Page 1 of 10
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 328
Overcoming The Challenges Facing The Visually Challanged
Integrated Pupils In Kenyan Schools
Nickson Moseti Ongaki, John Fredrick Moerwa Omwoyo, Faith Wavinya Musa
Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology P.O Box 62000 Nairobi, Kenya
Correspondence E-mail: nickson.moseti@gmail.com
Abstract
Education of children with special needs in ordinary
schools has received considerable attention in recent
years and continues to be a major concern in the
field of special education and indeed education in
general. Today, this practice of integration or
mainstreaming is based on the belief that the
ordinary classroom offers the optimal learning
situation without segregation, and it is thus the best
place to educate a child (Kaufman. 1978). It exposes
children with special needs to a broader curriculum
which benefits them psychologically and socially
since it does not limit their interaction to only other
handicapped children. This paper discusses the
results of a research study that was carried out to
identify challenges facing the integration of visually
impaired pupils (VIPs) and the possible solutions to
these challenges. This purpose was achieved using
research questions that sought to identify the
difficulties faced by the VIPs, causes of these
difficulties, their effects and possible solutions. The
design of the study of the study was a combination of
ex post facto and naturalistic. Data was collected
using questionnaires for teachers and pupils.
However, due to the nature of the disability and the
inability of the research to read Braille, the
questionnaire for the pupils were administered as in
depth interview. The target population consisted of
all the VIPs and the teachers in integrating primary
schools in Kisii County. Simple random sampling
was used to sample out 30 pupils and 20 teachers.
Introduction
Education remains one of the key indicators of
development. It imparts knowledge, skills and
attitudes for survival and develops a child to an
individual who can effectively participate in nation
building. Special education is important for human
capital development as it prepares those who are
most likely to be dependents to become self reliant
(Republic of Kenya, 2005). Traditionally, education
for students with disabilities was provided in
segregated schools, classes or institutions, often
designed to cater for a specific category of disability.
Many of these centers were started by voluntary
organizations setting up their schools for students
with a specific disability, and were maintained as
governments increasingly assumed responsibility for
the education of all students (Jenkinson, 1997).
The reasons for establishing segregated schools and
classes for children with disabilities are varied.
According to Gary and Vaughan, 2007, economies in
the provision of special instructional methods, aids
and equipments could be more easily achieved if
students with a specific disability such as sensory
impairment or hearing impairment were congregated
in a limited number of settings rather than dispersed
over many schools. Similarly, specialist teachers
Page 2 of 10
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 329
could be more concentrated in a single school
enhancing the development of professional expertise
in a specialized area. Secondly, students with
disabilities could benefit from the smaller classes
provided in special schools or units, where they
would receive more one-to-one attention and
instruction could be pitched at a level appropriate to
their needs. Thirdly, segregated schools are less
threatening to children with disabilities than the
regular school, and thus encouraging a feeling of
security and enhancing the self-esteem of students
with disabilities by avoiding continual comparison of
their achievements with those of other, more
competent students. Finally, placing children with
disabilities in regular classes is seen as
disadvantaging non-disabled students by creating
undue demands on teaching and other resources
(Gary and Mark, 2007: 23-24).
Education of children with special needs in ordinary
schools has received considerable attention in recent
years and continues to be a major concern in the field
of special education and indeed education in general.
Today, this practice of integration or mainstreaming
is based on the belief that the ordinary classroom
offers the optimal learning situation without
segregation, and it is thus the best place to educate a
child (Kaufman. 1978). Children with disabilities
thus need the companionship of their typical age
peers; they need the same experiences of
achievement and opportunities to grow into
adolescents and adults who have interesting and
satisfying lives. Above all, they need to develop self
respect and a sense of belonging. Despite the push
towards integration, a substantial numbers of
students/ pupils with disabilities remain in segregated
educational settings. In some cases, schools have not
taken up the challenge to adopt to meet the needs of
these students; in others parents have shown
reluctance to move away from the settings that have
provided so much support for their children while in
others the attitude of the normal pupils towards these
exceptional children has been negative (Jenkinson,
1997: 5).
