Page 1 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 135
Municipal revenue compliance and its potentiality of
Damak municipality in Nepal
1Shankar Prasad Upadhyay ; 2Prof. Dr. Kamal Das Manandhar
Ph. D. Scholar, Mewar University, Chittorgarh, Rajasthan, India
Assistant Dean (Management Faculty) Tribhuvan University, Nepal
Email: shankarsirs@gmail.com
Abstract
The major portion of municipal own source revenues is
tax revenue. Municipal own revenue sources are more
stable and consistent than intergovernmental transfers
as well as other external sources. The basic objectives
of the present study are to analyze the municipal
revenue compliance and to expose the own sources
revenue potentiality of Damak municipality. A
descriptive and analytical research design was applied
among 166 respondents (33 municipal policy advisors
and 133 municipal taxpayers) of Damak municipality
and simple random sampling method was used to select
the municipality as a sample. Also, Simple random
sampling method was employed to select the
respondents. Most of the taxpayers (i.e. 80.4 % ) have
paid municipal revenues and out of them, more than 57
percent taxpayers have paid the municipal revenues
below one thousand rupees. The contribution of own
source revenue to total revenue has been fluctuating
over the period of six years. From the view point of
municipal policy making advisors, integrated property
tax seems more potential source of revenue in
comparison to other own sources. To some extent, tax
compliance is satisfactory. Tax revenue wraps the main
segment of municipal own source revenues. Service
quality and local revenue collection capacity of Damak
municipality are almost moderate and likely to be
strong. Service delivery fee imposed by the municipality
for sanitation service is about satisfactory.
Key Words: Municipal tax revenue, Municipal revenue
compliance, Own source revenue, Revenue potentiality
1. Introduction
In Nepal, the key tax revenue sources of
municipalities are usually integrated property, rent,
house and land, vehicle, enterprise, advertisement, and
commercial video tax. Likewise, the major non-tax
revenue sources are; property rental charge, building
permit fee, vehicle parking charge, and service
fee/charge, etc. (LSGA, 1999). Whatever method of
collection is adopted the municipalities must be
transparent and it should be acceptable to the taxpayers
(Study Team, 2005). Decision regarding local revenue
administration is crucial for municipal decision making
advisors and decision makers. Revenues collected in
municipalities are generally classified into two types:
internal and external. Internal revenues are also
commonly categorized into two forms and they are tax
and non-tax revenues (Wegner, 2008).
The central Government of Nepal has positive
feelings on the increasing efficiency in service delivery,
but it is impeded by different aspects, including lack of
regular monitoring of performance and sound
procurement plans, non-performance of competitive
tendering and lack of performance auditing as well.
Page 2 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 136
Unwanted pressure of expenditures toward the end of
the fiscal year is the main cause of these factors
(Ministry of Finance, 2008, p. 16). For the local
government benefit principle of taxation is more
appropriate and for the central government ability to
pay principle is suitable. But, the ground reality in
developing countries, like Nepal, is vast difference.
There are only a few tax bases in practice.
Consequently, the municipality has become very weak
to administer the tax. Actually, municipal taxes or fees
are paid as a charge for the benefits obtained from the
services. Therefore, benefit principle becomes workable
only when benefit from local services can be
approximately identified. (Shrestha, 2009)
Positive peer attitude, rewarding tax payers,
offering a prize for best taxpayers and aim of low
profits etc. are the supportive factors of municipal
revenue compliance. Similarly, inability to be aware of
tax laws or insufficient tax education programmes, high
rates of tax and non tax revenues, complex tax
administration procedures, unfairness or chances of
misuse revenues etc. are the possible factors of non- compliance (Mumumba Omweri Marti, 2010).
Especially in developing countries like Nepal, many
researches are performed on taxpayers' attitude towards
municipality and the effect of individual religiosity on
tax fraud as well as on other factors influencing tax
compliance behavior (James O Alabede, 2011). The
fiscal exchange theory of public finance hints that the
existence of government expenditures may encourage
compliance and the governments can boost compliance
by making available goods or services that municipal
people demand more efficiently. According to the
political legitimacy theory, it is shaped by the degree to
which citizens believe the municipality. In conclusion,
we come across some indications that tax knowledge
and awareness have a significant impression on revenue
compliance point of view (Merima Ali, 2013). Tax
source is an important own source revenues of
municipalities. Both the benefit principle and ability to
pay principle of taxation are the basic philosophies
(BSBA, 2013). Revenue compliance is related to
taxpayer's perceptions of value for money and fairness
in the sub-national revenue system and that appropriate
enforcement can be productive (Smoke, 2013). Local
revenue collection strategies are varied from
municipalities to municipalities. But method of revenue
collection unanimously, is an important decision for
each municipality. Collection through contractors or
public private partnership (PPP) model and direct
collection by municipalities themselves are common
methods. Whatever may be the methods of revenue
collection both accountability and cost effectiveness are
most considerable factors for taxpayers and
municipalities themselves as well.
