Page 1 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 1
January 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 15
Determinants of Ghana Trade Balance: A Cointegration
and Variance Decomposition Approach.
Emmanuel Amoah, MPhil Statistics1 Kwame Antwi, MSc. Applied Statistics2
1Department of Statistics, University of Ghana
Email: emmanuelamoah27@gmail.com
2Department of Mathematics, KNUST
Email: kantwi35@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This paper attempts an empirical
investigation of the impact of exchange rate
on Ghana trade balance using the Johansen
co-integration and variance decomposition
analyses using the annual time series data
from 1980 to 2012; whether exchange rate
devaluation improves or worsens trade
balance has been at the centre of literature
debate over time with varying empirical
evidences for developed and developing
nation. The empirical results indicate that
there exist a long-run stationary
relationship between trade balance and its
determinant- money supply and GDP; as
employed in the study. On the variance
decomposition analyses the percentage of
the forecast variance in trade balance is
largely explained by innovation in money
supply, among other explanatory variables
as it maintains higher percentage than the
others. The paper concludes with important
implications for policy makers because it
provides evidence supporting that fact that
level of money supply has a major impact on
trade balance adjustment and that
devaluation of the exchange rate worsens
the trade balance of Ghana in the long run.
KEY WORDS: trade balance, Johansen co- integration, variance decomposition
INTRODUCTION
The trade balance in the economy helps to
determine the macroeconomic performance
of the economy like the balance of payment,
investments and savings in both the
developed and the developing economies.
On the other hand, the real exchange rate
plays a major role to improve the level of
the trade balance because the economic
theory stipulates that, the depreciation of the
real exchange rate improves the level of
trade balance in the long-run even though it
may reduce the trade balance in the short- run (Chiu et al. 2010).
Ghana is a developing country that has
experienced both trade surplus and deficit in
different periods of time. However, the
deficit in the trade balance has continued to
increase in Ghana.
The empirical literature review in this study
focuses on the empirical studies undertaken
to establish the relationship of the exchange
rate on trade balance. Various studies have
been undertaken and established different
results and these are explained as follows;
Page 2 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 1
January 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 16
Shahbaz et al. (2010) carried out a study
with the aim of establishing changes in the
real exchange rate and the respective effect
on trade balance (measured in terms of
trade) in Pakistan. The study made use of
the quarterly data from 1980 to the end of
2006 with only real exchange rate3 being
dependent variable and by using the
autoregressive distributed lag (ARDL)
technique; the long run relationship was
established to exist between real exchange
rate and the trade balance. The study made
use of the J-Curve approach to trade
balance. The VECM was carried out and the
impulse response function was also used to
check on the existence of J-curve, which
failed to exist according to the study. The
effect was negative and significant and
hence currency devaluation was noted to
unfavourably affect trade balance.
In the seminal paper of (Rose, 1991), he
examined the empirical relation between
real effective exchange rate and trade
balance of major five OECD countries in the
post-Bretton Woods era and found that the
exchange rate as insignificant determinant of
balance of trade. The research done by
(Rose & Yellen, 1989) could not reject the
hypothesis that the real exchange rate was
statistically insignificant determinant of
trade flows. They examined the bilateral
trade flows between the United States and
other OECD countries using quarterly data.
Furthermore, the studies of (Singh T.
(2002)) find that ‘real exchange rate’ and
‘domestic income’ explain a significant
influence while ‘foreign income’ shows an
insignificant impact on ‘trade balance’ this
result for Indian data. Singh’s study also
demonstrates a very significant effect
(+2.33) of real exchange rate and domestic
income (-1.87) on Indian trade balance.
Bhattarai & Armah (2005) study the effects
of exchange rate on the trade balance in
Ghana using a co integration analysis. The
results from this study show that the trade
balance of Ghana will not improve in the
short run unless it adopts policy rules in the
foreign exchange market, but it may be
costly if such adjustment were to occur
unaided in the long run. The result also
show that in the short - to - medium term, as
well as in the long, income levels are not
important determinants either of the import
demand or the export demand of Ghana. It
also shows that it is the exchange rate that is
the significant factor in the short term. In the
long run however, the study reveals that
only the real exchange rate significantly
affects the trade balance. However, the
estimate for Ghana show that even in the
long run, the Marshall-Lerner-Robinson
(MLR) condition for a successful
devaluation is barely met and therefore, in
Ghana's case the gains would not be enough
to offset the losses in the trade balance in the
short run. It is important in these efforts to
adopt a level-headed perspective of the
nature of the balance of payments problems.
The effect of the terms of trade losses and
domestic inflationary forces in developing
countries cannot be simply reversed by
exchange-rate changes. From the above, it is
clear that neither theoretical nor empirical
studies have established definitely whether a
depreciation of a country's domestic
currency would improve its trade balance.
Understanding of the long run relationship
Page 3 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 1
January 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 17
between exchange rate depreciation and
trade balance is important for policy
formulation and implementation in
developing countries, such as Ghana. Also,
the consideration of other variables like
money supply and GDP would help to give
more information on the increasing deficit
on trade balance. This information may help
the government to consider policies that
would improve trade balance in Ghana.
METHODOLOGY
Source of Data and Data Collection
Procedure
All series examined in this study; trade
balance, real exchange rate, real GDP and
money supply- are collected from Bank of
Ghana and WDI, World Bank. The data is
annual and spans the time period 1980 to
2012, which gives thirty two (32) data points
which is statistically large to be used for the
study.
Analysis Plan
In analysing the data set the following tests
were employed: Unit root test for
stationarity, ADF (Augmented Dickey
Fuller) test, PP (Phillips-Perron) test and
KPSS(Kwiatkowski, Phillips, Schmidt and
Shin, 1992) test, Co-integration test, Vector
error correction model (VECM), etc.
Eviews 8 statistical computing software was
used to implement the time series methods
that will be discussed and all statistical tests
were carried out at 0.05 level of
significance.
Unit Root Tests
Unit root tests are applied to check whether
the time series is stationary. Many unit root
tests are proposed in the literature. In this
paper we used three tests namely ADF
(Augmented Dickey Fuller) test, PP
(Phillips-Perron) test and KPSS
(Kwiatkowski et al (1992)) test.
The Dickey-Fuller test is based on testing
the hypothesis that series contains unit root
against the series is stationary under the
assumption that errors are white noise. The
test may be carried out using a conventional
t statistic. However, the tests do not follow
the standard student t distribution so the
critical values for the test are obtained by
simulation. An extension which will
accommodate some forms of serial
correlation is the augmented Dickey–Fuller
test.
The Phillips–Perron test on the other hand
test that a variable has a unit root. The null
hypothesis is that the variable contains a unit
root, and the alternative is that the variable
was generated by a stationary process.
KPSS proposed an LM test for testing trend
and/or level stationarity. That is, now under
the null hypothesis the series is assumed
stationary, whereas in the former tests it was
a unit root process. Taking the null
hypothesis as a stationary process and the
unit root as an alternative is in accordance
with a conservative testing strategy. One
should always seek tests that place the
hypothesis we are interested in as the
alternative one. Hence, if we then reject the
There was a problem loading this page. Retrying...
