Page 1 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 297
A Bourdieu Perspective of the Chingwizi Transit
Camp, Zimbabwe.
Kudzayi S. Tarisayi
Foundation Training Institute, Zimbabwe
Abstract
This paper utilizes French sociologist
Pierre Bourdieu’s conceptualization of
social capital to interrogate the social
capital of the Tokwe-Mukosi flood
survivors relocated at Chingwizi transit
camp in Mwenezi, Zimbabwe. The Tokwe- Mukosi floods and the subsequent
relocation of flood victims to Chingwizi,
Chisase and Masangula have been widely
covered in journalistic reports and recently
in scholarly studies. However, most
research on floods around the world in
general and the Tokwe-Mukosi floods in
particular focusses on property loss,
livelihoods implications, human rights
issues and government assistance to flood
victims or lack thereof. Thus, there is an
apparent research gap on the sociological
perspective to the implications of flooding
on communities. This present study utilizes
a case study approach and purposive
sampling to bring to the fore the social
capital implications of forced relations of
the Tokwe-Mukosi flood victims. The study
concludes that social capital at Chingwizi
transit camp was negatively affected at the
individual level but at the community level
here was an apparent increase in social
capital.
Key words: Social capital, floods,
Chingwizi transit camp, Tokwe-Mukosi,
Zimbabwe.
Introduction
This paper interrogates the social capital of
the Tokwe-Mukosi flood survivors
relocated at Chingwizi transit camp in
Mwenezi, Zimbabwe. The Tokwe-Mukosi
floods and the subsequent relocation of
flood victims to Chingwizi, Chisase and
Masangula have been widely covered in
journalistic reports and recently in scholarly
studies. However, most research on floods
around the world in general and the Tokwe- Mukosi floods in particular focusses on
property losses, livelihoods implications,
human rights issues and government
assistance to flood victims or lack thereof.
Thus, there is an apparent dearth in
literature on the sociological perspective to
the implications of flooding on
communities. A study by Tarisayi (2014)
reveals that the Tokwe-Mukosi floods
adversely affected twelve villages in
Masvingo province, specifically Chekai,
Jahwa, Zifunzi, Mharadzano, Chkandigwa
and Vhomo in Nemauzhe communal lands;
and Tagwirei, Ndove, Matandizvo,
Chikosi, Mashenjere and Nongera in
Neruvanga communal lands. The affected
villagers were subsequently relocated to
Chingwizi, Chisase and Masangula by the
government. An analysis of contemporary
literature reveals that other perspectives to
the Tokwe-Mukosi floods have been
proffered. However, researchers have not
explored the social capital perspective of
flood victims in general and of the Tolwe-
Page 2 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 298
Mukosi flood victims in particular.
Bourdieu (1986:244) reasons, “It is in fact
impossible to account for the structure and
functioning of the social world unless one
reintroduces capital in all its forms and not
solely in the one form recognized by
economic theory”. Thus, to get a complete
depiction of the Tokwe-Mukosi flood
victims it is imperative that other forms of
capital be reintroduced to the discourse.
These capitals include are not confined to
economic capital but include social capital
and natural capital. Hence, this paper
deviates from the economic theory and
incorporates the social capital perspective
into the debate on the implications of the
Tokwe-Mukosi floods and the subsequent
relocation of victims.
Chingwizi Transit Camp
Chingwizi transit camp was located in
Mwenezi district, Masvingo province in
Zimbabwe. Chakanyuka (2014) states that
more than 3000 families were relocated to
Chingwizi transit camp about 200 km
South-East of Masvingo town in early
February 2014 after they were displaced by
floods. The transit camp was created to
temporarily accommodate families affected
by the floods while permanent resettlement
plots were being arranged by the
government. According to the District
Administrator for Mwenezi district the
population at the camp increased from the
initially expected 2, 514 households to
about 3, 338 households. (OCHA
Zimbabwe, 2014).
