Page 1 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 08
September 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 145
Prevalence of Road Accident by Commercial Motorcycle
Operators in Benue State, Nigeria
Amine, J.D1. Abubakar, K2. and Clement Nkem, C1.
1Research Scholar, Department of Mechanical Engineering,
University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
2Research Scholar, Department of Science Policy and Innovation Studies (SPIS),
National Centre for Technology Management (NACETEM), North Central Zonal Office- Abuja, Nigeria
EMAIL: kz4tawa@gmail.com
Abstract
Four thousand eight hundred (4800)
questionnaires targeted at establishing the
frequency, causes and nature of injuries
sustained in road accidents by commercial
motorcycle operators within a period of five
(5) years (2006 - 2010) were administered on
operators, Motorcycle Hire Association
(MOHA), Federal Road Safety Corps (FRSC)
and the Transport Unit of the Nigerian Police
Force in four major commercial towns of
Benue State, Nigeria. Victims were also
interviewed on nature of injuries sustained.
Analysis of results revealed that, over
speeding accounted for 22.9 % of accidents.
Brake failure and non-compliant to traffic
rules had 17.8 % respectively, followed by
sudden stoppage by the law enforcement
agent 15.4 %, recklessness 14.2 % and poor
state of the road 11.8 %. Similarly, 38 %, 35
%, and 26 % of injuries recorded in Makurdi
were fractures, bruises, and head injuries
respectively. Oturkpo recorded 31 % bruises,
30 % fractures and 38 % head injuries. While
Gboko recorded 24 % bruises, 22 %
fractures and 53.8 % head injuries. Zaki- Biam had 25 % bruises, 27 % fractures, and
46.9 % head injuries. Conclusively Makurdi
had 646 accidents, followed by Oturkpo with
582, Gboko with 520 and Zaki-Biam with
330. These ranking can be justified by the
population of the commercial towns. There is
an urgent need to enforce the use safety
helmets and speed limits to reduce the
number of accidents and the resulting
injuries sustained by the users of this mode of
transport. This paper also proposed a
synergy of stakeholders aimed at manpower
development of riders in line with the
contemporary Science, Technology and
Innovations (STI) policy on Nigeria.
Key Words:
Prevalence, Accidents, Commercial,
Motorcycles, Operators
Introduction
Until about two decades ago,
commercial motorcycling, popularly known
as Okada was alien to Nigeria. Taxicabs and
minibuses were the common means of
commercial transportation. However,
individuals owned motorcycles and
governments at the three tiers gave
motorcycle loans to civil/public servants for
ease of mobility, but they were not used for
commercial purposes. The need to correct the
structural imbalances in the Nigerian
economic led to the introduction of the World
Bank mediated structural adjustment
Page 2 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 08
September 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 146
programme (SAP) in the mid-1980s. The
many negative fallouts of SAP in developing
countries that adopted the programme are
well documented in the literature. Negatives
of SAP includes the disappearance of the
middle income class, rapidly falling naira
exchange rate, government inability to
undertake new infrastructural projects and to
effectively maintain existing aging public
facilities. Consequently, middle-income- level vehicle owners could not replace them,
intra and intercity road networks became
rapidly degraded, and rural communities
gradually became inaccessible. Thus,
commercial motorcycling became a
necessity.
Commercial motorcycling has since
been accepted by most Nigerians and
gradually integrated into the urban life of the
country with tacit approval of government, as
they become new income generating avenues
to government, especially at the local level.
This mode of transportation has continued to
enjoy increasing acceptance relative to the
other modes (Ogunsanya and Galtima, 1993;
Adesanya, 1998; Layode, 1998; Fasakin,
1999). Commercial motorcycling (Owolabi,
1999) represents an estimated 25% of total
traffic in major roads within Southwestern
Nigeria. One thing that enhances the
sustainable operations of the commercial
motorcyclist is the relatively high level of
daily profits usually posted by operators
compared to daily operational cost (Layode,
1998).
Motorcycle, a two-wheeled light- weighted vehicle comprises a central frame
fabricated from tabular sectioned steel, to
which two pairs of cylindrical folks housing
hydraulically damped springs are attached to
bear the front and rear wheel, Olusanya and
William, (2003). The springs enhance
smooth riding and road holding qualities of
the motorcycles. The front pairing folks are
connected to a vertical rod, which bears
pivoted handle bars that are used to control
the direction and balance of the motorcycle.
In Section 2, we discussed relevant literature
that forms the foundation for the survey. The
methodology adopted is covered in Section 3.
