Page 1 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 501
How do self-efficacy and learning orientation affect
performance of university leaders?
Abdul Wahab ; Rosli Mahmood ; Shukri Bin Bakar
School of Business Management, College of Business, Universiti Utara Malaysia, kedah,
Malaysia
abdulwahab1984@hotmail.com; rosli@uum.edu.my; shukribakar@uum.edu.my
Abstract
This research examines the associations
between self-efficacy, learning orientation
and performance of university leaders. The
research through survey instruments
design followed a quantitative approach
and the population of the research was the
leaders of public sector higher education
institutions of Punjab, Pakistan. Data
collection was made through
questionnaires, and the constructs used
were adapted from past studies and
already examined for reliability. The
suggested structural equation model was
evaluated with Partial Least Squares
(PLS) methods. Findings showed support
for the theoretical model that was
measured. The results propose that self
efficacy and learning orientation is linked
with performance.
Keywords: self efficacy, learning
orientation, performance, university
leaders
Introduction
In the tertiary education system, higher
education institutions fulfill a very
important job in educating the specialists,
scientists, researchers and high-level
professionals, required by the state and in
producing most recent information and
knowledge in favour of national
innovation systems (World Bank, 2002).
Within this circumstance, an ever more
central concern of many governments is to
make sure that their universities are in
reality working at the most advanced stage
of intellectual and scientific development.
Top-notch University is a need of today.
The current higher education system of
Pakistan could be described as ‘non
market framed’. Education Policy (1998-
2010) says, “The entire thrust of Pakistani
regulatory interventions and government
policies not gearing universities to market
requirements and market principles”.
There have appeared new challenges lifted
by liberalization and internationalization
of universities. These have carried with
them different dimensions, approaches and
requirements to the leaders of universities
(Akhtar & Kalsoom, 2012).
Leadership is one of the major factors
influencing university’s performance (File
& Shibeshi, 2011). Whereas there are
numerous research studies linked with the
affair of leadership in institutions of
tertiary education, to date research studies
have not adequately studied precise
predictors of leadership effectiveness in
such institutions (Al-Shuaiby, 2009).
There is a vast body of study related to job
performance and leadership of middle
managers in business; however, similar
Page 2 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 502
studies of academic performance and
leadership behaviour in (HEIs) are missing
(Almayali & Bin Ahmad, 2012).
After substantial examination of the
research, the researchers were concerned
in finding out the level to which leadership
abilities of university leaders can be
anticipated by a blend of constructs
including their competencies, leadership
styles as well as roles to be a significant
aspect in leadership efficacy (Eagly et al.,
1992; Billing & Alvesson, 1994; Moss &
Jensrud, 1995; Daugherty & Finch, 1997;
Thorp et al., 1998; Rosser et al., 2003;
Eagly et al., 2003). But, there is a scarcity
of research associated with leadership
styles, and personal and professional
characteristics of university leaders as
predictors of their leadership effectiveness.
The challenges facing the Pakistani
universities at the start of the twenty first
century have straight inferences for its
leaders. There have come out new
challenges which have brought with them
diverse obligations, dimensions and
approaches to the university leaders
(Akhtar & Kalsoom, 2012). So in order to
meet all these challenges a vigorous sense
of efficacy is necessary to sustain and
thrive in front of all institutional
challenges. Bandura (2001) confirms the
importance of self-efficacy in leadership
situation by saying, “When faced with
obstacles or setbacks...those with a strong
belief in their capabilities will redouble
their efforts to master the challenge”.
Higher levels of self-efficacy offer the
inner thrust and guidance to shape the
agency necessary to follow challenging
tasks and opportunities effectively (Shamir
et al., 1993; Cropanzano et al., 1993;
Carver and Scheier, 1998; Mischel and
Shoda, 1998; Lord and Brown, 2004).
Apart from this there is an increasing
importance on the role of self-efficacy in
the area of entrepreneurship, involving
areas such as performance, entrepreneurial
career preferences and intentionality
(Gartner 1989; Scherer et al. 1989;
Chandler and Jansen 1992; Boyd and
Vozikis 1994; Krueger and Brazeal 1994).
From the above debate it may be stated
that in today’s dynamic environment as a
predictor of performance there is an
enormous need of self efficacy in
university leader’s behavior to respond and
meet all the challenges. Although
researches showed the association between
leaders self efficacy and performance, but
studies narrate, although leaders self- efficacy seems to be a promising construct
to comprehend their motivation and
behavior, it has been relatively unstudied
(Tschannen-Moran & Gareis, 2007). Also
the literature of self efficacy in the
association of university leader’s
performance particularly in the area of
higher education institutions of Pakistan is
scarce and somewhat unstudied.
The learning orientation studies have
found that organisations with greater
learning orientation perform better (Narver
et al., 2001; Li et al, 2008). (Farrell, 1999)
propose that one way of becoming more
innovative, and hence more profitable, is
to support considerable levels of learning
orientation within the organisation. It has
been discussed that in an atmosphere in
which a learning orientation is supported,
individuals will be encouraged, motivated
to learn, share and develop new skills and
viewpoints (Nonaka, 1991).
Page 3 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 503
Past researches has shown statistically
significant relations between learning
orientation and job complexity and
entrepreneurial style (Sadler-Smith et al.
2001). Leadership is another aspect that is
possibly associated to learning orientation
(Farrell, 2000). Some of empirical
outcomes also confirmed that learning
orientation has a important positive impact
on performance and radical innovation
(Lee & Tsai, 2005; Hughes et al. 2008) but
research scholars still believe that the area
of learning orientation and performance
orientation has been less studied (Laverie
et al., 2008). Apart from that concept of
learning orientation has received
considerable attention in the scholarly
literature as superior learning process but
its application towards university leader’
performance and specifically in Pakistani
higher education institution context are
very scarce and somehow not studied.
Scholars and administrators alike talk
about an immense leadership calamity in
higher education. Considerable studies
have been focused on the jobs of
presidents, deans and chancellors and have
revealed the leadership calamity by tertiary
learning institutions (Coats, 2000). The
quest for solutions to this leadership issue
leads us to realize that university leader
development is the most misunderstood
and least studied management procedure
(Gmelch, 2013). One of the most evident
deficiencies in the leadership development
area is the absence of sound research on
how to train and develop leaders (Conger
& Benjamin, 1999). (Gmelch, 2013)
Literature Review
Performance
Job performance is uncertainly one of
the most considerable dependent variables
of interest to businesses, government,
educators and the society. Researchers and
businesses are just now reaching
agreement on extensive definitions and
conceptualizations of individual level job
performance. The existence of a flawless
connection between individual
performance and broader organizational
goals is a key assumption that determines a
systems approach to performance
management (Hood, 1991, 1995; Wholey
& Hatry, 1992; Osborne & Gaebler, 1993;
Behn, 1995; Pollitt & Bouckaert, 2000). In
high-performing enterprises, every
individual is appraised according to his or
her performance. If appraised correctly
both the institution and the employees
within it will be affected optimistically
(Alam et al., 2010).
The acceptance of individual
performance management in higher
education institutions is studied at the level
of the academic director, dean, deputy
dean, and the heads of department who
have a main responsibility for managing
the performance of their unit of institution,
and consequently the performance of
department associates and individual
teachers (Meek et al, 2000). Burden of
greater liability and rising competition for
public funds were said to be basis for the
use of performance indicators in tertiary
education (see e.g. Sukboonyasatit et al.
2011; Sorlin, 2007; Lewis et al. 2001). Al- Shuaiby (2009) stated that numerous
studies have also been carried out by a
