Page 1 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 316
Changing Trends in Student Leadership in Public
School System in Kenya
Nickson Moseti Ongaki; John Fredrick Moerwa Omwoyo; Faith Wavinya Musa
Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology P.O Box 62000 Nairobi, Kenya
Correspondence E-mail: nickson.moseti@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Against the wider background of increasing
interest in the improvement of management
and leadership practices in public schools, this
paper focuses on the involvement of students in
leadership beyond the traditional structure of
school prefects. It also seeks to show how the
school administrators can be retrained in
fresher insights into leadership and
management in order to make their institutions
responsive to changing trends in
administration. Furthermore, the paper seeks
to interrogate the prefect system of student
representation in secondary schools, its
process and outcomes. New ways of
conceptualizing leadership are discussed in
relation to students’ roles as active agents in
improving learning especially in light of the
April 2001 educational legislation that
prohibited school corporal punishment. The
abolition of corporal punishment in schools as
(Ng’ang’a 2002:4) has argued, has left a gap
which cannot be filled and this has led to the
prevalence of diverse disciplinary problems in
schools. Schools are compelled to operate
within the regulatory framework of the
Ministry of Education which may at times
conflict with their peculiar needs, situations
and circumstances. To this end, schools are
somewhat constrained in combating the
rapidly escalating problems with discipline.
Furthermore, parental attitude toward
educators and school authorities exacerbate
the disciplinary control in schools due to
parents’ skepticism towards disciplinary
measures. This paper proposes the idea of
‘democratic governance” as one of the novel
ideas that can make school system relevant to
changing realities. It further introduces the
concept of “Leadership by Students” (LbS) to
underscore the fundamental need by education
authorities to conceptualize a school system
where each student is given a leadership role
in the school as an important way of ending
the prefecture system which is responsible for
the school strikes and a skewed view of
leadership where a few dominate the majority.
This paper argues that a perception of
leadership as a relational process of influence
rather than a hierarchical power structure
gives credence to the view that students’
leadership is developed more within a climate
of democratic governance than dictatorship.
Schools and networks of schools are suggested
as important sites for the enactment of
leadership as influence through the lateral
modalities of power such as negotiation and
persuasion which may contest and change
existing structures of student leadership. In
recent years the term “student voice”
increasingly has been discussed in the school
Page 2 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 317
reform literature as a potential avenue for
improving both student outcomes and school
restructuring (Harber & Meighan, 1989;
Harber, 1995; Ruddock & Chaplain, 1996).
The concept addresses a core voice that has
been missing in the discussion of school
reforms - the dilemma of ownership. Student
voice initiates public schools to reevaluate
who gets to define the problems of a school
and who gets to try to improve them (Trafford,
2006; Flutter & Ruddock, 2004; Apple &
Beane, 1995; Chapman, 1995). A key
challenge for policy workers is to understand
how different school governance structures
and educational reforms impact on the role of
student leaders and most importantly on the
ability of school leadership to provide effective
teaching and learning, (Hargreaves, 2003).
Since 2001, Zawadi Leadership Project in
Secondary Schools under the auspices of
Zawadi Counselling and Research Centre has
been conducting research and seminars on
LbS in 20 selected schools from Nairobi and
its environs. These studies have found out that
the school prefecture system in public schools
is an important cause responsible for the
rising cases of school strikes. These studies
have adopted a multi-method approach
including both quantitative and qualitative
data analysis. This paper looks outward,
focusing on the imperatives of student
leadership rather than inward, on school
heads and governing boards.
Key Words: leadership by students,
democratic governance, educational
governance, management and leadership
practices, negotiation, persuasion, school
prefects, school restructuring, student voice.
A. INNOVATIVE STATEMENT
IN THIS PAPER, WE ARGUE THAT A
LACK OF DEMOCRACY IN SCHOOLS
COUPLED BY AN AUTHORITARIAN
EDUCATION SYSTEM WHICH CREATES
A SORT OF POLICE SYSTEM OF
STUDENT GOVERNANCE IS THE MAIN
CAUSE OF THESE SCHOOL STRIKES
AND UNLESS THIS FACT IS
ASSIMILATED BY EDUCATION POLICY
MAKERS, THERE WILL BE NO END IN
SCHOOL STRIKES IN KENYA.
