Page 1 of 58
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 385
Leadership Behaviour, Organisational Commitment, Job
Satisfaction and Service Quality in Commercial Banks in
Uganda: A Case of Kampala District
Bosco mutambira
Research assistant Makerere University College of agriculture and environmental science
Department of agribusiness management
Email: bmutambira@gmail.com
Abstract
The purpose of the study was to establish the relationship between leadership behaviour,
organizational commitment, job satisfaction and service quality. The study was prompted by
reports of increased customer dissatisfaction and complaints thought to be a result of
perceived poor service quality in commercial banks.
Results revealed positive and significant relationships between leadership behaviour and
service quality, leadership behaviour and organizational commitment, leadership behaviour and
job satisfaction, organizational commitment and service quality, job satisfaction and service
quality which implies that when one variable is improved it leads to improvement of the other.
In addition, leadership behaviour is a better predictor of service quality followed by
organizational commitment which implies that to improve on service quality; emphasis
should be put on improvement of leadership behaviour followed by organizational commitment.
Introduction
Leadership is widely recognised as a critical factor in the success or failure of an
organization (Hasbullah, 2008). Leadership enables an organisation to translate its potential
for good performance into productivity (Samuel, 2005). Managers can no longer rely on
their hierarchical positions to attain organisational goals. In order to get best result from
subordinates, managers need to encourage high morale, a spirit of involvement and
co- operation and a willingness to work by adapting desirable leadership behaviour
(Asuquo,
2007).The choice of leader behaviour influences the internal environment. Banks being
customer-contact businesses, the behaviours and actions of frontline employees during
service delivery influence how service quality will be perceived (Malhotra &
Mukherjee,
2004). Supportive and participative leader behaviours are key in influencing employee
Page 2 of 58
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 386
behaviour and commitment towards quality (Forrester, 2000). The freedom and ability
to make decisions and commitments from employees improves on employee-service
quality to customers. Leaders need to involve employees in the defining and developing
vision statements (Liu, 2006). He further argues that failure of involvement leads to
employees being dissatisfied and unwilling to summon the effort needed to provide a
higher standard of service quality to customers. This therefore means that commitment
and job satisfaction of customer-contact employees is important during service delivery,
though banks customers continue to complain about bank services.
Kagenda (2008) noted how Stanbic and Centenary banks managed on the autocratic mode
of leadership behaviour have been unresponsive to customer needs, leading to low
service quality. For example, Anecdotal findings indicate the hurdles customers
experience before their loans and advances can be sanctioned in Stanbic bank
resulting from too much.
Bureaucracy (Kyokunda, 2006). This led to salaried employees shifting their accounts
from Stanbic to Standard chartered bank where the procedures and process of acquiring
loans are flexible (Loan portfolio report, 2008). Stanbic bank written complaints also
increased from
4.9% to 8% (Kyokunda, 2006). Stanbic bank staff are allocated specific roles which cannot be
altered even in cases of special needs without prior authority (Customer Evaluation Report,
2003 & Asiimwe, 2010). This has led to long queues when customers are paying schools fees
(Daily Monitor 25th, February, 2010). All these undermine the service quality in such banking
institutions.
Oseku (2009) noted that the poor relations between the leaders and subordinates undermine
service quality. In Centenary bank for example, the loans department manager failed to
communicate to employees the progress on the growth of loan portfolios in bank as agreed on
before. This made employees dissatisfied with their jobs leading to the reduction of Loan
portfolios from 9% in 2006 to 7% in 2007 as centenary bank dissatisfied employees discouraged
customers from taking up loans from the bank accusing it of charging higher interest rates with
unflexible repayment terms and instead referred them to competitors whose interested rates were
slightly low.
Low commitment amongst staff may lead to low service quality. For example Odeke (2010) adds
Page 3 of 58
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 387
that in Barclays bank Lira branch, the employee commitment reduced due to the banks failure to
honour its promise of pay rise and to create a favourable internal climate. This created job
dissatisfaction amongst employees. Employees made errors like crediting other customer‟s
accounts which took long to be corrected, lack of concern for customer needs, delays in
approving and processing transactions leading to an increase of customer complaints from
5% in 2008 to 8.8% in 2009 which undermine the quality of service in such banks. Namubiru
(2008) links low commitment with the rise in e-bank fraud as seven bank employees are currently
facing fraud charges amounting to 567.6M. One being from Bank of Africa (sh17m), four Crane
Bank employees (sh50.6m), three cashiers of Capital Finance Limited (sh500m) (New Vision
Friday, 3rd October, 2008).
Institutions need to ensure quality consistence and improved criteria for assessment in
addressing the ever increasing concerns on quality banking practices.
LITERATURE REVIEW
The review of the existing scholarly literature about leadership behaviour,
organizational commitment, job satisfaction and service quality. This review focuses on
supportive, participative and directive which are the constructs of leadership behaviour.
Organizational commitment was denoted by the constructs of affective normative and
continuous. Job satisfaction is seen under extrinsic and intrinsic attributes. Service
quality was reviewed using the constructs of tangibility, reliability, responsiveness,
assurance and empathy.
Leadership behaviour and service quality
Leadership behaviours adopted by managers have been argued to influence the
effectiveness of the service delivery process, resulting in greater levels of service quality
being provided to organizational customers (Zeithaml & Bitner, 1996). Leadership is a
social influence process in which the leader seeks the voluntary participation of
subordinates in an effort to reach organization goals (Omolayo, 2000), a process whereby
one person exerts social influence over other members of the group (Bamigboye, 2000),
a process of influencing the activities of an individual or a group of individuals in an
effort towards goal achievement in given situations (Akanwa, 1997), and a relational
concept involving both the influencing agent and the person being influenced (Eze, 1995).
