Page 1 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 128
Challenges and Delivery in the Higher Institution: A Survey of
University Autonomy in Nigeria.
Olakunle Folami
Department of Sociology Adekunle Ajasin University Akungba Akoko Ondo State Nigeria
Abstract
Public universities are owned either by the
federal or state governments. Corruption,
strike, funds and economic doldrums limit the
research and teaching capacity of universities
in Nigeria. These affect the contribution of
university system to the development of the
nation. McClelland’s Learned Needs Theory
was employed in this paper to explain the
desire of the universities to accomplish
successfully research and teaching delivery in
a competitive environment. Quantitative
method of data collection was used in this
paper to collect data from the respondents.
Questionnaires were administered among one
hundred and thirty six respondents from six
states and federal universities across the
nation. The paper found that both state and
federal universities could not meet their
financial obligations. Paucity of funds has led
to incessant strike, student unrest and brain
drain. It was also found that scarcity of funds
has affected research and development in the
universities. The paper therefore,
recommended autonomy and external source
of funding for the universities.
Internationalisation of the universities
research, and public/private partnership were
also recommended.
Keywords: Autonomy, Funding, University,
Research.
Introduction
Education, most especially the university
education is central to the national
development and its importance to individual
growth and wellbeing cannot be
overemphasised. There is a link reaction
between individual development and
education. According to Aluko (1996)
university is a place where human potentials
are developed and refined for the utilisation of
national development. Universities provide
manpower needed by the nation. The quality
of manpower available to a country is largely
determined by the standard of its education
(Jega, 1994). Funding is a major instrument
which determines how well a university
achieve its objectives. No matter how lofty the
objectives of a university are, inadequate
funding is capable of hampering its realisation.
Adequate funding promotes research and
development, qualitative teaching, good
learning environment, and ability of the
university to contribute to national
development adequately. Education generally
in Nigeria receives low attention from
government. Olorode (2005) claims that
unstable university calendar, strikes, brain- drain, lack of autonomy and low morale
among the lecturers contribute to the quality of
universities outputs in terms students and
research.
In recent times, university system has
been overwhelmed with strike, brain-drain,
student unrest and closure due to lack of
adequate funding. The ability to generate fund
privately is hampered by the status that created
the university system in Nigeria. Section 106
of the nation’s education policy recognizes
that the financing of education is a joint
responsibility of the Federal, State and Local
government (Onyekwu, 2011). But in practice
the funding is left solely to the owners. It has
become difficult for university to secure funds
from private organization to support research.
Scholarships, grants and bursaries for students
Page 2 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 129
and researchers are difficult to come by.
Olorode (2005) says that the culture is not
simply there among the business organisations
to support research and scholarship in Nigeria.
The Tertiary Education Fund and Petroleum
Technology Development Fund are created by
Acts of Government as compulsory
contributions from the business organisations
to finance education in Nigeria through a fixed
percentage tax deduction from the source
(cdnetng.org. n.d).
The proposition the paper seeks to
explain is that; first, inadequate funding could
result to brain-drain in the universities; and
second, there is a relationship between
university funding, research and teaching in
the universities. The study therefore, sets to
examine the extent of funding available to the
public universities in Nigeria. It seeks to know
the sources of funding available to Nigerian
universities. It also examines alternative
means available to universities in Nigeria to
generate more fund. The study like others in
the field of sociology of education and
management attempts to link paucity of funds
to challenges such as brain-drain, strike,
ineffective research and absent of season
lecturers in the Nigerian universities. This
article is divided into the following sections;
one, needs theory and challenges facing
universities; two, strike, brain-drain and
university system; three, private sector and
funding of university; four, method; and five,
results and conclusions.
Needs Theory and Challenges
McClelland’s Learned Needs Theory is used
in this study to explain the desire of
universities in Nigeria to accomplish
moderately performance goals, be successful
in competitive situation, assume personal
responsibility for fund sourcing and
internationalisation of programmes. Three
motivational needs were identified by
McClelland (1969) including achievement
motivation (n-ach); authority/power
motivation (n-pow); and affiliation motivation
(n-affil). First, the n-ach person is
'achievement motivated' and therefore seeks
achievement, attainment of realistic but
challenging goals, and advancement in the job.
