Page 1 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 118
The Evidence for Conservation Benefits from Ecotourism in
Kurdistan Region of Iraq
1Mariwan Qadir Rahim
Sulaimani Environmental Directorate
Abstract
Currently, ecotourism has been grown as a
result of developing global apprehension for
disappearing cultures and ecosystems, tourism
development which can destroy a protected
area and have impact on social and
economical development. Tourism in
Kurdistan Region of Iraq has been grown with
economical development especially in tourist
seasons. The aim of this paper is to show the
benefits of ecotourism in Kurdistan Region as
evidence for conservationist. To implementing
the ecotourism project in high biodiversity
value landscapes might be facing many
constrictions, which are affected the quality
and mission of the project. In Kurdistan region
ecotourism might be face financial problem,
which is affect the fate of the project. The
technical staffs that have more experience with
ecotourism are one of another limitation factor
in Kurdistan. The ecotourism might be faced
some limitation factor as legislation to apply
projects, Therefore, ecotourism project is
needed strong policy in order to protect
people’s right. The importance of this study in
the process of conservation work especially
using land of indigenous people should have
benefits for local communities in order to
implementing the project.
Keywords: Ecotourism, Conservation, and
biodiversity
Background
Currently, ecotourism has been grown
as a result of developing global apprehension
for disappearing cultures and ecosystems,
tourism development which
can destroy a protected area and have
impact on social and economical development
(Ceballos-Lascurain, 1990 quoted in (Wearing
& Neil, 1999). This Short note summarizes
how to use ecotourism as a mechanism to
protect the environment of Kurdistan Region
and benefit for indigenous people with
evidence.
Tourism in Kurdistan Region of Iraq has
been grown with economical development
especially in tourist seasons (see Fig 1.)(Sarky,
2007) This growth in tourism might be affecting
the beauty of Kurdistan, if it is not managed
appropriately. One of the treatments is to
persuading the people and the government to
consider about the ecotourism, which has less
effect on environment than general tourism. It is
necessary to protect our environment by
implementing conservation projects and using
ecotourism as a tool to conserve the natural
heritage, which is useful for local people’s
livelihood and for environment. According to
(UN, 2010), tourism is “a social, cultural and
economic phenomenon related to the movement
of people to places outside their usual place of
residence, pleasure being the usual motivation”.
While, ecotourism has different definition and,
there is not standard definition for ecotourism
(Hvenegaard 1994; IUCN 1993, cited in
(Hvenegaard, 1998). Hetzer (1965), who is one
of the first person that mentioned the ecotourism
have four ‘pillars’ which is: minimizing
environmental impacts, respecting host cultures,
maximizing the benefits to local people, and
maximizing tourist satisfaction(Blamey, 2001).
However the conservation and environmental
goals should be reached, which is suggested by
most of experts (Boo 1990; Buckley 1994;
Lindberg, Enriquez and Sproule 1996; Wallace
Page 2 of 7
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 119
and Pierce 1996, cited in (Hvenegaard, 1998).
The term of ecotourism can be defined as
``product'' or as a functioning
``principle''(Campbell, 1999). Scheyvens has
expressed the ecotourism as “environmentally
responsible, enlightening travel and visitation to
relatively undisturbed natural areas in order to
enjoy and appreciate nature”(Scheyvens, 1999).
The International Ecotourism Society (TIES)
defines ecotourism as “responsible travel to
natural areas that conserves the environment and
improves the well-being of local people” (TIES,
1990, p. 9, cited in(de los Angeles Somarriba- Chang & Gunnarsdotter, 2012).
Fig. 1. Number of tourists who visit Kurdistan
Region of Iraq from (2008-2012) sources of
data from (Sarky, 2007).
The Constraints to implementation of
ecotourism projects
To implementing the ecotourism project
in high biodiversity value landscapes might be
facing many constrictions, which are affected
the quality and mission of the project.
