Page 1 of 39

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 1

January 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 244

Practices and Challenges of Public-Private Partnership in

Solid Waste Management: The Case of Addis Ababa City

Administration

Negesse Bogale Teferra

Department of Public Administration and Development Management, College of Business and

Economics, Dilla University, P.o.Box +251-419, Dilla, SNNPRS, Ethiopia:

E-mail: negessebogale@gmail.com or negessedu@gmail.com:

Abstract

The public private partnership is applied in

developing countries on solid waste

management service delivery, especially in

urban areas to provide the services

effectively and efficiently. As well, it is better

approach in the provision of solid waste

service in most urbanizing cities of

developing countries like Addis Ababa, both

public and private sectors have no capacity

to provide solid waste handling service

separately. Because of this, the study

assesses the practices and challenges of

public private partnership on solid waste

management in Addis Ababa City. The study

employed both qualitative and quantitative

research approach. The researcher

collected data via questionnaire, interviews

and monthly reports of sub-cities. Besides,

the study used descriptive analysis and

interpretive techniques to analyze the

quantitative and qualitative data

respectively.

The finding of the study shows that in the

partnership, there is no law enforcement

structure and the administrators are not

committed to enforce even the existing rules

and regulations. In the partnership there is

no strong coordination between

stakeholders (service providers, waste

generators, concerned organization etc.)

with each other to enhance the provision of

solid waste services. Even if the partnership

shows the improvement of solid waste

handling service .in the city, still both public

and private party did not dispose all

generated waste, from the total of 2202 tons

solid waste generation per day, about 30-

35% of waste didn’t properly collected by

service providers. Because, of many factors

that affect the effectiveness of public-private

partnership on solid waste management

such as lack of clear and effective

legislation that coordinate apprehensive

stakeholder, absence of separation of waste

at the source and negative perception of

people regarding the work of solid waste.

Solid waste collection, transportation and

disposal capacity of the public and private

sectors are low and inadequate as compared

to the amount of waste generation in the

city. Therefore, both sectors should adopt

scientific methods for collection,

segregation, transportation and disposal of

solid waste. Moreover, public sector

accommodates private sector to provide and

manage solid waste effectively and

efficiently.

Page 2 of 39

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 1

January 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 245

Key words: Partnership, public private

partnership, solid waste, solid waste

management

1. Introduction

The generation of Solid Waste (SW) is

inevitable. It was not important in former

times but became an issue as soon as people

started to settle in communities. Eversince,

Solid Waste Management (SWM) has been

of great concern to municipal authorities

worldwide (Dorvil, 2007). Solid waste

management systems are an essential

component of the environmental

infrastructure in human settlements. These

systems encompass all the activities

undertaken from the point of waste

generation up to the final disposal

(Mugagga, 2006).

Municipal solid waste and recycling can be

unpacked into value chain service by

structuring and sequencing the arrangement

into source separation, collection, recycling,

transportation and treatment and/ or land

filling. Public Private Partnership (PPP)

investment arrangement can be brokered

between urban government and private

contractors (including formal and informal

entrepreneurs) through contractual

agreement (Asubonteng, 2011). The primary

target of municipal solid waste management

(MSWM) is to protect the health of the

population, promote environmental quality,

develop sustainability, and provide support

to economic productivity. To meet these

goals, sustainable solid waste management

systems must be embraced fully by local

authorities in collaboration with both the

public and private sectors (Henry et al.,

2005).

Both public and private sectors are active in

handling solid waste management (SWM) in

developing countries. Public sector agencies

in SWM generally mean municipalities or

city corporations. They operate under certain

inherent limitations. For instance, rigid laws,

under which they must work, make it

difficult to bring change to operational

matters. Moreover, since much of the work

such as street sweeping, loading and

unloading waste and drain cleaning are done

manually; the public sector must employ a

large number of people. This sector also

suffers from low productivity of staff,

inadequate supervision and unsatisfactory

equipment (Ahmed & Ali, 2004).

The private sector operating solid waste

management in various forms of partnership

with the public sector, they may provide

Page 3 of 39

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 1

January 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 246

capital, management and organizational

capacity, labour and/or technical skills. Due

to their profit orientation, private enterprises

can, under appropriate conditions, provide

municipal solid waste management

(MSWM) services more effectively and at

lower costs than the public sector. However,

private sector involvement does not, in

itself, guarantee effectiveness and low costs.

Problems arise when privatization is poorly

conceived and regulated and, in particular,

when competition between suppliers is

lacking (Schubeler, 1996).

The private sector in most of the African

countries is still in its infancy. On top of the

infancy of the private sector in the region,

the sector is relatively very small in size and

capital base, especially so for the

indigenous, as opposed to the foreign (in

form of Foreign Direct Investments-FDIs)

private sector. One option in facing these

challenges is to enhance the role of both the

public and private sectors in owning,

financing and management/operation of the

production and distribution of goods and

services. Consequently, Public Private

Partnerships (PPPs should increasingly be

viewed as a mechanism to provide state

functions and municipal goods and services

on a cost effective and sustainable basis

(Ngowi, 2005).

In a number of instances the waste

management services in major cities across

Africa is either in a limited state of

operation, or has stopped almost completely

due to various reasons. One of the main

challenges facing these cities is to start

providing such services again, or to

substantially improve the existing services,

but within the realities of limited technical

and/or financial resources or institutional

capacity. One of the possible solutions to

this problem which has been identified by a

number of municipalities, and which either

has been implemented, or is being

considered, is the use of Public Private

Partnership contractual arrangement with

private contractors as a means of addressing

the waste management service delivery

(Liebenberg, 2007).

Addis Ababa is the capital city of Ethiopia,

located in the central highlands of the

country with an area of 540 km2 of which

18.174 m2 is rural and its altitude ranges

from 2000m - 2800 m above sea level

(Nigatu et al., 2011) which makes Addis

Ababa the highest capital city in Africa