 2005; Coleman and

Mattson, 1995; Doxon et al., 1987; Kim and

Mattson, 2002; Liu et al., 2003, 2004; Lohr

et al., 1996; Owen, 1994; Park, 2002; Park

et al., 2004; Tomono, 2003; Ulrich et al.,

Page 3 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 04

May 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 357

1991; Verderber and Reuman, 1987). This

relaxation occurs remarkably quickly, within

3-6 minutes (Ulrich, 1992; Ulrich and

Simons, 1986). People in a plant

environment not only showed faster physical

recovery from stress, but also improved

psychological (Kaplan, 2001; Kaplan and

Kaplan, 1995; Ulrich, 1979), emotional

(Adachi et al., 2000; Chang, 2000; Cho,

2002; Kim and Mattson, 2002; Owen, 1994;

Park, 2002; Tomono, 2003; Ulrich, 1981,

Ulrich et al., 1991; Yamane et al., 2004),and

cognitive states (Cimprich, 1993; Hartig et

al., 1991; Liu et al., 2003, 2004; Tennessen

and Cimprich, 1995). Viewing plants has

been linked to positive health outcomes of

individuals, such as pain reduction, less need

for analgesics, and faster recovery from

surgery (Diette et al., 2003; Lohr and

Pearson-Mims, 2000; Park, 2002;

Ulrich,1984; Ulrich et al., 1993). There are

certainly extensive evidences that the

presence of plants may significantly

improve stress and enhances the teachers’

health, safety and well-being (Cooper

Marcus and Barnes, 1999; Gerlach-Spriggs

et al., 1998; Hartig et al., 1999; Parsons et

al., 1994; Ulrich, 1999; Ulrich and Parsons,

1992).

Numerous researchers have documented

high levels of stress among teachers

regardless of what level they teach (Reglin

and Reitzammer, 1997; Sago, 1995;

Tuetteman and Punch, 1992, Mokad , 2005)

which appears to be an international

phenomenon (Gaziel, 1993). The main

sources of stress for teachers are society

(with a mean rating of 2.87), parents(mean

rating - 2.60), teaching(mean rating – 2.29),

teaching environment(mean rating – 1.79),

pupils(mean rating – 1.79),

supervision(mean rating – 1.42),

curriculum(mean rating – 1.37),

colleagues(mean rating – 1.28) and

administration(mean rating – 1.08) (Mokad,

2005). Stress has been associated with

anxiety, depression, neurotic impairment,

and other psychological symptomatology

(Brown and Harris, 1989; Dohrenwend and

Dohrenwend, 1974, 1978;

Hollister, 1983; Rodin and Voshart, 1986).

Stressors consume and deplete energy and

prolonged stress contributes to fatigue

(Aistars, 1987; Irvine et al., 1991) and

weaken the body’s immune system, increase

susceptibility to infectious disease, and

delay wound repair (Kiecolt-Glaser et al.,

1995). Mokad (2005) reported that teachers

have adopted coping strategies such as

watching TV (62%), talking with friends

(59%), praying (54%), relaxation (38%),

reading (38%), forgetting work (34%),

playing sports and travelling (23%). These

strategies may impact negatively on

teachers’ productivity. This is despite the

current widespread knowledge that natural

environments hold positive attention, may

block negative thoughts, and produce stress- reducing effects (Kaplan, 1992b, 1992c;

Ulrich, 1983) due to human’s evolutionary

development in the Savannah 4 million

years ago (Orians, 1980, 1986).

The presence of plants may brighten the

teaching environment and create an

attractive, soothing and restorative

atmosphere from workplace stress factors.

Plants uniquely restore people to physical,

psychological, and emotional well-being.

They provide a comfortable and restful