Outstanding to reach objectives should have be
a strong collaboration, connection and protect
of the right of local people homogeneity
(CBD, 2010). Therefore, these types of project
act directly against the local people’s
economic interest, which is eliminated from
properties and wildlife exploitation that they
had admission it formerly. Furthermore,
Conflict with local people’s necessities and
requirements has happened to achieve
conservation object. The most origin causes of
this conflict might be results from enforce on
land use and executive applies of a site such as
agriculture and fishing or activities such as
hunting. Consequently, to assimilate local
development with environmental conservation
and effective conservation initiates needed the
active participation of local communities in
decision-making processes(Dimitrakopoulos et
al., 2010). In addition, to implement the
conservation projects with ecotourism there
are many constraints which is facing the
environmental NGO and the governmental
organizations as follow as explained:
Conflict with Local people
According to (Neil, 2009), who
mentioned that the community may interact
many conflicual issues to development of
tourism generally.
Avoiding local people
contribution from decision-making
about the ecotourism projects.
After establishment of legislative
mechanism to involve the indigenous
people in decision-making, the
government has no any positive step to
implementing the role.
After executive the project, there
are no benefits for locals, because it is
exploited commercially.
Affect on the consistency and
construction of the people.
The social change will be
accelerated meaningfully by rapid
development of tourism.
According to (Wearing & Neil, 2009) local
communities comprise groups with different
and potentially conflicting Interests (see
Fig.2.). That is, not all groups want the same
things.
Page 3 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 2
February 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 120
Fig.2.Stakeholders and their needs, redraw the
figure from (Wearing, S., & Neil, J. , 2009).
Financial constraints
In Kurdistan region ecotourism might
be face financial problem, which is affect the
fate of the project. Furthermore, in many
developing countries to implementing the
ecotourism projects, budgetary limitations are
often very serious. The insufficient of funds
are the most common phenomenon. This
constraint can be discouraging and damaging
the conservation achievement especially in
monitoring phase. For instance, some natural
reserve are poorly protected because of the
management have poor financial condition and
included the huge area to protect it (Kiss,
1990, cited in (Winkler, 2011).
Limitation in manpower and technical staff
The technical staffs that have more
experience with ecotourism are one of another
limitation factor in Kurdistan. Getting loans or
grants from international organizations,
charity, government or banks can solve a lack
of funds but work has to be done by people,
especially people in the field. Therefore, this is
perhaps the most important constraint of all.
Thus, without properly trained technical staff
the projects will be fail, local people is know
how to protect and maintain any project
(UNEP, 2005). According to (FAO, 1990)
identify the needs of technical staff, the
following factors must be considered:
Numbers, levels, basic
qualifications and sources of staff.
Training needs including type
of training and time schedule.
Incentive needs for field staff
and local people especially for those
stationed in remote areas.
Policy constraints and others
Ecotourism project is needed strong
policy in order to protect people’s right,
because when the government want to
implement a new project on land, most of the
lands are owned by local people or they used
for agriculture or they used as place for
grazing their livestock. Therefore the
government should be considering the
indigenous people’s right. Hence, the
ecotourism might be faced some limitation
factor as legislation to apply projects.
According to (Thomas, 2008) Policy
constraints can be termed as “attitudinal,
historical, structural, process-based, political,
and ideological”. The management of
conservation projects might be face some
political issues, when implementing and
creation of new project, which tend to be the
subject of bureaucratic systems disposed to the
influence of political personalities who may or
may not support the conservation project
during their term in office(Dygico, Songco,
White, & Green, 2013). For example,
according to (Dimitrakopoulos et al., 2010), in
Greece, both the inclusion of social issues and
the participation of multiple environmental
stakeholders during decision- making
processes were until recently very limited.
This has resulted in negative attitudes and
protests from local communities and in the
inadequate management of protected areas.
However, the establishment of 28 management
authorities in Greece in recent years implies a
possible shift towards increased public and
