Page 1 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 290

Tokwe-Mukosi Floods: A Conundrum of Perspectuves

Kudzayi Savious Tarisayi

Foundation Training Institute, Zimbabwe

kudzayit@gmail.com

Abstract

The events that followed the Tokwe-Mukosi

floods and the resultant displacements have

been subjected to a multiplicity of analysis.

The analysis has led to the emergency of an

assortment of narratives ranging from the

livelihoods perspective, internal

displacement perspective, conspiracy

perspective, political perspective and the

legal perspective. This conceptual paper

offers a consolidated analysis of these

various perspectives on the Tokwe-Mukosi

floods. This article is based on secondary

data analysis on research by various

scholars on the Tokwe_Mukosi floods and

their impact. It concludes that

displacements can be studied and analysed

from various perspectives as revealed by

the plethora of narratives on the Tokwe- Mukosi floods and subsequent

displacements.

Key Words: Tokwe-Mukosi, livelihoods

perspective, internal displacement

perspective, conspiracy perspective,

political perspective, legal perspective

1.0 Introduction

The discourse on internal displacement in

general and the Tokwe Mukosi floods and

subsequent relocations to Chingwizi has

drawn attention from various scholars and

resultantly a multiplicity of perspectives

have emerged. Various and more often than

not conflicting narratives have emerged

analysing the Tokwe Mukosi floods and the

eventual relocation to Chingwizi. The

Tokwe Mukosi floods have been

interrogated from the livelihoods

perspective (Tarisayi, 2014; Mutangi &

Mutari, 2014; Rusvingo, 2014); the legal

perspective (Nyamafufu, 2014); the

conspiracy perspective (Mugabe, 2014) and

the political perspective (Tarisayi, 2015;

Mtimba, 2014) as well as introduce the

Development-Induced Displacement and

Resettlement (DIDR) perspective to the

Tokwe-Mukosi phenomena. Thus, this

paper seeks to interrogate these various

perspectives that have been proffered and

come up with a consolidated narrative on

the Tokwe Mukosi floods.

2.0 Background

Tokwe-Mukosi dam is in Masvingo

Province at the boundary of Chivi and

Masvingo Rural districts. In January- February 2014, Zimbabwe’s enormous

Tokwe-Mukosi Dam basin flooded

following higher than normal rains.

Tarisayi (2014:02) states, “The heavy rains

and subsequent floods adversely affected

twelve villages, explicitly Chekai, Jahwa,

Zifunzi, Mharadzano, Chkandigwa and

Vhomo in Nemauzhe communal lands; and

Tagwirei, Ndove, Matandizvo, Chikosi,

Mashenjere and Nongera in Neruvanga

communal lands”.The Tokwe Mukosi

floods were declared a national disaster by

the President of Zimbabwe, His Excelency

Robert Mugabe in February 2014. Human

Rights Watch (2015:01) states, “President

Page 2 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 291

Robert Mugabe immediately declared the

floods a national disaster and appealed to

the international community for US$20

million to help relocate and provide

humanitarian assistance to those affected”.

The victims of the 20 000 Tokwe Mukosi

floods were relocated by the Zimbabwe

National Army and the Civil Protection

Unit (CPU) to Chingwizi in Mwenezi

district.

2.0 Emerging Perspectives

2.1 The Livelihoods Perspective

The main perspective that has been most

pursued in relation to the Tokwe Mukosi

floods pertains to the implications of the

floods on the livelihoods of the internally

displaced people. Jayaratney (2007) vies

livelihoods as entailing basically the

capabilities, assets and activities required

for living. Livelihoods can be classified in

terms of individual and community;

individual livelihoods include jobs, works

or sources of income, activities that provide

income to live on (such as farming; fishing

and trading) (Jayaratney, 2007). While,

Scoones (1998) avers that livelihoods can

be exposed to various stresses, risks and

shocks such as drought which can increase

vulnerability context of livelihoods. It

follows that the livelihoods of the internally

displaced people relocated at Chingwiza

have been exposed to the shock of floods

which has led to their vulnerability.

