Page 1 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 345
Flooding and Women with Disabilities in the Tokwe- Mukosi Basin, Zimbabwe.
Kudzayi Savious Tarisayi
Foundation Training Institute, Zimbabwe
kudzayit@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The paper explores the impact of floods on
women with disabilities in the Tokwe- Mukosi basin, Zimbabwe. It discusses the
impact of flooding on the livelihoods of
women with disabilities as well as the
challenges they are facing in the course of
their relocation. The research employed
purposive sampling. Data was gathered
through key informant interviews and
observation in the Tokwe-Mukosi basin,
transit camps and the Nuanetsi relocation
site. Research revealed that women with
disabilities were adversely impacted by the
floods. Their livelihood assets were
destroyed and environmental and access
barriers became more pronounced. The
research also revealed that the relocation
exercise was not all-encompassing thus,
further compounded the situation for
women with disabilities. The paper
concludes that there is a need for the
government of Zimbabwe to improve
disaster management by taking on board
representatives of people with disabilities.
Keywords: women with disabilities,
floods, livelihoods, Tokwe-Mukosi basin,
Zimbabwe
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This study analysed the impact of flooding
on women with disabilities in the Tokwe- Mukosi basin. Tarisayi (2014:02) states,
“The heavy rains and subsequent floods
adversely affected twelve villages,
explicitly Chekai, Jahwa, Zifunzi,
Mharadzano, Chikandigwa and Vhomo in
Nemauzhe communal lands; and Tagwirei,
Ndove, Matandizvo, Chikosi, Mashenjere
and Nongera in Neruvanga communal
lands”[1]. Various studies have been
carried out on the impacts of floods on
livelihoods around the world, in Ghana
(Fredrick et al, 2010) [2], in India (Afro,
2009) [3] and in Zimbabwe (Tarisayi, 2014)
[1], however there is an apparent paucity of
research on the impact of flooding on
women with disabilities. Grech (2009)
argues, “Disability still remains
overwhelming marginalised at mainstream
developmental research, institutional,
policy and programme levels” [4].
Ramifications of flooding on women with
disabilities remains a terra incognita for
researchers especially in developing
countries. Hence, this study interrogated the
impact of floods on women with disabilities
referred to as the “forgotten tribe” by
Choruma (2007) [5]. There is an apparent
dearth of literature on issues pertaining to
women with disabilities. Charowa (2005)
[6] states that the disabled people are so
excluded as not to be considered even
worthy of research as they are among the
most severely marginalised people in the
world.
Page 2 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 346
1.1 The Tokwe-Mukosi Basin
Tokwe-Mukosi dam is located in the semi- arid district of Chivi, Masvingo province in
Zimbabwe. The area in January/ February
2014 received 850 mm of rainfall which is
double its usual rainfall. Thus, these heavy
rains and the subsequent partial collapse of
the Tokwe-Mukosi wall resulted in
flooding. The floods affected twelve
villages within the Tokwe-Mukosi basin
and the President of Zimbabwe declared a
state of disaster in the Tokwe-Mukosi area.
2.0 Review of related literature
2.1 Defining disability
Disability has been variously defined by
scholars, development agencies,
governments and activists around the
world. The World Health Organisation
utilizes the definition that, “any restriction
or lack of ability to perform an activity in a
manner or within a range considered
normal for a human being” (WHO, 1996)
[7]. In addition, a disability maybe physical,
cognitive, sensory, emotional,
developmental, or some combination of
these (Schechter and Feldman, 2010) [8]. A
more comprehensive definition is proffered
by Hardman, Egen and Wolf (1993:484) [9]
as, “Condition characterised by loss of
physical functioning or difficulty in
learning and social adjustment that
significantly interferes with normal growth
and development, for example loss of
sight”. The authors further highlight that
disability is a bit different from handicap
and impairment. Thus, their explanation
denotes that handicap is a limitation
imposed on the individual by
environmental demands for example a
wheel chair user faces a handicap in
buildings without ramps.The Disabled
Persons Act of Zimbabwe defines a
disabled person as,
a person with a physical, mental or
sensory disability, including a
visual, hearing or speech functional
disability, which gives rise to
physical, cultural or social barriers
inhibiting him from participating at
an equal level with other members
of society in activities, undertakings
or fields of employment that are
open to other members of society
(Government of Zimbabwe, 1996)
[10]
The study considered the impact of
flooding and the subsequent evacuations on
women with all types of disabilities
regardless of severity.
