Page 1 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 127

Modeling Urban Road Maintenance Priority Rating Using

Multi Criteria Decision Making With Fuzzy Logic Approach

(Case Study on Arterial Roads in Mamminasata, Indonesia)

M. Asad Abdurrahman1, Lawalenna Samang2, Sakti A. Adisasmita2, M. Isran Ramli3

1 Doctoral Student, Civil Engineering Department, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia

2 Professor, Civil Engineering Department, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia

3 Associate Professor, Civil Engineering Department, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia

ABSTRACT

Road pavement will degrade along with its

age; thus, preservation program should be

carried out to maintain its service level.

Nevertheless, there is always a gap between

allocated budget and maintenance cost. In

order to spend the available budget

optimally, it is necessary to develop a

ranking procedure to optimize this limited

fund. Recent procedure by the Department

of Public Works has a weakness. This paper

offers an alternative assessment framework

which enables to take a number of technical

and non-technical aspects into

consideration. Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy

Process (FAHP) is utilized in this

framework. Five artery roads are evaluated

to demonstrate the proposed method.

Finally, it is concluded that the proposed

methodology makes the decision process

more rational.

KEYWORDS:

Priority; rank; road; maintenance; fuzzy

AHP

INTRODUCTION

Due to the limited allocated budget in road

maintenance program, it is necessary to

develop a comprehensive prioritization

procedure to determine roads with higher

priority first, in order to fulfill the needs in

pavements preservation schedule. Recent

priority procedure offered by the

Department of Public Works (2005) has a

weakness where this procedure is only

consider technical aspects such as traffic and

pavement condition. In addition, several

researches offer the method for prioritizing

road maintenance such as Sembiring (2008)

and Moazami (2011). However, these

procedures also unable to take non-technical

factors into consideration.

This paper proposes a systematic assessment

procedure which enables to take a number of

technical and non-technical aspects into

consideration. Rating approach in Fuzzy

Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) is used.

Prioritization is modeled on the basis of

important criterions such as maintenance

program (MAINT), traffic (TRAF), social

and economic impact (SOCEC), and land

zone (ZONE). Pairwise comparisons

between criterions and sub-criterions are

gained by capturing the experts’ opinions

towards the importance of aspects which

affecting the maintenance priority.

The main scope of this study is modeling

and developing a comprehensive technique

to analyze the maintenance priority rating of

road section based on the existing conditions

(MAINT, TRAF, SOCEC and ZONE). To

demonstrate the capability and effectiveness

of the proposed model, five artery road in

Makassar city is implemented as case study.

METHODOLOGY

Page 2 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 128

Modeling road maintenance priority rating

can be considered as a multiple criteria

decision making (MCDM) problems which

involve a set of alternatives that are

evaluated on the basis of conflicting and

incommensurate criterion and sub-criterions.

The common solution to a multi-criteria

problem is to segregate the problem into a

number of smaller sub-problems and solve

them individually.

The Simple Multi-Attribute Rating

Technique (SMART) is a method that

dealing with the multi-objectives problems.

The main strength of this technique is

simplicity. However, the consequence of its

simplicity is that the method unable to

capture all the detail and complexities of the

real problem (Goodwin, 2004). ELimination

Et Choix Traduisant la REalité (ELimination

and Choice Expressing REality)

(ELECTRE) is a different technique to

evaluate decision options which widely

applied for many MCDM problems.

However, this technique unable to provide a

procedure of obtaining weights and score,

(Watson, 1987). Alternatively, the most

known methods on MCDM is Analytical

Hierarchy Process (AHP) which especially

is based on pairwise comparisons on a ratio

scale (Saaty, 2001).

However, the main weakness of AHP is

unable to accommodate uncertainty in the

decision making process. Critics claim that

it is demanding to ask experts’ opinion to

present their judgments as a discrete

numerical value in the pairwise comparison

matrices. Therefore, fuzzy logic approach is

suggested to overcome the inability of AHP

to handle uncertainties.

The case study was conducted in five artery

roads which funded by state government as

shown in table 1. The roads are located in

Makassar city.