Social Capital
This study is guided by the social capital
theory as propounded by Pierre Bourdieu,
Coleman and Putnam. Various perspective
to the interrogation of the concept of social
capital have been availed in different
disciplines. This study traces the concept to
the work of Pierre Bourdieu, contributions
by James Coleman and Robert Putnam. The
original theoretical development of the
concept was by the French sociologist
Pierre Bourdieu (1980) but contributions by
American sociologist James Coleman
(1993) and later on Robert Putnam (1993)
expanded the concept. Putnam (2002)
argues that one of the strengths of the social
capital concept is its use in the fields of
economics, public health, urban planning,
criminology, architecture, and social
psychology, other than political science and
sociology where it originated. Therefore,
due to its wide usage in different fields
diverse conceptualizations are bound to
reveal themselves to a greater extent. A
comparative exploration reveals that there
is no apparent consensus on the definition
of social capital. Bourdieu (1985:248)
defines the concept as “the aggregate of the
actual or potential resources which are
linked to possession of a durable network of
more or less institutionalized relationships
of mutual acquaintance or recognition”.
Consequently, it follows according to this
definition that people build and invest in
relations for the benefits that they would
bring later in their lives. Therefore, in
Bourdieu’s conceptualization social capital,
economic capital and natural capital are all
part of the social order.
Another perspective is submitted by
Coleman who defines social capital as:
“the set of resources that inhere in
family relations and in community
Page 3 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 09
October 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 299
social organisations and that are
useful of the cognitive or social
development of a child or young
person. These resources differ for
different persons and can constitute
an important advantage for children
and adolescents in the development
of their human capital” (Coleman
1994: 300).
This conceptualization according to
Coleman’s submission entails that social
capital is important as a resource not only
to acquire status or credentials (as seen by
Bourdieu), but also in the enhancement of
people’s human capital. Thus, for Coleman,
this is facilitated within the family and as
such the family becomes the “archetypal
cradle of social capital” (Field 2008: 29). In
addition, community ties are significant for
the benefits they yielded to individuals
according to Coleman.
Another perspective to social capital is
proffered by Robert D. Putnam in his
publication: ‘Bowling Alone’. Putnam
(2000:19) defines social capital as the
“connections among individuals – social
networks and the norms of reciprocity and
trustworthiness that arise from them”.
According to Putnam (2000), social capital
includes bonding capital and bridging
capital. “Bonding occurs when you are
socializing with people who are like you;
same age, same race, same religion and so
on. Bridging is what you do when you make
friends with people who are not like you”.
Thus, Putnam elaborates that there are two
forms of social capital, which are bonding
and bridging social capital. In addition,
Putnam (1995) avails a conceptual
expansion of social capital by widening the
unit of analysis from the individual, as
espoused by Bourdieu and Coleman, to the
whole community and country. Therefore
according to Putnam (1995) the whole
community also possessed social capital.
Hence, this study adopts two units of
analysis, namely the individual as
championed by Bourdieu and Coleman as
well as the community as expatiated by
Putnam.
Portes (1998:03) states, “the consensus is
growing in the literature that social capital
stands for the ability of actors to secure
benefits by virtue of memberships in social
networks or other social structures”.
Whereas, a simply definition is proclaimed
by Fukuyama (1999:16), “Social capital
can be defined simply as a set of informal
values or norms shared among members of
a group that permit cooperation among
them”. Whereas, Bankston and Zhou
(2002:287) state, “Social capital is a
‘metaphorical construction’ which does not
consist of resources that are held by
individuals or by groups but of processes of
social interaction leading to constructive
outcomes”. Thus, this therefore reveals a
controversy in whether social capital is a
process or resource like other capitals such
as financial or human capital. This
controversy emanates from the use of the
word ‘capital’ in social capital which
usually denotes a quantifiable resource.
Bankston and Zhou (2002:286) further
argue that social capital is not quantifiable
and hence availing a difference between
social capital and human capital or financial
capital.
