Page 1 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 01
February 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 37
Non-Governmental Organisations:
An Ubuntu Perspective
Kudzayi Savious Tarisayi
Foundation Training Institute, Zimbabwe
kudzayit@gmail.com
Abstract
This conceptual paper is a contribution
towards an appreciation of the African
philosophy of Hunhu/ Ubuntu to Non- Governmental Organisations (NGOs)
discourse. It seeks to demonstrate through
an interrogation of the dimensions of
Hunhu/ Ubuntu that within the African
culture there are still some values worth
promoting in general and in NGOs in
particular. The perspective that is proffered
is that the values of Hunhu/ Ubuntu are
quite affluent and if nurtured can contribute
momentously to NGOs.
Keywords: Hunhu/ Ubuntu, Non- governmental Organisations, African
philosophy,
1. INTRODUCTION
This conceptual paper is a contribution
towards an appreciation of the African
philosophy of Hunhu/ Ubuntu to Non- Governmental Organisations (NGOs)
theoretical framework. It seeks to
demonstrate, by means of an interrogation
of the dimensions of Hunhu/ Ubuntu that
within the African culture there are still
some values worth promoting in general
and in NGOs in particular. The perspective
to be proffered is that the values of Hunhu/
Ubuntu are quite affluent and if nurtured
can contribute momentously to NGOs.
African values as espoused by Hunhu/
Ubuntu could contribute considerable to
NGOs. The paper also argues that the
African philosophy of Hunhu/ Ubuntu can
be utilised by Non-Governmental
Organisations to overcome some of their
criticisms in terms of accountability.
2. SCHOLARSHIP ON NON- GOVERNMENTAL
ORGANISATIONS
NGOs have been referred to using various
terms in different quarters in different parts
of the world. Gupta (2011:01) states these
organisations have been, “Variously
referred to as Non-Profit Organizations
(NPO) and Voluntary Development
Organizations (VDOs), Non-Governmental
Organizations (NGOs) are non-profit, non- governmental organizations that an
individual joins by choice”. Furthermore,
Lewis (2007:01) augments, “While the
term ‘NGO’ is widely used, there are also
many other over-lapping terms used such as
‘non-profit’, ’voluntary’, and ‘civil society’
organisations”.
The term NGO encompasses a wide- ranging spectrum of organizations. Chand
(1991) opines that a broad and
multidimensional approach is required to
define and interpret the term NGO, because
NGOs today have been forging ahead as
development oriented institutions
embedded with the capability to function as
‘supplementary’ and ‘complementary’
Page 2 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 01
February 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 38
entities in addressing the diversified needs
of the community. Matanga (2010:114)
states, “The concept NGO has been widely
discussed. Some describe NGOs as part of
the ‘aid industry’, others as vehicles for
privatizing foreign assistance, others as part
of grassroots community organizing and yet
others as service contractors”. Whereas,
Brown (1998:21) states that the term NGO
covers everything from a small grassroots
traditional organization to the international
big organization, from rural to urban, with
varying and diversified objectives and
capacities which often make it difficult to
demarcate the boundary of its area of
functions and responsibilities.
Ben-Ner (1984) states that an NGO is an
organization whose purpose is to serve the
public rather than to earn a profit for its
owners. Therefore, it can be reasoned that
an NGO entails an organisation whose
obligation is to assist the people rather than
earn a return.
3. ORIGINS OF NGOs
There is a generally consensus in literature
on the origins of NGOs, which has been
traced back to the end of the Second World
War. Matanga (2010:114) expounds, “The
emergency of NGOs as major providers of
services and goods in addition to the
modern nation-state can arguably be traced
to the post-World War 11 period in
Europe”. The general rationale behind their
formation was the rehabilitation of war
devastated Europe socially, politically and
economically. In the beginning, their main
focus was the provision of welfarist in
nature as services such as psychological
counselling were offered to minimise social
trauma caused by the war. The end of the
post-war reconstruction in Europe, NGOs
shifted their focus through redefining their
objectives so as to justify their existence.
Hence, in the process they shifted
geographically to the developing countries,
and in addition to their immediate concerns
with relief and welfare, extended their
activities into the sector of development
and politics (Ndegwa, 1996:17).