The choice of Makurdi, Gkoko, Otukpo and
Zaki-biam of Benue State for this study was
based on the population density and
commercial activities in the towns warranting
the use of commercial motorcycle for
transportation. It is not as if accidents
involving motorcycles are particular to
Nigeria alone, but the prevalence and severity
differs from place to place, which is an issue
of concern and calls for an evidence-based
road safety policy measures deserving
holistic approach. Section 4 contains the
discussion of the outcome, followed by
conclusions as we recommended in Section
5.
CONCEPTUAL OUTLINE
Acceptability of the Motorcycle as a
Means of Transportation
The use of motorcycles for
commercial activities, with riders carrying
passengers for money has been on the
increase in different parts of Nigeria thus,
becoming a major mode of transportation
Solagberu, et al., (2006), despite the fact its
users are 20 times more venerable to crashes
than motor vehicles (Murgatroyd 2004,
WHO 2006). According to the World Health
Organization (WHO, 2006) motorcycle users
make up a high proportion of overall traffic
injuries and deaths, particularly in low- income and middle-income countries where
motorcycle ownership is high. The
acceptance of this mode of transportation is
due to the absence of a convenient,
inexpensive, and reliable alternative.
Coupled with their maneuverability during
traffic congestions, fuel efficiency, and door
step delivery for both passenger and cargo.
Owners of this business generate income,
Page 3 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 08
September 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 147
which sustains their families. The
motorcycles used for commercial activity are
often branded with names like “Hire” in
Benue, “Okada”, in the mid-west, “Achaba”
in the North, and “Going” in the East, and
“Akauke” in the South- South parts of
Nigeria. According to Olusanya, et al.,(2003)
commercial motorcycling has gained wide
spread acceptance, due in large part to the
economic down turn, which has placed the
purchase and maintenance of new cars and
mini buses beyond the grasp of most
Nigerians, other factors are its ability to
travel on roads which are unmotorable
footpaths in villages and urban slums. It is
inexpensive to maintain, environment
friendly, with minimum delay, as it requires
just a passenger or two in some situations.
Prevalence of Road Accident in Nigeria
from Motorcycles
Despite the numerous advantages
associated with the use of motorcycle for
commercial applications, the absence of any
substantial protective barriers between the
motorcycle rider and the road makes user
prone to serious injuries in the event of an
accident (Kadiyali, 1982). In most urban
centers in Nigeria, the high rate of motorcycle
accident is a source of worry to both the
society and government agencies charged
with the responsibility of promoting safety on
Nigeria roads. Emejulu, et al., (2009)
reported in a survey that of 1055
neurosurgical cases attended to in a center in
the period under study about 748 had trauma,
road traffic accidents accounted for 537 (71.8
%), while 367 (68.3 %) were from
motorcycles. The effect of most of the
accidents range from incapacitation of
victims, damage to property to loss of lives.
Ngim, et al., (2008) in another study
discovered that in Calabar, motorcycle riders
caused about 52.8 % of accidents.
In the United States, the death rate per
registered motorcycle is every 59 per 100,
000 that is approximately three times the
death rate per registered passenger car of 17
per 100, 000 (Preusser, et al., 1995). Besides
the higher death rate, motorcyclists are likely
to be injured when involved in an accident.
Horswill and Helman (2001) considered
about 399 injury accidents in the UK in which
either a motorcycle or a car was involved in a
head-on-collision with the same type of
object in the same way. About 97 % of
motorcyclists were injured or killed in these
collisions compared with 50.5 % of car
drivers. This makes it clear that motorcyclists
are more susceptible to injury and death than
car drivers in support of the need for safety
dressing to cushion the effect in the case of
an accident.
Bolade (1991), and O’flaherty
(1999), identified and grouped the causes of
road accidents into human, vehicular and
roads/environmental factors. Accidents may
be classified as fatal or serious. An accident
involving loss of human life within 30 days
of occurrence or from injuries sustained
directly from the accidents is termed fatal. On
another hand, an accident is termed serious if
someone is wounded and hospitalized, but
with higher chances of survival. In a case
there is no injury to someone but there is
damage to vehicles or property, such accident
is termed minor. Olusanya, et al., (2003)
attributed commercial motorcycle accidents
in Nigeria to speed, failure to stop at
junctions entering major roads, refusal to
wear protective clothing like helmets, gloves
and boots, overloading and failure to obey
appropriate road signals. The commercial
motorcycle riders are usually involved in all
aforementioned accidents.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Two thousand and seventy eight (2078)
questionnaires of the four thousand eight
