Page 1 of 60

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 381

Assessment of Local Governance under the Policy of Administrative

Decentralization: The Case of Horro District, Or Omiya Regional State, Ethiopia

Beresa Abera

School of Law and Governance, Department of Governance and Development Studies

Hawassa University, Ethiopia

Email: bajtb666@gmail.com

Abstract

This study presents the assessment of local

governance under the overriding policy of

decentralization in Ethiopia taking the

case study of Horro district. Both

qualitative and quantitative methods were

employed in the study. In so doing, both

primary and secondary data were

collected during the study. Primary data

was collected from the target population

by using questionnaire, semi-structured

interview and non- participant

observation. Secondary data was gathered

from literatures. The study used two

sampling techniques: purposive and

systematic. Purposive sampling method

was used to identify sample kebeles (the

lower unit of local government structure

below district in Ethiopia) based on the

availability of facilities and access to

transportation, and to pick up the key

informants for interview. In addition,

systematic sampling was applied to select

sample individual respondents from

sample kebeles for the purpose of

administering questionnaire. The total

sample size of this study was 141, among

which questionnaires were distributed to

the sample population of 131 and the rest

10 people were interviewed. The

quantitative data were analyzed using

SPSS version 16.0 computer software, and

the qualitative parts were done by

narration. Stakeholders’ participation,

local good governance, service delivery

and autonomy of the district were

discussed to assess administrative

decentralization-local governance

synergy. The result of the study reveals

that there are moderate public

participation in politics, and limited

participation of CSO and private sector in

development activities and administration.

In addition, the findings demonstrate that

there exists weak accountability,

responsiveness and transparency. These

happen due to more emphasis given to

upward accountability, top-down

nomination, and absence of Medias that

helps to disseminate accurate information.

There are also poor public service

deliveries of potable water, electricity,

health, road and agricultural extension,

but good achievements have been observed

in education and saving and credit

services. The autonomy of the district is

challenged due intervention from higher

level government, particularly zone.

Strengthening the process of

decentralization at local government and

encouraging stakeholders’ participation to

formulate and execute collective action

can promote local governance in the study

area.

Key Terms: Administrative

decentralization, local governance, public

service delivery, Horro district,

stakeholders’ participation, good local

governance.

Page 2 of 60

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 382

1. Introduction

1.1 Background of the study

Over the last quarter century,

decentralization reforms have swept across

many countries of the world by

transferring power and responsibilities of

the state to lower tiers of government,

changing decades of centralized political

and economic practices as well as the way

in which we study politics (Falleti, 2005).

As Taye and Tegegne (2007) writes, “The

underlying principle for decentralization is

that the local government, being closer to

their constituencies, will make quick

responses to the local needs and thus

would able to efficiently match the public

services with the local preferences”. Due

to multidimensional nature of the issue,

there are many arguments for and against

decentralization.

Political scientists who draw from the

liberal tradition argue that decentralization

helps to deepen and consolidate

democracy by devolving power to local

governments (Diamond and Tsalik, 1999).

Economists who draw from a market

theory of local expenditures argue that

decentralization helps to improve resource

allocation through better knowledge of

local preferences and competition among

localities (Oates, 1972). Other scholars,

meanwhile, warn against the devolution of

power to sub national officials and show

that it can augment distributional conflicts

(Treisman, 1999), foster sub national

authoritarianism (Cornelius, Eisenstadt

and Hindley, 1999), and exacerbate

patronage (Samuels, 2003). Interestingly,

despite their disagreements on the effects

of decentralization for local governance

and economic reform, all of the

aforementioned studies share an

assumption that decentralization increases

the power of sub national officials.

There are different dimensions of

decentralization that includes political

(which focus on pluralistic politics and

representative government with the aim to

give citizens or their elected

representatives more power in public

decision making); administrative (which

seeks to redistribute authority,

responsibility and financial resources for

providing public services among different

levels of government); fiscal (which its

central theme is to decentralize financial

power and responsibility); and market

(which focus on privatization and

deregulation to shift functional

responsibility from the public to the

private sector) decentralization (WB,

2007).

As far as local governance is concerned,

administrative decentralization is the most

Page 3 of 60

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 383

practiced and accepted form of

decentralization (Cohen and Peterson,

2005). It is the process of transfer of

planning, financing and management

responsibilities and functions from the

central government, regional governments

and its agencies to local governments,

semi-autonomous public authorities and

regional or functional authorities (UNDP,

2004).

More importantly, administrative

decentralization is very closely interrelated

with local governance. Local governance

is a system through which citizens and

their groups can articulate their interests

and needs, mediate their differences, and

exercise their rights and obligations at

local level (UNDP, 2004). Indeed,

decentralization reinforces and legitimizes

local governance

processes when correctly done.

Ethiopia has come to adopt

decentralization policy since 1991 which

transfers powers, resources, functions and

responsibilities from the center to the

regional and local governments (Taye and

Tegegne, 2007). Consequently, nine

regional states and two city

administrations named Addis Abeba and

Dire Dhawa were created. The process of

decentralization in Ethiopia took two

phases; the first phase was started in1992

and ended in 2001 which transferred

powers, functions and resources from

the center to the regional government.

This process deserves a landmark spot in

the political development of Ethiopia. The

second phase of decentralization began in

2001/2002 which whispered to further

deepen the process of decentralization as it

was aimed at further pushing powers,

resources and functions to the local level

governments (Meheret, 2002). This

process is accompanied by a program

called District Level Decentralization

Program (DLDP).

DLDP is a sub-program of Ethiopia’s

capacity-building strategy. Its aim is to

deepen the process of decentralization by

empowering the lower tiers of the regional

governments, the district administrative

units, which is considered as the key level

of local government. The first phase of the

implementation of the program was

limited to four regional states: Amhara

state, Oromiya state, Southern Nations/

Nationalities and Peoples’ state (SNNPs),

and Tigray state (Meskerem, 2007). This

program, as stated in its objective, is hoped

to enhance the quality of local governance

since it enables the government to be

closer to the people and makes the local

government more accountable, transparent

and responsive to the local people.