Page 1 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 03
March 2016
Available online:http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 138
Capital Structure and Firm Performance: Evidence from
Nepalese Manufacturing Companies
Yuga Raj Bhattarai1
Abstract
The main purpose of the study was to examine the effect of capital structure on the performance of
manufacturing companies listed at the Nepal Stock Exchange. Secondary data of eight
manufacturing were obtained from the published annual reports and financial statements of the
respective companies covering the years 2004-2014. The results of multiple regressions analysis
show that capital structure has a significant negative relationship with the performance of Nepalese
manufacturing companies. In addition to capital structure, the firm performance is significantly
positively associated to the firm size but negatively associated to the tangibility. The study
concludes that higher use of debt in capital structure reduces the performance of Nepalese
manufacturing companies.
Keywords: Capital Structure; Firm Performance; Nepal Stock Exchange; Financial Statement.
I. Introduction
Capital structure has been a major issue in
financial economics ever since Modigliani and
Miller showed in 1958 that given frictionless
markets, homogeneous expectations, the
capital structure decision of the firm is
irrelevant. The capital structure of a firm is
generally the specific mix of debt and equity
the firm uses to finance its operations (Abor,
2005). The difficulty facing companies when
structuring their finance is to determine its
impact on performance, as the performance of
the business is crucial to the value of the firm
and consequently, its survival. Managers have
numerous opportunities to exercise their
discretion with respect to capital structure
decisions. Thus, the capital structure decision
is crucial given that it has an effect on the
financial performance of firms.
1
Mr. Bhattarai is a Associate Professor at Patan Multiple
Campus, Tribhuvan University and a Ph.D. Scholar at
Tribhuvan University, Nepal. He can be reached at
yugarajbhattarai@gmail.com
The capital structure employed may not be
meant for value maximization of the firm but
for protection of the manager’s interest
especially in organizations where corporate
decisions are dictated by managers and shares
of the company closely held (Dimitris, and
Psillaki, 2008). Even where shares are not
closely held, owners of equity are generally
large in number and an average shareholder
controls a minor proportion of the shares of
the firm.
The optimal capital structure is considered as
an outcome of the reciprocal relationship
(trade-off) between the benefits of the tax
savings resulting from the use of debt as a
source of funding and the risk of bankruptcy
resulting from high debt, which is pressing
toward the use of owners’ funds to finance the
company’s needs for funds level. Therefore,
the funding decision is considered as one of
the most complex decisions taken by the
administration, which is represented by the
optimal mix of owners’ funds and borrowing
money to finance the company’s need for
funds, which results in a reduction in the cost
of capital to a minimum with risks remaining
within the acceptable range, which is
positively related to firm performance and
reflected on the market value of the
Page 2 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 03
March 2016
Available online:http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 139
company’s shares, which is reflected in the
wealth of the owners of the company.
Combinations of equity and debt in firms’
capital structures have been identified by
scholars (Tian and Zeitun, (2007), Champion,
(1999), Gosh et al, (2000), Hadlock and
James, (2002), Abor, (2005), San and Heng,
(2011), and Chakraborty (2010) to affect
current and future financial operations of the
firm. Debt, a tax deductible expense, seems
cheap when minimal as the after-tax cost is
lower than equity improving earnings per
share and dividend per share. Increasing levels
of debt in a firm’s capital structure increases
its after-tax cost, negatively affecting
corporate financial performance. Corporate
financial performance is directly influenced by
its market position (Ross et al., 1996); risk
(Fruhan, 1979); economic growth (Varaiya et
al 1987); size of the company (Mathur and
Kenyon, 1997); capital structure (Kakani et
al.,2011) and total assets (Beaver et al, 1970).
This study is one of such and it aims at
providing empirical evidence in confirming
the validity of the theories to assist the firm’s
management in determining the best capital
structure that enhance firm performance. The
study aims to analyze the effect of capital
structure on firm performance for listed firms
in the Nepalese Stock Exchange. The findings
of this study may enable corporate managers
understand how debt and equity mix affect the
firm performance and will then adopt an
appropriate source of financing. It is hoped to
be useful to academicians as a source of
knowledge for further research.