4. NON-GOVERNMENTAL
ORGANISATION THEORATICAL
FRAMEWORK
4.1 Public goods theory
The formation of NGOs has been explained
using the public goods theory. The public
goods theory or the performance failure
theory articulates that NGOs exist to gratify
the residual unsatisfied demand for public
goods in society (Tvedt (1998). In addition,
Weisbrod (1977) argues that people
construct or form their alternative
organisations (that is people’s organisations
or NGOs) when the government or the
market cannot fulfil the demand of public
goods for all the people or serve all the
interests at least at the minimum level.
Therefore according to the public goods
theory it follows that where a significant
minority wants a specific kind or a level of
public goods for majority support is
lacking, the government cannot help, and
NGOs step in to fill the gap. The political
form of state failure creates a situation in
which NGOs emerge as innovative
responses to a novel problem, because of
their activities for experimentation and
flexibility.
4.2 Contract failure theory
Another influential and related theory is the
contract failure theory. This theory suggests
that NGOs arise where ordinary contractual
mechanisms fail to provide the public with
adequate means to assess the services firms
produce. Brown and Korton (1991:48)
argue that organizations might come into
existence to be remedies in the case of
‘market failure’ situations because markets
Page 3 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 01
February 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 39
tend to be ‘especially’ vulnerable to failure
in developing countries. Thus, when
contracts are difficult to define, people will
trust non-profit organizations or NGOs
more than commercial firms, because the
former appear to have fewer incentives to
take advantage of the consumers’
ignorance.
The theories of public goods and contract
failure have been utilised to explain the
emergence and existence of NGOs.
4.3 Criticism of NGOs
The operation of NGOs, has however
attracted criticism from various spheres
which is undermining their development,
advocacy and humanitarian activities in the
developing world. NGOs have a tendency
to concentrate on small scale projects with
a limited geographic spread. This approach
has allegedly been palliative bearing in
mind the omnipresence of poverty around
the world.
In addition, Chambers and Conway (1992)
argues that NGOs run their projects the
‘government style’ without giving ample
devotion to local conditions and interests
within communities. This follows from the
fact that NGOs have money but do not
know much about local conditions, culture,
past failures and the structure of the local
leadership. Furthermore, Moyo and
Makumbe (2000:20) criticize NGOs on the
grounds that they create a dependency
syndrome in their beneficiaries, whereby
beneficiaries become reliant on them to
such an extent they neglect their
livelihoods.
In addition, NGOs have been criticised for
the skewedness of their accountability.
NGO accountability is tilted upwards at the
expense of the beneficiaries and their own
goals and vision mainly due to their need to
lure and protect their funding (Tarisayi,
2012). Cronin and O’Regan (2002:24)
state, “Hulme and Edwards (1997) believe
that NGOs are getting closer to donors and
governments, and more distant from the
poor and the dispossessed, largely for the
fear of biting the hand that feeds them.”
NGOs in Zimbabwe in particular and
Africa in general seem to be more worried
about ensuring a steady flow of their
funding while sacrificing accountability
to their beneficiaries. There is a general
perception among NGOs that prioritizing
donors helps guarantee uninterrupted
donor support which can be viewed to
be critical to their own existence. Hence, it
can be argued that beneficiaries are not
being prioritized mainly due to the desire by
NGOs to safeguard their lifeline, which is
donor financial support. Therefore, it can be
revealed that NGOs have a glaring
weakness in terms of their accountability to
the beneficiaries.
5. HUNHU/ UBUNTU AFRICAN
PHILOSOPHY
The Hunhu/ Ubuntu African philosophy has
attracted scholarly attention from divergent
arenas of study. Due to this divergence it
has evidently been applied in a number of
spheres, most prominently in theology by
Archbishop Desmond Tutu (Tutu, 2000), in
Education and Educational Assessment by
Maunganidze et al (Maunganidze et al,
2011), as well as in management (Mbigi,
1997). In politics various African leaders
have pursued their versions of Ubuntu
African philosophy, namely Julius
“Mwalimu” Nyerere of Tanzania, Nelson
Mandela and Kenneth Kaunda.
Hunhu/Ubuntu as an ancient African
philosophy or worldview has largely been
regarded as deeply rooted in traditional
African life. Nussbaum (2003) views
Ubuntu as a philosophy and a frame of
mind prevalent among African people