The Salamanca Statement in 1994 was unequivocal
in asking the international community to endorse
inclusive schooling when it said, ‘all children must
have access to mainstream schools...; regular schools
with this inclusive orientation are the most effective
means of combating discriminatory attitudes... they
provide an effective education to the majority of
children and improve the efficiency and ultimately
the cost-effectiveness of the entire education system’
(UNESCO, 1994).The rights of disabled children to
be educated in the mainstream are spelled out in
Article 23 of the convention which reminds
politicians and education decision makers that a child
with a disability should not be excluded or
discriminated against. It calls for a child to be
educated in a manner that will allow the child to
achieve the ‘fullest possible social integration and
individual development’ (UNESCO. 1989: Article
23).
In 1997, the UK government’s Green Paper on
special educational needs asserts that ‘the ultimate
purpose of special education needs provision is to
enable young people to flourish in adult life. There
are therefore strong educational, as well as social and
moral grounds for educating children with special
needs with their peers’ (DfEE 1997 as quoted by
Gary and Mark, 2007: 131).
Mainstreaming/integration thus expose children with
Page 3 of 10
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 330
special needs to a broader curriculum which benefits
them psychologically and socially since it does not
limit their interaction to only other handicapped
children. Due to the above benefits, many countries
have legislated the policy on integration. Some of the
countries are the United States of America in 1975,
Sweden in 1965, Scandinavian countries in 1960,
Romania in 1990, Uganda in 1992 etc. In Kenya the
approach has received considerable attention through
the education commissions that mainly lay the
foundation of Kenya’s education policies.
In 1964, the Kenya Education Commission chaired
by Ominde recommended that ‘children with
impairment are capable of receiving education and
training in regular schools provided special
considerations are given to their needs by teachers’
(Republic of Kenya, 1964: Recommendation 132).
The 1976 report of the National Committee on
Educational Objectives and Policies chaired by
Gachathi recommended that ‘special education would
follow a policy of integration of the handicapped in
society, especially in cases where the handicap has
been adequately compensated by facilities’ (Republic
of Kenya, 1976: Recommendation 166). In 1988, the
Kamunge Report and the ensuing Sessional Paper
No. 6 of 1988 recommended the integration of
children with disabilities into regular formal school in
order to enhance their enrolment and participation in
formal schooling (Republic of Kenya, 1988).
Following these recommendations, an integration
policy was introduced in 1990 to allow the
handicapped children to be integrated with the non- handicapped children. The same year, the Kenya
Integrated Education Program was started by the
Ministry of Education to coordinate the activities of
the integrating schools. In the more recent Sessional
Paper No. 5 of 2005, the government commits itself
to ‘design and implement programs that enhance
inclusive education in all institutions’ (Republic of
Kenya, 2005: Section4.23)
In spite of the benefits of integration, majority of the
special needs children in Kenya are in special schools
‘where there are specialized equipments and
instructional materials, appropriate physical facilities
and medical services’ (Guralnick, 1978: 72).
According to the Ministry of Education, Statistics
Unit, in 2008/2009, the enrolment of the visually
impaired in primary schools stood at 2,944. Out of
that only 1417 are in integrated programs. In Kisii
County only 145 are in integrated programs and
majority of these are not educable. This is even after
the government committed itself in the Sessional
Paper No. 5 of 2005 ‘to provide support to each
public primary school to begin removing barriers that
make the school environment unfriendly to
challenged learners. The schools were also given
grants to facilitate procurement of the necessary
teaching/learning materials and equipments’
(Republic of Kenya, 2005: Section4.23). The low
enrolment may be as a result of a myriad of
challenges that this research will seek to unveil.
Factors which influenced the Movement towards
Integration
The movement towards integration of students with
disabilities came about as a result of a number of
interrelated influences
a) Integration as normalization
Normalization refers to utilization of means which
are as culturally normative as possible, in order to
establish and/or maintain personal behaviors and
characteristics which are as culturally normal as
