Page 1 of 13

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e‐ISSN: 2395‐0463

Volume 01 Issue 10

November 2015

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page | 94

Resisting Anti‐Gay Laws through Media Advocacy and Online

Communities of Meanings: A Study on Nigerian Homosexuals

Endong, Floribert Patrick Calvain

Department of Theatre and Media Studies

University of Calabar, Calabar-Nigeria

floribertendong@yahoo.com

Vareba, Anthony Leva

Department of Mass Communication

River State Polytechnic, Bori, Nigeria

tvareba@yahoo.com

Abstract

The systematic demonization and

criminalization of homosexuality in

Nigeria have exacerbated homophobia in

the Nigerian society. Such a scenario has

immensely been reported by mostly

western or west-based scholars and

exploited as another argument to tarnish

the image of Nigeria in the international

scene. A detail which has virtually not

caught the attention of most scholars is the

ensemble of efforts by indigenous social

forces such as the Nigerian civil society

(NGOs and human right activists) in view

of resisting the Nigerian anti-gay

dispensation and defending the rights of

LGBT persons in the country. This paper

opts to fill this gap. It reviews various

advocacy initiatives conceived by the

Nigerian civil society and geared towards

pushing LGBT rights in Nigeria. It

particularly explores this stakeholder’s

mobilization of media advocacy and the

social media to mediate the plight of

Nigerian homosexuals and raise

awareness about the human rights of

LGBT persons in the country. It argues

that though tremendous, these advocacy

initiatives are yet to produce very

consequential fruits. Minds are still slow to

change meanwhile conservative/

traditionalist myths continue to govern and

dominate in the Nigerian public opinion.

All these tend to suggest that

homosexuality still has a long way to go

for it to be fully accommodated in the

Nigerian social system as well as to be

ultimately decriminalized.

Keywords: Media advocacy, LGBT Right

Movement, Homosexuality, Social Media,

Online Communities

Page 2 of 13

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e‐ISSN: 2395‐0463

Volume 01 Issue 10

November 2015

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page | 95

1. Introduction

As a contentious phenomenon,

African homosexuality has left no

contemporary school of thought indifferent

in the Dark Continent. In Nigeria

particularly, the phenomenon has

progressively metamorphosed into

homophobia. Indeed, homosexuality is

mainly demonized in the country’s

political and social spheres, on bases which

range from culturalist arguments (cultural

purism) to biblical injunctions or

postulations. Similarly to most African

countries, the Nigerian Government has

enacted laws which severely criminalize

the phenomenon, sentencing to 14 years of

imprisonment any convicted case of

homosexuality and to 10 years

imprisonment any person who assists a

marriage between homosexual persons.

The Nigerian law equally represses same

sex unions, membership in gay group as

well as public display of same-sex

relationship. Furthermore, the law

fervently exhorts the populace to report

any suspected case of homosexuality to the

cops. Such a visibly “harsh” dispensation

has literally exacerbated the stigmatization

and ostracism of the gay community as

well as has exposed them (the gay fold) to

such risks as blackmail, extortions, public

humiliation or lynching. In addition to this,

the anti-gay dispensation has

systematically slowed and handicapped

advocacy or activism for the phenomenon

(African homosexuality). Such a negative

impact of the anti-gay laws is felt

particularly in the mainstream media,

which are driven by a relatively

homophobic code (see Article 3.7.5 of the

2010 Nigerian Broadcasting Code). In such

an environment, freedom of expression is

violated and pro-gay activism is made to

basically be underground or clandestine.

The international civil rights observatory

body Human Right Watch (HRW) actually

predicted such a scenario in 2011 – when

the legislation was still in gestation.

Human Right Watch succinctly foresaw

that: “the bill will expand Nigeria‘s already

draconian punishments for consensual

same-sex conduct and set a precedent that

would threaten all Nigerians‘ rights to

privacy, equality, free expression,

association and to be free from

discrimination” (cited in Adebayo

2012:58).

The Nigerian (anti-gay) laws

actually violate a wide range of civil rights.

They create a climate of intimidation and

fear which is un-friendly to media

advocacy and activism for LGBT rights.

The laws also threaten self-expression by

LGBT people and their allies; and

systematically hinder the expression of

support for LGBTI human rights.

Furthermore, the laws indirectly affect

Nigeria’s literary, artistic, and cultural

communities as they put LGBT writers and

artists at risk of criminal prosecution and

violent physical attack, as well as limits

their ability to publish and distribute their

works in the Nigerian territory.

Additionally, the law threatens freedom of

expression thereby eroding the strength of

Nigerian democracy.

In reaction to this situation, a

number of western democracies led by the

USA have embarked on a series of both

diplomatic and subtly “aggressive”

Page 3 of 13

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e‐ISSN: 2395‐0463

Volume 01 Issue 10

November 2015

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page | 96

approaches aimed at advocating the

decriminalization of homosexuality in the

country. In the process, these western

countries have mounted multifaceted

pressure on the Nigerian Government in a

bid to ultimately compel it to recognize

LGBT rights as human rights. In so doing,

they even sometimes threatened to

discontinue their cooperation especially

their financial aid. These exogenous pro- gay efforts have been complemented or

supplemented by indigenous struggles by

some LGBT rights activists, NGOs, and

“charismatic” and courageous LGBT

Nigerians (notably Reverend Rowland Jide

Macauley, Davis Mac-Iyalla, Bisi Alimi,

Ade Adeniji and Yemisi Ilesanmi among

others). Despite these pressures and

threats, the Nigerian society is still terribly

homophobic and the country persists in its

criminalization philosophy, brandishing

culturalist and moralist arguments. As

succinctly put by David Mark (2014) (the

leader of Nigerian Senate and the man

responsible for the same-sex marriage

prohibition Act), the anti-gay dispensation

will “prove to the rest of the world, who

are advocates of this unnatural way

[homosexuality] that Nigerians promote

and respect sanity, morality and

homosexuality”.

The criminalization of

homosexuality and western countries’

pressure in favor of the LGBT movement

are fueling a hot and delicate debate

involving cardinal social and political

forces including the media of mass

communication. Going from this premise,

homosexuality (as a sexual orientation) and

LGBT rights movement (as a human right

philosophy and arguably presented as a

facet of westernization/cultural

imperialism) have become the subjects of

passionate debate in the social networks in

Nigeria. This debate involves serious

interactions between Nigerian bloggers or

web journalists – among which should be

counted a myriad of LGBT persons and

sympathizers – and their fans/readers.

Indeed, the social networks have created a

fertile forum for discussion and

negotiations on African homosexuality and

the LGBT right movement. They have, in

various ways, immensely facilitated pro- gay expressions by Nigerians and

advocacy for the LGBT right movement.

Such an advocacy and activism are

virtually more complicated – if not

somehow stultified – in the mainstream

media, given the fact that the industry is

naturally governed by a homophobic media

law (the Nigerian Broadcasting Code

2010). One way in which this advocacy

has been made possible is the creation of

online communities by gays, through

interactions on facebook, Twiter, relevant

and tactically conceived web sites and

blogs among other instrumentalities. This

paper critically examines the various

strategies LGBT activists and pro-gay

Nigerians employed to engineer advocacy

efforts in favor of the gay-proselytism. It

particularly analyses how the social

networks are mobilized by the gay

community as a strategic weapon to

describe their plight, mount an advocacy

for the LGBT right movement in Nigeria

and resist or react to a dispensation which

is highly unfavorable/ asphyxiating to

them.