The livelihoods perspective reveals that the

livelihoods of the people of the Tokwe

Mukosi were adversely affected by the

floods (Tarisayi, 2014; Rusvingo, 2014;

Mutangi & Mutari, 2014). Among the

livelihoods that were affected include

subsistence farming, market gardening, art

and craft as well as petty trade. Thus

literature reveals that while most

livelihoods were affected negatively

remittances have actually increased as the

people of Tokwe-Mukosi have increasingly

become dependent on external support for

sustenance. Hence, it can be concluded

within the livelihoods perspective that the

livelihoods of the people were negatively

implicated. However, it can be revealed that

the livelihoods perspective falls short of

exposing the effects of the losses incurred

during the course of relocation.

2.2 Internal Displacement Perspective

The other alternative perspective to the

Tokwe-Mukosi floods and subsequent

relocation to Chingwizi is the internal

displacement perspective. The construction

of dams has led to involuntary displacement

and resettlement of an estimated 40 to 80

million people across the world (Robinson,

2003). The floods in February 2014 in

Tokwe Mukosi resulted in about 20 000

people being displaced from their homes

((Nyamafufu, 2014). An internally

displaced persons (IDP) according to the

Kampala Convention is a person forced to

flee or to leave their homes/ place of

residence (Iwabukuna, 2011). Thus

according people displaced by the Tokwe- Mukosi floods can be classified as IDPs.

Internal displacement does not occur as a

result of individual ‘choice per se and

constitutes a situation of non-freedom (in

terms of agency and opportunity as IDPs

have “been forced or obliged to flee or to

leave their homes”) (UNOCHA, 2004:01).

Cernea (1997; 2003) point out that DIDR

negatively impacts on the living standards

Page 3 of 7

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 292

and livelihood outcomes of displaced

communities. In addition, it can be revealed

within this perspective that the most

vulnerable in society such as the disabled,

the elderly and children are the most

affected by DIDR leading to their

impoverishment (Cernea, 2003). While,

Maldonado (2003) argues that effects of

forced displacement are not confined to just

the physical relocation of people, it also

impacts on people’s lives economically,

physically, culturally and socially leading

to their impoverishment. Therefore, it can

be reasoned within this perspective that

DIDR due to the construction of the Tokwe- Mukosi dam has had wide ranging impacts,

cutting across all spheres of life of the

people. Robinson (2003:06) states,

“Impoverishment and disempowerment

have rather been the rule than the exception

with resettled people due to development

projects”. This observation can be utilised

to explain the impoverishment and

disempowerment incurred by the people of

Tokwe-Mukosi due to their displacement.

Michael Cernea constructed a model,

known as the Impoverishment Risks and

Reconstruction (IRR) model to analyse the

effects of involuntary displacement that

came as a result of major development

projects (Robinson, 2003). Cernea’s model

proposes that “the onset of impoverishment

can be represented through a model of eight

interlinked potential risks to displacement”

(Cernea, 2003). These are landlessness,

homelessness, marginalisation, food

insecurity, increased morbidity and

mortality, loss of access to common

property and social disintegration. In

addition, as asserted by Cernea (as cited in

Turton, 2009:29), “some people enjoy the

gains of development, while others bear its

pains”. Hence, while communities around

Tokwe-Mukosi dam and investors are

going to enjoy the gains of the construction

of the dam, the IDPs are bearing the pains

due to displacement. Thus, based on

Cernea’s model it can be revealed that the

people of Tokwe-Mukosi have been impact

in the eight dimensions due to the

displacement.

2.3 The Legal Perspective

Another emerging narrative on the Tokwe- Mukosi floods can be reffered to as the legal

perspective. The legal perspective seeks to

interrogate the Tokwe-Mukosi phenomena

through an assessment of Zimbabwe’s

adherence to various international

conventions such as the African Union’s

Convention on the protection and assistance

of internally displaced persons on the

protection and assistance of internally

displaced persons. Adebe (2011) avers that

the African Convention on the protection

and assistance of internally displaced

persons also known as the Kampala

Convention, due to an increase in the

number of internally displaced persons

(IDPs) in Africa. Giustiniani (2012) puts

the number of IDPs around the world at 26

million of which 11 million in Africa.

Within the legal perspective, Nyamafufu

(2014) reveals that the Government of

Zimbabwe (GoZ) managed to adhere to

some of the principles of the Kampala

Convention such as Article 9 (2) (d) on the

movement of IDPs to safe areas and the

provision of basic services that include

schools and health facilities for people at