Page 1 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 64
Developing Effective Teachers’Evaluation System: A
Study of Educational Institutions in Karachi
1
Syed Kashan Ali Shah,
2
Zulfiqar Ali,
3Najabat Ali
1 2 PhD Scholar, Department of Public Administration, University of Karachi, PAKISTAN
3Research Scholar, Hamdard Institute of Education and Social Sciences, Hamdard University, Main
Campus, Karachi, PAKISTAN
1Corresponding Author: Syed Kashan Ali Shah Email: kashan_shah@live.com
ABSTRACT
The years of research has proven that nothing
educational institutions can do for their
students more than giving them effective
teachers. The objective of this research is to
develop effective evaluation system for
education Institutes in Karachi. In order to
collect data various reports, international
surveys and faculty evaluation systems were
studied. Faculty In charge and program
managers were interviewed to get their
opinion on guidelines for developing faculty
evaluation. Teachers were consulted on what
areas assessment should be based. Moreover,
Students feedback on teacher’s performance
was collected. Results reveal that students’
feedback, colleagues review, and teacher’s
self-reflection method will be significant in
designing effective evaluation system. Study
recommends that a teacher’s evaluation
system should allocate appropriate weight
age to students’ feedback, peer review and
standards set by institute.
Keywords: Faculty, evaluation, feedback,
performance, teachers, education.
INTRODUCTION
Nearly everyone agrees that great teachers are
critical to student success and that our
educational institutions have not done nearly
enough to evaluate teachers accurately and
use this information to improve educational
quality. We cannot address any of these issues
without better teacher evaluation systems.
Evaluations should provide all teachers with
regular feedback that help them grow as
professionals, no matter how long they have
been in the classroom. Evaluations should
give educational institutions the information
they need to build the strongest possible
instructional teams, and help districts hold
school leaders accountable for supporting
Page 2 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 65
each teacher’s development. Most
importantly, they should focus everyone in a
school system, from teachers to the
superintendent, on what matters most:
keeping every student on track to graduate
from high school ready for success in college
or a career.
Evaluations should do all of these things, but
in most cases, they don’t even come close.
Instead, they are typically perfunctory
compliance exercises that rate all teachers
“good” or “great” and yield little useful
information. As Secretary of Education Arne
Duncan noted in a summer 2010 speech, “our
system of teacher evaluation... frustrates
teachers who feel that their good work goes
unrecognized and ignores other teachers who
would benefit from additional support.”
The crucial question now facing education
leaders is, “How?” How can they avoid the
pitfalls of evaluation systems? How can they
create evaluations that become useful tools
for teachers that help push students to new
heights? What can they learn from the
institutes and universities that are making real
progress? This guide is intended to address
these critical questions. We hope to provide a
blueprint for rigorous, fair and credible
teacher evaluation systems centered on
student outcomes.
Just as there is no simple system for
evaluating the quality of faculty research,
there is no simple system for evaluating the
quality of faculty teaching. However, by
thinking carefully about the purposes of
evaluation, and by crafting multiple methods
of evaluation that suit those purposes, one can
devise evaluation systems that are reliable,
valid, and fair. Equally important, the process
of discussing and crafting evaluation systems
focuses attention on the practice of good
teaching and helps to create a culture in which
teaching is highly valued.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Years of research have proven that nothing
educational institutions can do for their
students more than giving them effective
teachers. Effective teachers not only deliver
education but also develop vision among their
pupils. A few years with effective teachers
can put even the most disadvantaged students
on the path to success. A few years with
ineffective teachers can deal students an
academic blow from which they may never
recover.
Page 3 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 05
June 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 66
“The effect of increases in teacher quality
swamps the impact of any other educational
investment, such as reductions in class size.”
Gold Haber, 2009
“More can be done to improve education by
improving the effectiveness of teachers than
by any other single factor.”Wright, Horn and
Sanders, 1997
“Having a top-quartile teacher rather than a
bottom-quartile teacher four years in a row
could be enough to close the black- hite test
score gap.” Gordon, Kane and Staiger, 2006
“Having a high-quality teacher throughout
elementary school can substantially offset or
even eliminate the disadvantage of low socio- economic background.”Rivkin, Hanushek and
Kain, 2002
Research has also shown that the best
predictor of a teacher’s effectiveness is his or
her past success in the classroom. Most other
factors pale in comparison, including a
teacher’s preparation route, advanced degrees,
and even experience level (after the first few
years). The lesson is clear: to ensure that
every child learns from the most effective
teachers possible, educational institutions
must be able to gauge their teachers’
performance fairly and accurately. Jordan,
Mendro, and Weerasinghe, The Effects of
Teachers on Longitudinal Student
Achievement, 1997
Teachers’ Performance Evaluation in HEIs
Higher education plays an important role in
our societies. It educates students for work or
for academic and research performance. Yet,
this is not its only role. It also represents the
cornerstone for the democratization, growth
and wellbeing of our societies (Razavi, 2007).
Considering the universalizing era and the
change in the universities' mission and a
move towards high-quality and organizational
excellence, the existing indicators of
evaluation which are mainly goal-oriented
and introspective, are no more indicative of
the evaluation of the universities; therefore,
by using the modern indicators of universal
evaluation which are derived from
organizational excellence models, it is
possible to walk towards the development of
a society and the effectiveness of universities
consistent with national and international
evolutions (Ghurchian et al., 2010).
Over the last few years, a great emphasis has
been laid upon faculty development programs
within and or outside the higher education
institutions (Usmani, 2008).