There is a strong need for feedback as to
achievement and progress, and a need for a
sense of accomplishment. Second, the n-pow
person is 'authority motivated'. This driver
produces a need to be influential, effective and
to make an impact. There is a strong need to
lead and for their ideas to prevail. There is also
motivation and need towards increasing
personal status and prestige. Third, the n-affil
person is 'affiliation motivated', and has a need
for friendly relationships and is motivated
towards interaction with other people. The
affiliation driver produces motivation and need
to be liked and held in popular regard. These
people are team players (Businessballs, 2015).
The need for autonomy by the
universities to meet the current challenges
explains why power with limited moderation
over activities by external agencies like state
or federal government is desirable. The desire
by the universities to conduct their businesses
with interferences requires a high ‘socialized
power’ in which they seek power for
autonomous purpose (Rue and Holland 1986).
According to Smelser (1962) universities with
a strong affiliation need to form positive
relationships with outside world. Donnel and
Gibson (1987) says that universities with a
high need for achievement make better
entrepreneurs because they are able to work
autonomously towards the challenging goal of
establishing a new source of funding
(Sergiovamni and Carver, 2003).
In the modern era, university should
encourage partnership with private sector of
the economy through research and
development. This will provide a strong
economic base and a better source of finance
for the university (ICAN study kit, 1998). The
research output of a university could be sold to
a private sector or government agencies (Croft
Page 3 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 01 Issue 10
November 2015
Available online: http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 130
2004). University must be ready to seek grants
and endowed research chair for professors who
can attract funds (Olorode, 2005). These
could go a long way to finance its budget if
not for lack of autonomy that hampered such
ingenuity in Nigeria (Olorode, 2005).
In Nigeria, the annual budgetary
allocation to education has dropped from
19.6% in 1993 to 12.4% in 2010. In 1996,
OECO countries accounted for 85% of the
total R&D investment; China, India, Brazil
and East Asia represented 11% and the rest of
the world (inclusive of Nigeria that is) only
4% ... Nigeria has only 15 scientists and
engineers per million persons. This compares
with 158 in India and 4,103 in the United
States (World Bank, 2002). Nigeria’s number
of scientific publication for 2005 was 711
significantly less than its 1991 output which
was 1,062 (Task Force 2010). The country’s
low research output probably reflects the low
priority accorded to research and development
by government. Nigeria’s federal university
system spends only 1.3% of its budget on
Research (Harnett, 2000).
The introduction of a special agency
“Education Trust Fund” to generate funds to
finance education in Nigeria has not recorded
desired results. Obikwe (2006) said that the
funding of Nigeria universities is at all time
low, despite the purported efforts of successive
government, no much can be shown for the
efforts. Onweh (1997) states that there is an
urgent need for stakeholders in the country’s
education sector to align their different
objectives to rescue university system from
total collapse. On education, Nigeria spends an
estimated 2.4% of its GNP while sub-Saharan
Africa as a whole spends 5.1%.... school drop
out have continually risen and also, the
education standards have reportedly declined.
Between 2000 and 2007, for example, the
Government Allocation for higher education
declined by 27%... even as enrollment grew by
79%. The result is a dramatic fall in the quality
of University education and research as
implied by the 62% drop in the real value of
recurrent expenditure per student during this
period (Saint, 2010).
Strike, Brain-drain and University System
University system continues to experience
problems such as strike, closure, irregular
academic calendar, brain-drain, low level of
research and other problems as a result of
small budgetary allocation to education by
government in Nigeria. Research into the
financial ability of universities has not been
taken the central stage until it becomes clear
that Federal and State government could not
cope with the financing of the nation’s
Universities as a result of global economic
meltdown and a need to develop decades of
infrastructures neglected by successive
military governments in Nigeria. According to
Aluko (1996), low academic salaries coupled
with more frequently university closure which
linked to students’ unrest and government
interferences on a number of campuses have
prompted numerous university staff to forsake
the academic calling. The World Bank notes
that some 23,000 qualified academic staffers
are emigrating from Africa each year in search
of better working conditions. It is estimated
that 10,000 Nigerians are now employed in the
United States alone. More often, however, it is
a neighboring country which beckons, South
Africa attracts staff from Malawi, Zambia, and
Nigeria, and the universities in Botswana and
Swaziland attract Zimbabweans (Aluko,
1996).
The economic doldrums which the
country currently witnessed have had serious
effects on the university system in Nigeria.
The budgetary allocation declines led to the
rationalization or cancellation of a number of
services rendered by the universities (Olorode,
2005). The services that were affected
included support and sponsor of staff to
conferences, both local or overseas; inadequate
and epileptic supplies of stationary items and
