Page 1 of 17
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 325
Corporate Philanthropy Disclosure: Does Board’s Education
Matters?
Mohd Farid Asraf Md Hashim, CPA (Aust)1; Mohd ‘Atef Md Yusof, PhD2
*1Lecturer, School of Accountancy, Universiti Utara Malaysia, 06010 UUM Sintok. Kedah Darul
Aman, Malaysia;
2 Senior Lecturer, School of Accountancy, Universiti Utara Malaysia, 06010 UUM Sintok.
Kedah Darul Aman, Malaysia
mdfarid@uum.edu.my ; atef@uum.edu.my
Abstract
The study on corporate philanthropy (CP)
disclosure is limited and need to be given
further attention. Thus, the objective of this
paper is to examine the importance of board
of directors’ (BOD) education, in addition
to firm-specific factors, as possible
determinants of CP disclosure of Malaysian
public listed companies. Three BODs’
education characteristics were considered
namely the level of education, field of
education and place of education. Data for
the study was collected using secondary
data. A CP checklist was used to measure
the level of CP disclosure in the annual
reports of 296 companies listed on Bursa
Malaysia for the year 2013. By employing
multiple regressions, the results indicated
that the board’s level of education is
statistically significant in explaining the
disclosure of CP. The results also displayed
no significant relationship between field of
study, place of education and CP disclosure.
It is expected that this study will have
important policy implication that enhances
the transparency and accountability
pertaining the corporate givings.
Keywords: board of directors; corporate
philanthropy disclosure; Malaysian public
listed companies; corporate governance
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Resources dependency theory claims that
the roles of the board of directors (BODs) is
not limited to monitor and oversees the
business’s governance. They also provide
resources for the formation of strategy
through consultations, dissemination of
information and advice to the chief
executive officer (Zahra and Pearce, 1989).
By providing resources and strategic
direction (Pfeffer & Salancik, 2003) to the
company, the board of directors plays an
important role in determining the policies
and decisions of corporate philanthropy
(Buckholtz, Amason & Rutherford, 1999).
This includes the decision on size, goals and
direction as well as the management of
company’s charitable contribution activities
(Velasco, 1996; Coffey & Wang, 1998;
Strandberg, 2008; Lev, Petrovits &
Radhakrishnan, 2011). Due to the facts that
the corporate philanthropy (CP) is regarded
as voluntary or discretionary to be
undertaken by firms (Carroll, 1979), the
characteristics and personality of the top
Page 2 of 17
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 326
management may affect any decision related
to the CP governance (Choi & Wang, 2007).
Self-interest motives by the executives
(Wang & Coffey, 1992; Lev et al., 2011)
and the lack of specific requirements on CP
disclosure (Campbell & Slack, 2008;
Shapira, 2012) have fortify the importance
of BODs role to ensure an attainment of a
greater accountability and transparency that
eventually help stakeholders in making
better decision. In Malaysia, the Companies
Act 1965 does not allocate any reporting
requirement for philanthropic givings.
Furthermore, political interests, the issues of
materiality and cost benefits of CP
disclosure are amongst the determinant
factors that lead to the absence of legal
requirements on corporate donations
disclosure (Shapira, 2012). Thus, attention
needs to be given on this matter since the
board is the one who hold the responsible
for the information disseminated in the
annual report (Gibbins, Richarson &
Waterhouse, 1990).
Arguments from the agency theory have
shown that the BODs characteristics are
important to achieve greater accountability
and transparency including in the issue of
CP (Coffey & Wang, 1992, Helland &
Smith, 2004). Yet, some of the previous
literatures have demonstrated that the
influences of the BODs on the level of
corporate social reporting are varied and
inconclusive. Lack of experience and
knowledge of the directors lead to the
weaknesses in term of corporate’s
understanding on different customers’and
public perspectives including in the issue of
corporate social responsibility (Claessens,
Djankov and Lang, 2000; Bursa Malaysia,
2007) which include the CP. As a
consequence, directors’ involvement in the
formation of corporate social reporting is
limited (Strandberg, 2008).