CONSEQUENTLY, THIS PRESENTATION
IS A CONDENSATION OF RESEARCH
AND TRAINING FINDINGS SPANNING A
PERIOD OF 8-YEARS (2001-2009) THAT
INTERVIEWED MEMBERS OF SCHOOL
COMMUNITIES WHO INCLUDE:
HEADMASTERS-ALSO REFERRED TO AS
PRINCIPALS, TEACHERS, STUDENTS,
PARENTS, MEMBERS OF BOARD OF
GOVERNORS (BOGS), PREFECTS AND
PARENTS. FURTHERMORE, THIS
PRESENTATION PROBES THE
PREVAILING SCHOOL CULTURE
DEFINED AS “HISTORICALLY
TRANSMITTED PATTERNS OF MEANING
THAT INCLUDE THE NORMS, VALUES,
BELIEFS AND MYTHS UNDERSTOOD BY
MEMBERS OF THE SCHOOL
COMMUNITY” ESPECIALLY AS IT
PERTAINS THE ROLE AND PLACE OF
STUDENT LEADERSHIP IN THE
OVERALL SCHOOL LEADERSHIP AND
MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE. THE
RESEARCH QUESTION PERVADING THE
ENTIRE SPECTRUM OF THIS
DISCUSSION IS: HOW BEST CAN THE
STUDENTS’ VOICE BE HEARD IN THE
Page 3 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 04
May 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 318
PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM? AND THE
TITLE FOR THIS INNOVATIVE PROJECT
IS: “CHANGING TRENDS IN STUDENT
LEADERSHIP IN PUBLIC SCHOOL
SYSTEM: INTRODUCING THE CONCEPT
OF LEADERSHIP BY STUDENTS (LBS)”
A. INTRODUCTION
“Democratic Management” is the new concept
that ought to be incorporated by schools’ in
order for them to fit in the “new school order
realities” and in order for the students’ voice to
be heard. The word “democratic” is used to
stress the openness of schools and educational
systems; the term “management” is used to
underline the technical and instrumental
dimensions of governing. We govern those
things or beings, the behaviour of which
cannot be predicted totally. We manage things
or beings, the behaviour of which is easier to
predict. When we govern, we negotiate,
persuade, bargain or apply pressure, because
we do not have full control of those we
govern. When we manage, we tend to instruct
and order because we think we have strong and
legitimate power to do so. Thus, as schools are
becoming more and more open institutions,
rooted in specific local social and economic
settings, and characterized by a complex array
of different needs and interests, then
governance rather than management is what
should characterize relations with students.
And since so many factors cannot be
controlled by executive powers alone, an open
and democratic approach is the only way to a
successful and sustainable leadership in a
modern school.
From 2001, Zawadi Counselling Centre has
been conducting a series of researches and
training seminars on the minority Prefectorial
System of governance and management in 20
secondary schools in Nairobi and its environs
and how best to improve governance and
management in schools. One of the ways in
which Zawadi Counselling Centre has helped
initiate this concept of democratic
management in schools is through the LbS
concept which involves all students in
leadership and management of their respective
schools. Furthermore, such an involvement
lends credence to the concept of “the naked
public square” where leaders are publicly
elected by the majority students to represent
the student body under an agreeable formulae
as opposed to the culture of secret selection by
the few (headmaster and teachers) using an
unknown formulae where the select few
student leaders make major decisions affecting
every student becomes the norm. The LbS
concept will make school strikes a thing of the
past since dialogue born of democratic
governance will be the in-thing in human
relations. The LbS idea is an important aspect
of the concept of “transformational leadership”
which focuses on the importance of teamwork
and comprehensive school improvement as an
alternative to other modes of leadership.
Transformational leadership is contrasted with
instructional leadership which encompasses
hierarchies and leadership structures and
usually excludes teacher development, and,
transactional leadership which is based on an
exchange of services for various kinds of
rewards that the leader controls, at least in part.
Advocates of school reforms also usually
advocate altering power relations. The
problem, explain (Mitchell & Tucker, 1992) is
that we have tended to think of leadership as
the capacity to take charge and get things