Table 1: Location of case study

Code Street Name

Road A Perintis Kemerdekaan

Road B Achmad Yani

Road C Nusantara

Road D Veteran Selatan

Road E Sultan Alauddin

This decision hierarchy takes into account a

number of tangible and intangible aspects in.

These aspects and its hierarchy were

identified by repetitively discussing, and

consulting with a number of professional

and government staffs. They included

officials from the Public Works Department,

and Regional Planning Development

Agency. Four criterions with their sub- systems have been identified for the model

as listed below:

A. Traffic (TRAFF)

A.1. Volume (passenger car unit/day)

A.2. Velocity (km/hour)

B. Maintenance program (MAINT)

B.1. Routine maintenance

B.2. Periodic maintenance

B.3. Reconstruction

C. Social and Economic impact (SOCEC)

C.1. Fair distribution of budget

C.2. Accessibilities

D. Land zone (ZONE)

D.1. Industrial

D.2. Commercial/Social

D.3. Residential

Traffic information was acquired through

survey based on the procedure in Indonesian

Road Capacity Manual 1997. Maintenance

program is determined by visual survey

based on the procedure in Manual of Road

Maintenance Program 1990. Social and

economic impact criterion is expressed by

fair distribution of budget aspect which is

calculated by its fund allocated. For

instance, if maintenance budget for road A is

$X in the previous year; thus, fair-budget

distribution value is 1/X. Accessibilities is

Page 3 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 01 Issue 09

October 2015

Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 129

defined by road’s connectivity to the outer

region. Land zone is obtained from

observation to determine the ratio of

commercial/social, residential, and industrial

zone alongside the road.

Fig 1: Hierarchy of goals, criterions, and

alternatives

FUZZY NUMBERS AND FAHP

This study utilizes Triangular Fuzzy

Numbers (TFN). A Triangular Fuzzy

Numbers à is defined by a triplet (l, m, u)

and its membership function μA(x) can be

defined by equation as follows:

1

1

1 2

2 1

3

2 3

3 2

3

0 ,

,

( )

,

0 ,

A

x a

x a

a x a

a a

x

a x

a x a

a a

x a

 

    

 

     

  

(1)

where x is the mean value of A and l, m, u

are real numbers. Define two TFNs à and B̃

by the triplets A = (a1, a2, a3) and B = (b1, b2,

b3) then:

A B  1 2 3 1 2 3   ( , , ) ( , , ) a a a b b b 1 1 2 2 3 3  ( , , ) a b a b a b A B  1 2 3 1 2 3   ( , , ) ( , , ) a a a b b b 1 1 2 2 3 3     ( , , ) a b a b a b 1 1

1 2 3

3 2 1

1 1 1 A a a a ( , , ) ( , , )

a a a

 

 

Fig 2: Triangular Fuzzy Number (TFN) Ã

This study adopts modified synthetic extent

FAHP (Chang, 1996). The advantage of this

FAHP method is that it allows for

incompleteness of the pairwise comparison.

This permission for incompleteness

indicates its suitability in decision problems

where uncertainty sometimes exists in the

process of decision making.

In order to construct pairwise comparison of

alternatives under each criterion, a triangular

fuzzy comparison matrix à = {ãij} is

defined as follows:

12 13 1

1

12 2

1

13

1 1

1 2

(1,1,1)

(1,1,1) ....

.... (1,1,1) ....

.... (1,1,1)

n

n

n n

a a a

a a

A

a

a a

 

 (2)

where ãij = (lij, mij, uij) and aij

−1 =

(1/uji, 1/mji, 1/lji) for i,j = (1,2, ... , n)

Table 2 shows the fuzzy scale that is used

for pairwise comparison.

Table 2: Fuzzy scale for pairwise comparison

Scale Fuzzy

Number Domain Triangular

Fuzzy

Maintenance Priority Maintenance Program Land Zone Social & Eco. impact Traffic B1 B3

B2 A1 A2 C1 C3

C2 D1 D2 Road A Road B Road C Road D Road E

( ) A  x

a1 0

1

x A

a2 a3