The main aims of the present study are to
analyze the municipal own source revenue compliance
and to explore its potentiality regarding Damak
municipality in Nepal.
2. Review of Literature
2.1 Problems of Revenue Compliance
Many taxpayers pay little attention to tax
matters and may not even view tax evasion as an ethical
issue. Similarly, the ethical values of them may be
much more tempered by situational requirements than
unrealistic anticipation (Philip M.J. Reckers D. L.,
1994). In most developing countries, budget execution
and accounting processes are either manual or
supported by very old and inadequately maintained
software applications. This has had toxic effects on the
performance of their municipal expenditure
Page 3 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 137
management systems, that are often not adequately
appreciated (Khemani, 2006, p. 2). The type of
government system appears to matter in the propensity
to engage in corruption. The literature makes clear that
the causes of corruption tend to be complex, but
corruption thrives in the developing world because of
the prevalence of weak public institutions, low levels of
education attained by the majority of citizens, and the
presence of an underdeveloped civil society. (Prier,
2007, p. 76). We have so many anxieties on the subject
of the management of municipal finance in Nepal.
Nepal government and Udle/GTZ (development partner
agency for local governments of Nepal) have clearly
stated (MLD, udle/GTZ, 2008) that there is no clear
transparency for what the levied taxes are utilized. The
taxpayers want to have better services for its taxes, but
often they are not delivered by the municipal
administration. Inter -agency coordination, conflicting
laws, syndicating/ cartelling of interest groups, low
administrative efficiency, negatively motivated local
staff, low tax effort, low effort on transparency
(dissemination and mass communication), political
instability, non tax compliance, and non- feasible local
revenue sources are the major revenue mobilization
problems (Nepal Government, 2010). Lack of well
defined mission and comprehensive functional role,
lack of proper structure for the development process,
and low quality of staff are also the reasons of
ineffectiveness of municipal administration (Adams,
2012, pp. 4-13). Regarding the measurement,
explanation and control of tax evasion, we still need to
fulfill many gaps in our understanding although we
might have learned so many matters of finance and
taxation. (Alm, 2012). A challenge for a study of
taxpayer attitude is a lack of reliable data due to an
individual’s reluctance to reveal one’s own non- compliance. (Merima Ali, 2013, p. 5).
2.2. Revenue Compliance in Nepal: Policy Perspective
Pertaining to the noncompliance of municipal
tax by the citizen, Nepal government has made the
provision under the Section 260 of Nepalese Local Self
Governance Act (1999) that if any person does not pay
any tax, duty or charge levied or contracted or any other
amount due and payable to the local bodies, it shall be
recovered by the District Administration Office as
government dues. Likewise the government has
mentioned the provision under the sub section 2(a &b)
and 4 of section 165 of Nepalese Local Self
Governance Act (1999) that if any one does not pay the
taxes, fees, charges, tariffs contracted or imposed by the
Municipality and any other amount due and payable to
it, the municipality may take actions. Besides the
provisions stated in the section 59 of Local Bodies
Resource Mobilization and Management Manual
(2012) issued by the Nepal Government, the local
bodies have to fulfill all the conditions of budget
authority, circulars and directions issued from the
concerned ministries, and the provisions of minimum
conditions and performance measures (MCPM) manual
(MoFALD, 2012).
The Department of Revenue Investigation of
Nepal Government has set the preventive module for
revenue compliance. The preventive strategy includes
compliance of the acts and rules, mobilization of flying
and emergency squad, adherence of code of conduct of
investigation officials, issuance of guidelines and
orders, use of information technology etc. (Nepal
Government , 2014).
2.3 Municipal Revenue Potentiality
Internal sources of revenue are more stable
and consistent than external sources. External sources