2.2 Incidence of disability
People with disabilities comprise
approximately 10 % of the world’s
population, 75 % of whom live in
developing countries and constitute one of
the most poor, marginalised and socially
excluded groups in society (DFID,
2005)[11]. However, Choruma (2007) [5]
argues that there disparities on the statistics
on the prevalence of disabilities in
Zimbabwe. Thus, there are few sources of
reliable statistics regarding prevalence of
disabilities and these can also be argued to
be inconsistent. Choruma (2007)[5] states
that Zimbabwe’s Housing and Population
Census, conducted in 2002, estimated a
prevalence rate of 2,9 %, with 45 % being
male and 55 % being female. Hence, this
study focuses its attention on the “forgotten
tribe” which constitutes 55 % of the total
population of people with disabilities.
2.3 Human Rights and
Disabilities
The legal enactments on the rights of people
with disabilities emanate from the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights
(1948) [12]. The UDHR entails that all
human beings are born free and equal in
Page 3 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 347
dignity and rights. Everyone, including
women with disabilities are entitled to all
the rights and freedoms set forth in this
declaration without distinction of any kind.
In addition, The United Nations General
Objectives declared the recognition of
people with disabilities in the Decade of
Disabled People 1983-1992.
In Zimbabwe, rights of women with
disabilities are supported by the Disabled
Persons Act of Zimbabwe which calls for
non-discrimination on the basis of
disability. However, Manombe-Ncube
(2001) [13] argues that there are no specific
policies in place to ensure the
implementation of the Act or the need to
intensify programmes that uplift the status
of women with disabilities in particular.
Thus, women with disabilities are assumed
to be participating without having strategies
in place to remove barriers that hinder full
participation. Choruma (2007) [5] argues
that legislation makes no provision for
affirmative action or positive
discrimination and policies remain vague or
unenforced, professionals in health and
education, employers and disabled people
themselves remain largely unaware of what
those are.
2.4 Women with disabilities
Charowa (2005) [6] posits that despite their
significant numbers, women with
disabilities especially in developing nations
remain hidden and silent, their concerns and
rights overlooked. A study conducted by
the National Societies for the Care of the
Handicapped Association (2005) found out
that women with disabilities are more likely
than others to be extremely poor or
destitute, illiterate, without employment
and often undeserved due to lack of access
to public services. Furthermore, (Choruma
2007:14)[5] states that disabled women are
disempowered by both their gender and
their disability in terms of their ability to
influence decisions that affect them. Thus,
this entails that women with disabilities are
faced with double barrelled challenges in
life as a result of their gender and
disabilities. Therefore, it can be argued that
gender discrimination compounds the
discernment of women with disabilities as
they are already discriminated on the basis
of their disability. In addition, Rust and
Matts (2007) [14] argue that social and
economic discrimination, architectural,
transportation, institutional and policy
barriers continue to prevent disabled people
from accessing any opportunities.
Furthermore, Lang and Charova (2007:01)
[15] state that disabled people encounter
multiple attitudinal, environmental and
institutional barriers that militate against
their effective inclusion within Zimbabwe
society.
2.5 Floods
Floods are phenomena that has been widely
researched and covered by the media.
Floods by nature are complex events caused
by a range of human vulnerabilities,
inappropriate development planning and
climate variability (ADPC, 2005) [16].
While, The Fourth Assessment Report
(2007) [16] of the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change (IPCC) predicts that
heavy precipitation events, which are very
likely to increase in frequency, will
augment flood risk. Flooding at an
unexpected scale (damaging flood) and
with excessive frequency causes damage to
life, livelihoods and the environment.
3.0 Purpose and Significance of the study
It is a paradox that whilst there has been a
growing body pertaining to gender,
certainly not enough has been reported on
women with disabilities. Moreso, there is
an apparent paucity of research pertaining
to ramification of disasters such as floods