The rest of the study is divided into: section 2
reviews the theoretical framework and related
studies; section 3 includes the methodology;
section 4 presents the results and discussion;
and section 5 incorporates the conclusions and
recommendation.
II. Theoretical framework
Theories of capital structure
The capital structure of a firm could be
explained, in general terms, by three dominant
theories; The Modigliani-Miller Theory, The
trade-off Theory and The Pecking Order
Theory.
The theory of business finance in a modern
sense starts with the Modigliani and Miller
(1958) capital structure irrelevance
proposition. According to MM (1958)
investors and firms are assumed to have equal
access to financial markets, which allows for
homemade leverage. The investor can create
any leverage that was wanted but not offered,
or the investor can get rid of any leverage that
the firm took on but was not wanted. As a
result, the leverage of the firm has no effect on
the market value of the firm.
The original version of the trade-off theory
grew out of the debate over the Modigliani- Miller theorem. When corporate income tax
was added to the original irrelevance, this
created a benefit for debt in that it served to
shield earnings from taxes. Since the firm's
objective function is linear, and there is no
offsetting cost of debt, this implied 100% debt
financing.
The pecking order theory does not take an
optimal capital structure as a starting point,
but instead asserts the empirical fact that firms
show a distinct preference for using internal
finance over external finance. If internal funds
are not enough to finance investment
opportunities, firms may or may not acquire
external financing, and if they do, they will
choose among the different external finance
sources in such a way as to minimize
Page 3 of 13
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/index.php/JSMaP
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 03
March 2016
Available online:http://internationaljournalofresearch.org/ P a g e | 140
additional costs of asymmetric information.
According to Akerlof (1970), the latter costs
basically reflect the “lemon premium” that
outside investors ask for the risk of failure for
the average firm in the market. The resulting
pecking order of financing is as follows:
internally generated funds first, followed by
respectively low-risk debt financing and share
financing.
Review of related studies
Major studies related to capital structure and
firm performance have been reviewed as
follows:
Safarova (2010) analyzed the factors that
determine firm performance of New Zealand
listed companies and discovered that size is
the most important factor determining firm
performance, followed by growth and
leverage, while other factors such as
tangibility, corporate governance, cash on
hand and risk appeared to be marginally
related to firm operating performance.
Pouraghajan et al (2012) analyzed the impact
of capital structure on the financial
performance of companies listed on the
Tehran Stock Exchange using a sample of 400
firm-years among Companies Listed on the
Tehran Stock Exchange in the form of 12
industrial groups during the years 2006 to
2010. They discovered, from the results, that
there is a significant negative relationship
between debt ratio and financial performance
of companies, and a significant positive
relationship between asset turnover, firm size,
asset tangibility ratio, and growth
opportunities with financial performance
measures.
Salteh et al (2012) investigated the impact of
capital structure on firm performance, using
five performance measures (including return
on equity, return on assets, earning per share,
market value of equity to the book value of
equity and Tobin's Q) as dependent variable
and four capital structure measures (including
short-term debt, long- term debt and total debt
to total assets, and total debt to total equity) as
independent variable. They selected 28 Iranian
companies listed in Tehran Stock Exchange
(TSE) as a sample. The study covered 2005 to
2009. The results indicate that firm
performance, which is measured by
(ROE,MBVR & Tobin's Q) is significantly
and positively associated with capital
structure, while there is a negative relation
between capital structure and (ROA, EPS).
They concluded that firm performance is
positively or even negatively related to capital
structure.
Valentin (2012) asserted that a company’s
financial performance is directly influenced by
its market position. The author also identified
risk and growth as important factors
influencing a firm’s financial performance.
The size of the company can also have a
positive effect on financial performance
because the larger firms can use this
advantage to get some financial benefits in
business relations.
Abbas et al. (2013) carried a study on
determinants of firm’s financial performance,
using the textile sector of Pakistan for their
study, and found that firm’s performance is
significantly affected by short - term leverage,
size, risk, tax and non - debt tax shield.
Fosu (2013) studied 257 South African listed
firms using panel data to investigate the
relationship between capital structure and firm
performance, paying particular attention to the
degree of industry competition, found that
financial leverage has a significant positive
effect on firm performance.