It is believed that board members with
relevant skills, education and experiences
are able to bring different perspectives
(Yusof, 2013) in understanding the needs of
different stakeholders on the issue of CSR
and corporate philanthropy, as well as its
disclosure (Bursa Malaysia, 2007; Michelon
& Parbonetti, 2012; Musa & Oba, 2012).
Nonetheless, the profiles possessed by the
board of directors also enable the transfer of
knowledge that ultimately formed a better
CSR (Strandberg, 2008; Barka &
Mokkadem, 2012) and CP governance.
Based on the above discussions, this study
examines the BODs’ characteristics
particularly its education attributes that
influences the disclosure of CP. This
includes level of education, field of
education and place of education. The
attributes are expected to help in
illuminating the relevant characteristics of
BODs that might strengthen the
accountability and transparency of CP
report.
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW AND
HYPOTHESES DEVELOPMENT
The current study suggests the application of
resource dependency theory as a basis to
explain the role of BODs which is not only
limited to the internal control mechanisms of
the organization. The theory also explains
other roles and functions of directors such as
providing valuable resource for the
organization which include advising,
expertise and legitimacy (Daily, Dalton &
Cannella Jr, 2003; Pfeffer & Salancik,
2003). Indeed, the various compositions
among board members contribute to the
diversity of talents, values, experiences
(Coffey & Wang, 1998; Hillman, Cannella
Page 3 of 17
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 327
& Paetzold, 2000) and expertise through
education (Hillman, Cannella & Harris,
2002). Thus, it is believed that it may impact
the decision of CP disclosure.
2.1 Boards’ Education
The level of education is one of the
individual's human capital elements that can
help to improve organization (Judge, Cable,
Boudreau & Bretz Jr., 1994). It portrays the
level of credibility, expertise, experience
and knowledge of an individual. This
statement is in line with the understanding
brought by the resource dependency theory
that board members’ level of education
would provide sources in form of expertise
(Hillman et al., 2002). With higher
capabilities in managing the organization
and coupled with the ability to understand
the financial matters, the management with
higher education is said to be able to deal
with money related conflict, management
control and strategic vision processing
capability (Amran & Ahmad, 2011).
Referring to the issue of corporate reporting,
there is a positive relationship between the
top management's education level and the
company's strategic decision-making
processes involving the financial reporting
(Papadakis, Lioukas & Chambers 1998;
Balta, Woods & Dickson, 2010). As
depicted by Akhtaruddin and Rouf (2011),
any strategic decision of disclosing relevant
accounting information lies in the hand of
the BOD. Hence, the BODs with higher
level of education s are essential in
providing broader perspective (Akhtaruddin
& Raof, 2011) that will assist companies to
understand the needs of different
stakeholders, particularly on the issue of
corporate philanthropy, CSR and its
disclosure (Bursa Malaysia, 2007; Michelon
& Parbonetti, 2012; Moses and Oba, 2012).
In fact, directors with Masters and doctorate
qualifications are seen to have the capability
of applying research techniques which leads
to more extensive and in- depth analysis.
This ability contributes to the uniqueness of
ideas in shaping policy and addressing
issues as well as making strategic decisions
(Milliken & Martins, 1996; Westphal and
Milton, 2000; Bathula, 2008). Knowledge
and skills attained from the higher education
will also ensure good supervisions and
reduce information asymmetry. This
eventually leads to better corporate
disclosures (Chemmanur & Paeglis, 2005;
Alexandrina, 2013). They also have the
capability to assess and address the risks
(Berger, Kick & Schaeck, 2012) of any
disclosure made by the company. These
arguments are empirically documented by
Akhtaruddin and Rouf (2011) and in
Alexandrina (2013). Based on the above
arguments, the following hypothesis is
proposed:
H1: There is a positive relationship between
the proportion of board members graduated
with an advanced degree and the level of CP
disclosure.
2.2 Field of Education
Specific educational backgrounds of
directors contribute to the resources,
knowledge and skills that are valuable to the
firm. This is in line with the notion brought
by resource dependency theory (Hillman et
al. 2002). The relevance of the knowledge
possessed by directors also significant in
strengthening the effectiveness of
monitoring and oversights function which is
vital for the formation of corporate reporting
(Nahar, 2010) including the CP disclosure.
