Page 1 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 48

Exclusive Rights and Exclusion of Communities

in Common Property Resources

Jayarajan A

1 Ph. D Research Scholar , Department of Political Science and Development Administration, Gandhigram

Rural Institute – Deemed University

email: najayarajan@gmail.com

K.S. Nakkeeran

1 *Professor and Head, Department of Political Science and Development Administration, Gandhigram Rural

Institute – Deemed University

email: kirangru@gmail.com

Abstract

Common Property Resources are widely

used by all the people of the village, it is

regulated by government institutions and

by the local communities. Each and

everyone in the village have exclusive

rights to access commons but some sections

of the Indian society are not allowed to use

because of the caste they belongs. The

untouchability practice was still in many

villages where Dalits are not treated unfair

by the upper caste while they access to

commons. The paper narrated

retrospectively about the Dalit problem

pertains with Common access and

highlighted the contemporary issues.

Key word: Dalit, commons, Common

Property Resources, Exclusion

Introduction

This paper is concerning over two

most important issues, one is exclusive, that

intend to find out the communities that

have full rights over the common property

resources (CPR). Second is to study on

exclusion, where communities that were

deny in access over commons. These two

significant issues were taken on the

grounds that through this study, the rights

of a community will be found and in the

meantime issues in access to CPR will be

dealt with. Naturally, this world is meant to

be shared among all, whereas we have

divided up its resources in terms of

‘property’ on the basis of needs, customs

and laws, as well as by mere fiat and force.1

In the state of nature, Locke believed that,

Property is common in the sense that

everyone has a right to draw subsistence

from whatever nature offers2

. Property

rights are always combinations of public

and private3

. In private property, only an

individual and his family have rights to use

and get benefit. In CPR, access and utility

are not constrained to an individual and his

family but shared commonly by numerous

individuals.

Before getting details of the CPR ,

it’s indeed to know about the word

‘commons’, it represent all resources used

for human welfare, which are not

necessarily owned by an individual or

group of individual. CPR represents the

resources used commonly by a community.

Page 2 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 49

Other than the private holdings, most of the

resources in the villages have been

traditionally used as village common.

CPR is available for the common

purpose, to use those commons; rules are

framed by its stakeholder or by the

institution. Some of the resources only can

be used (e.g. buildings and roads) and in

some resources monetary benefits could be

achieved (e.g. fisheries and trees), usually,

monetary benefits only get from the natural

resources. It is commonly understood that

everyone have right to use but in practical it

is impossible, the common resources kept

for common won’t be used by the other

people. It seems to be universal but it is

not, the people who are not part of the

village are not allowed to use commons.

Right to access in the common properties is

a paradoxical. At this juncture, the

exclusive rights and the exclusion of

community must be studied to understand

the status of community in access to

commons.

Context

The CPR rights could be viewed

into two aspect, a) natural resources and b)

public properties. Many previous

researches have conducted study in many

issues related to CPR like efficient use of

CPR and its significant (Gordon, 1954;

Soctt, 1955; Hardin, 1968). Another school

of thoughts has conducted regarding the

Cooperative solution can overcome the

collective action problem and help achieve

efficiency in the use of such resources

(Gibbs and Bromley, 1989; Ostrom, 1990)

commons and importantly about the

dependent of the poor on CPRs (Jodha,

1985, 1986, 1995). Further, Jodha observed

that the rural poor are heavily dependent f

CPRs for their livelihood.

Their contribution to theory

building in the field of CPR is more worthy

but mostly they only concentrated on

natural resources, for example, Forest,

Fisheries, and Water Bodies etc. However,

Shyam Divan and Armin Rosencranz

(2001)4

classified Property into two generic

types: private and common. Within private

property, only an individual and his family

have legal rights to the benefits arising

from its resources and capital. Within

common property, access and utility are not

limited to an individual and his family but

are shared common by many people.

Commons can be further classified

into public properties like public transport,

entertainment places, service offices,

hospitals, etc. and natural resources like

nature forests, ponds, lakes, rivers and

streams, ores, minerals fuels, sand, mud,

limestone, and other types of stones and

salts. Moreover, previous researches have

detailed connotations about various aspects

of commons in the field of natural

resources but less on the public resources,

this propounded theoretical construction

not enough to address the problem in

access to CPR by its stakeholders

particularly in India. Keeping various

previous researches as a base, the following

detailed classification of commons was

made, they are produced below through

Page 3 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 05

June 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 50

chart:

Classification of Common Property Resources

Although everyone has equal right

to access these commons, Indian social set

up prohibit some section of the people from

the common access because of their caste

they belongs. People were divided into

various groups on the basis of caste, sub

caste, class and sub class. The ideology of

one group differs from the other one, even

though they are from the same religion. In

the villages, these groups live without

mixing with the other people. Every group

has own identity of customs, rituals and

practices which won’t be coincide with the

other one, with this way they are peculiar.

In this situation, this paper aims to find the

status of people access to the commons,

importantly about communities that have

exclusive right over the CPR and the

communities that are excluded in the CPRs.

Exclusive Rights and Exclusion in CPR

Exclusion is one of the most

complex issues nowadays that the country

faced with. In India, Caste identity is the

specific reasons for the exclusion by the

upper caste. Raising this issue would

unfold the conspiracy of the upper caste

rules of this county to which they may be

obliged to answer.5

It is necessary to toss a

few lights of the Dr. BR. Ambedkar

movement in access to the commons. He

launched the satyagraha for asserting the

Common Property Resources

(Non-Monetary benefits)

1.Temple

2.Government Water Tap & well

3. Kalam (place for drying grains)

4.Vandipettai (Car Shed)

5. Buriyal Ground

6.Village Road

7. Saavadis (Common place where

village people recreate)

8.Common play Ground

9.Hospitals, Anganwadis, Schools

and other government buildings

Common Property Resources

(Monetary benefits for

stakeholder)

1. Fishery from Canal, River,

Tank and other water reservoir

2. Village Vested Assets: Trees

and small forest for Lease

3. Village Markets