Page 1 of 18
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 284
A Study on Project Cycle and Project Risk Management:
A Case of Highway Construction Project
Mohamed Kargbo1 Ebrahim Almekhlafi2 Milton Abdul Thorlie3
Isata Tarawally 4 Mnaranara E. Theresia5
1School of Finance and Economics, Dalian University of Technology, 116023, China,
Email: mohamedkay17@yahoo.com
2School of Management, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, 116023, China,
Email: ealmekhlafi@ymail.com
3School of Mathematical Sciences, Dalian University of Technology, 116023, China,
Email: miltonthorl@yahoo.com
4Department of International Business and Management, Zhejiang Normal University (Jihua)
Email: isatababytarawally@yahoo.com
5School of Humanities and Social Sciences, Dalian University of Technology, 116023, China,
Email: kapongoti@yahoo.com
Abstract
Practitioners are constantly creating awareness
of the need to construct highway infrastructure
projects to support the growth of world
population and upgrade the existing
infrastructures to support the fundamental
services that directly impact people’s living
habits, in the hope of reducing poverty and
fostering economic development, trade, and
technical cooperation. The project cycle
management and project risk management are
powerful tools on which to achieve these
objectives. This study seeks to investigate the
factors responsible for projects failure
particularly in the highway construction
projects within the frame work of risk
identification, risk assessment, analysis,
treatment, monitoring and control using Fuzzy
linguistic approach, Kendal’s Concomitant
Rank Approach and Sensitivity analysis. The
findings of the study are that Project
implementation should be aimed at focusing on
specific; measureable; achievable; realistic and
time bound alternative scenarios and that
prudent risk management approaches may offer
solution to achieving project goal. This study
contributes to current literature by providing a
qualitative understanding of relationship
between project cycle management and project
risk management in developing and developed
countries. This understanding is important for
academics, project managers and policy makers
in shaping the future stability of infrastructural
projects and hence economic growth.
Keywords: Project Cycle, Project Risk
Management, Highway Construction Project,
One Belt and One Road Project and Economic
Growth
1. Introduction
The relationship between project cycle
development and project risk management is a
controversial topic because we are most concern
about poor performance in project management
that can lead to cost increase (project cost
overrun); loss or reduction in project
Page 2 of 18
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 285
satisfaction/utility, delay to complete project on
time, reputation issues and insolvency/stalled
projects and thus have a negative effect on the
socio-economic growth. This research does not
undermine project failure and the devastation it
may cause on the society and the overall growth
climate.
We have seen recently the world population is
rising exponentially and demands for additional
and more efficient infrastructure are increasing
in all sectors. Practitioners are constantly
creating awareness of the need to build
infrastructures to support the growth of world
population, and upgrade the existing
infrastructures to support the fundamental
services that directly impact people’s living
habits. In 2005 the American Society of Civil
Engineers (ASCE) reported that the critical
infrastructure of the United States was outdated,
and in 2008 the President of ASCE presented a
testimony in the US congress to recommend a
substantial commitment and investment in
infrastructure construction and upgrades as part
of the economic development plan and to meet
the current demands of population increase
(ASCE, 2008). The project cycle management
entails identification, feasibility and appraisal,
negotiation/financing, implementation,
monitoring and evaluation and post evaluation
and is a powerful tool on which to achieve this
goal (Zayed, et al, 2009).
It can be analogous to infer that it is in the same
spirit that the “One Belt and One Road” project
which has the potential to offer solution to the
growing needs in Asia and may help to reduce
poverty and fostering economic development,
trade, and technical cooperation in the Asia
continent is proposed. Therefore, the
implementation of such a laudable initiative will
enhance peace, security, stability, regional
integration and hence economic development
among its member states. However, two of the
weaker areas that international development
infrastructure projects need to improve,
according to the World Bank (2007), were: (i)
the prediction of realistic outcomes (i.e.: cost,
safety, scope and schedule), (ii) the achievement
of accurate results when compared to a
benchmark. World demand of infrastructure is
expected to rise and public owners are
increasingly challenged by stakeholders to
optimize the use of available funds to maximize
the delivery of infrastructures (Zhang, 2005a).
The global need for infrastructure investment
and improvement of its efficiency as argued by
Tah et al., (2001) is due to increasing demands,
and also to market and government failure
worldwide; market failure, because of
significant inefficiencies and limited
competition; and government failure, in terms of
its slow and infective decision making and
implementation. Both infrastructure
development and implementation efficiency are
needs that have to be satisfied, and they are
forcing industry practitioners to create new
methods to deliver infrastructure projects
on-time and on-schedule. One approach is the
application of alternative delivery methods, like
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) that aids
funding and increases synergy between public
and private entities based on trust, allowing
more capital availability for the development of
infrastructure. Other approaches are based on
improving efficiency and predictability to
maximize the use of the available resources; an
example of this is the application of risk
identification, analysis and mitigation
techniques that provide owners with tools to
predict and prepare for the difficulties during
construction. Innovations in both areas are
needed to fulfill a demand that is only expected
to increase in the future. However, project risk
management particularly with highway
Page 3 of 18
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 286
construction infrastructure projects is often
ignored.
The highway construction project has numerous
uncertainties and risks, which increase with
respect to the size and the complexity of a
project and often fraught with risk and
uncertainty. However, engineers, project
managers and cost estimators often overlooked
or failed to recognize project risks and
uncertainty early in the project development
process. As a result they do not communicate
project uncertainty, risk and its effects to
stakeholders.
Project Management Institute (PMI) defines
project risk as an uncertain event or condition
and that its occurrence has positive or negative
effect on at least one project objective, such as
time, cost, scope, or quality (PMI 2004).
Uncertainty’ refers to the occurrence of an event
about which little is known. Project risks may
have one or more causes and impacts, and
project risk management might be formal or
informal process. Project risk management
includes the process concerned with conducting
risk management planning, identification,
assessment/analysis, responses/treatment, and
monitoring and control on a project; most of
these processes are updated throughout the
project. Ashley et al., (2006) have emphasized
the importance of risk assessment, risk
allocation, and risk management in effective
management of highway construction projects.
These scenarios may not be an exception to the
proposed highway construction project of the
“One Belt, One Road” construction project and
could pose potential impediments to the project
life cycle and management.
Now that growth promotion in the highway
construction project is being actively supported
by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the
World Bank and other International Financial
Institutions (IFS) including Governments, all
these efforts requires research to find out the
link between project cycle development and
project risk management. The highway
construction project management provides good
laboratory test as it has fraught with problem of
quality and safety; time management (program
/schedule), scope and change management;
procurement and contracts; information
management and; external influence (the macro
and legal environment) and people management
for a very long time.
Given the abysmal and poor construction of
highway projects in recent times, even with the
introduction of the IMF and the World Bank
adjustment programmes coupled with
governments’ initiatives and support to highway
construction projects; the following questions
becomes imperative and concern; (i) What are
the factors responsible for the poor performance
and failure in highway construction project and
its implication on the socio-economic growth
and development of nations? (ii) Can prudent
project cycle development design useful for the
stability and mitigation of project risk
management in terms of increased productive
investments and hence economic growth?
To this end, a comprehensive project cycle
development and risk management approach
can help project team identify, assess, mitigate
and control project risks. Another benefit of risk
management approach is the ability to generate
range of estimates early in the project
development process and to establish justifiable
contingencies with the aim of achieving project
objectives. This understanding is important for
academics, engineers, project owners,
development partners and policy makers in
shaping the future stability of the highway
construction projects regarding quality, time and
cost efficiency globally. These issues therefore,
