Page 1 of 22
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 342
The Impact of Agricultural Mechanization on
Employment. Substitution and Complementarity in Spain.
Pedro Arias1 ; Silverio Alarcón2 ; María Botey3;
Universidad Politécnica de Madrid Ciudad Universitaria s/n 28040 Madrid (Spain)
(pedro.arias@upm.es); (silverio.alarcon@upm.es) ; (maria.botey.fullat@gmail.com);
Abstract
This study is focused on analyzing the
relationship between two factors traditionally
seen as substitutable, namely mechanization
and agricultural employment. To this aim, we
have estimated mechanization levels
according to the number of registered
tractors and employment levels according to
personnel employed in agriculture. The
methodology used is based on the univariate
analysis of time series in order to assess their
individual behavior. Following that,
causality amongst these variables was
analyzed to establish their dynamic
relationship by defining the transfer function.
Key words: agricultural
mechanization, employment, time serie,
causality, transfer function.
Classification JEL: C53, E27, Q16
Abbreviations used: INE (Spanish
National Institute of Statistics); EPA (Labor
Force Survey); ARIMA (Autoregressive
Integrated Moving Average Models); AR
(autoregressive component); MA (mobile
component); SMA (seasonal mobile
component); MAGRAMA (Ministry of
Agriculture, Food And Environment); ADF
(Augmented Dickey-Fuller test).
1. Introduction
In general terms mechanization can be
defined as the regular use of machinery
equipment and installations in
productive activity. In the agricultural
context, the FAO (2006) defines under this
heading the manufacturing, distribution and
functioning of all kinds of tools, implements,
machinery and equipment used for land
preparation, agricultural production,
harvesting and primary processing.
Agricultural mechanization is – along
with the development of further agricultural
techniques – one of the productive factors
with the highest impact on the growth of the
world’s agricultural production, as declared
by the FAO (2000). In the specific case of
Spain this has entailed a process of
agricultural transformation with social and
economic effects. It has increased
productivity but at the same time, and
according to numerous authors including
Daly (1981), Garcia et al (1985), Picazo and
Reig (1990), Márquez (1999), Singh (2006),
Akinbamowo (2013) and Zhizhang and
Hanlin (2014), it has led to a decrease in the
size of the workforce. Other authors have
diverging opinions as mechanization and
other factors reduce work in certain areas but
the increase in production, productivity and
crop intensification allows for absorbing the
employment loss in other agricultural
activities, as shown by Rochin (1978),
Reimer (1984), Sindhu and Grewal (1991)
and Verma (2005).
Page 2 of 22
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 343
In fact, the decrease in the size of the
workforce cannot be attributed solely to
mechanization given that there are other
variables which have also had an effect on
this loss. Escudero (1986) links it to farmers
quitting agricultural activity due to retirement
or transfer to other sectors. Other authors like
Garrido and González (1992) note the
influence on the mechanization effect of a
series of factors and administrative measures
aiming at lowering the number of farms.
Further studies, (Leguina and Naredo, 1973;
Naredo, 1974; Ortega, 1983) have shown that
mechanization was caused initially by
migratory dynamics, which since the 1950s
have been gradually diminishing workforce
availability in the agricultural sector and
causing an increase in wage costs. This
situation favored machinery acquisition and
the use of new production techniques to
lower costs and increase productivity.
Therefore, mechanization can be both the
cause and effect of the decrease in workforce.
In short, the 1950s effectively
inaugurated a process of intensification of
machinery use parallel to a loss of size of the
agricultural workforce. This has led to more
agricultural activity with fewer farmers and
to the specialization and simplification of
alternatives.
This process of technological
transformation can be observed when we
compare the active agricultural population
and the number of tractors registered up to
the early 1980s; these variables evolved in
opposite directions, which could be
interpreted as factor substitution i.e.
mechanization replacing workforce (Figure
1).
Figure 1
Tractors (registered number)
1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980
period
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
tractors
Active agricultural population (thousands of people)
1960 1964 1968 1972 1976 1980
period
2100
2600
3100
3600
4100
4600
5100
employment
However, there is no general consensus
regarding the cause-effect relationship
between these variables. In view of all
this and in the face of the observed
behavior of both variables, the object of
this study is to analyze their evolution
and define their causality. This paper is
then focused on the following questions:
Estimating a time model for
mechanization and employment in
agriculture throughout the period 1985-
2014.
Page 3 of 22
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 344
Establishing the causal relationship
and defining the transfer function
between these variables.
The study is structured as follows:
section 2 presents materials and
methods, section 3 describes the
mechanization process and the
evolution of agricultural employment,
section 4 presents the estimations of the
time models for mechanization and
workforce. Finally, section 5 deals with
causal relationships and defines the
transfer model.
2. Materials and methods
Achieving the proposed objectives
requires the previous characterization of
the two variables. In the case of
workforce we have studied the
personnel employed in agriculture; in
terms of mechanization level, a series of
indicators can be found in the literature
to estimate it: (Ferrer (1978), Spoor
(1987), NCAER (1981), Binswanger
(1982), Andrés and Espejo (1989), Vico
(1996), Binimelis et al (2005), Singh
(2006), Sharabiani and Ranjbar (2008),
Ghadiryanfar et al (2009), Fadavi (2010)
and Zangeneh and Banaeian (2014)).
These indicators are basically structured
in two groups according to their nature,
which can be either technical or
economic. Within the latter group, some
authors lean towards using tractor
demand, given that it is one of the
pieces of machinery that has contributed
most to agriculture modernization
(Cooper (1994) and Pérez (1984) and is
thus a robust indicator of the
mechanization process. In view of this,
we have chosen the latter approach and
we estimate mechanization by means of
the demand for tractors and specifically
through the number or registered
tractors.
As to workforce, we have used
information provided by INE through
quarterly EPA survey. As for
mechanization, we use the tractor
registration data collected in the Boletín
Mensual de Estadística [Monthly
Bulletin of Statistics], issued by the
Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Food
and Environment.
The methodology used to achieve the
first objective is based on the univariate
analysis of the time series. This
technique was developed by Box and
Jenkins (Box-Jenkins, 1976; Peña,
2005) in the 1960s and has since been
applied extensively in different fields,
mechanization analysis amongst them
(Kuchler and Vroomen (1987), Biondi
et al (1998), Arias (2001), Unakitana
and Akdemirb (2007) and Kim et al.
(2013)). This methodology focuses on
the univariate analysis of time series
through ARIMA models. The first stage
involves defining and estimating the
model1
and making the necessary
transformations so that the series is a
stationary process (in median and
variance). The second stage is the
1 Estimating the ARIMA model requires
the defining of the different parameters
constituting it. Thus, an ARIMA (p, d, q)x(P, D,
Q)s requires the defining of the autoregressive
component for the regular stationary part s
(orders p and P respectively), the mobile
average (orders q and Q) and the regular and
seasonal differentiations (d y D) to be used in
the series.
