Page 1 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 4
April 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 217
Motivation for Second Language Learning among Kiswahili
Learners of English: A Case study of CILOS, Dar es Salaam
Asteria Gabriel Ngaiza
Department of Management, Moshi Co-operative University (MoCU)
P. O. Box 474, Kilimanjaro-Tanzania
E-mail: asteria.ngaiza@mocu.ac.tz
Abstract
This study investigates motivation factors
for learning English among Kiswahili
learners of English. The study is a
descriptive one which involved 20 Kiswahili
learners who were learning English as their
second language at Cilos center for
language courses in Dar es Salaam. A
questionnaire comprising 20 item statements
to elicit learners’ motives for learning
English was used as a method for data
collection. The study used Gardener’s
integrative-instrumental motivations. The
findings indicate that the learners were
motivated with the level of instrumental
significantly higher than that of integrative
motivation. The study suggests that English
as Second Learning (ESL) teachers should
try to use a variety of motivation strategies
and a variety of tasks in order to strength
learners’ motivation in second language
learning.
Keywords: motivation, English as Second
Language (ESL), English as Foreign
Language (EFL)
Introduction
Motivation is one of the most important
concepts in psychology. Theories
concerning motivation have attempted to
explain why humans behave and think as
they do. The notion is also of great
importance in language education. Teachers
and students commonly use the term to
explain what causes success or failure in
learning. Indeed, motivation provides the
primary impetus to initiate second or foreign
language (L2) learning and later the driving
force to sustain the long learning process.
Without sufficient motivation, individuals
with the most remarkable abilities cannot
accomplish long-term goals. For language
learners, mastery of language may be seen
as a goal. Motivation is one of the most
Page 2 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 4
April 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 218
important prerequisites for learning a second
language; motivation affects the way you
practice, what you observe and what you do
(Dörnyei, 2001a). Motivation has been
thought to be a very important factor
determining whether or not a learner can
acquire second language successfully since
highly motivated students do seem to be
more successful in terms of acquiring a
language (Logan, 1969 & Dörnyei, 2001b).
Further, Yashima (2002) affirms that,
factors like motivation, anxiety, and attitude
have an effective role in language
achievement and proficiency. When learners
start learning a language, they may already
have some motives for learning it.
However, the motive may vary widely from
person to person. Some people may learn an
L2 (Second Language) for the pure intrinsic
enjoyment that comes with learning a new
language while others may learn it in order
to obtain the extrinsic reward such as
passing an examination.
Empirical Studies on Motivation to
Second Language Learning
The study on motivation as a predictor of
second language learning performance was
initiated by Robert Gardner and his
Canadian colleagues. A lot of researches on
second language acquisition have provided
empirical evidence on the relationship
between language achievement and
motivation, for instance (Bernaus &
Gardner, 2008; Csizér & Dörnyei, 2005; Yu
& Watkins, 2008). As far as language is
concerned, motivation is defined as a
“combination of effort plus desire to achieve
the goal of learning a language plus
favourable attitude towards learning a
language” (Gardner, 1985). In his socio- educational model, Gardner describes two
kinds of motivation: integrative and
instrumental, with much emphasis on
integrative motivation. Integrative
motivation refers to learners’ desire to at
least communicate or at most integrate (or
even assimilate) with the members of the
target language. Instrumental motivation
refers to more functional reasons for
learning the language such as getting a
better job, a higher salary or passing an
examination.
Studies by Taylor, Meynard and Rheault
(1977); Ellis (1997), and Crookes et al.
(1991) indicate that integrative and
instrumental motivation types are essential
elements of success when learning a second
language. In some of the early researches
conducted by Gardner and Lambert,
Page 3 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 4
April 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 219
integrative motivation was viewed as being
of more importance in a formal learning
environment than instrumental motivation
(Ellis, 1997). In later studies, integrative
motivation has continued to be emphasized,
although now the importance of
instrumental motivation is also stressed.
Similarly, Noels (2001) suggests that both
integrative and instrumental orientations
help to sustain efforts in learning a second
language, though integrative orientation may
not exist in particular contexts especially in
EFL settings where learners have limited
contact with the L2 community or culture. In
that case integrative orientation could be less
important than instrumental orientation to
promote successful L2 learning in some
particular contexts. However, it is important
to note that instrumental motivation has only
been acknowledged as a significant factor in
some researches, whereas integrative
motivation has been continually linked to
successful second language acquisition. It
has been generally found out that in most
cases students select instrumental reasons
more frequently than integrative reasons for
the second language learning.
Gardner and Lambert (1972) assert that
individuals with an integrative orientation
would demonstrate greater motivation in
learning L2, and, thus, achieve greater L2
competence. This is in agreement with
Gardner and Lambert (1959) who upheld the
relative importance of the integrative
orientation in L2 acquisition. However,
Chihara and Oller, (1978); Gardner and
Lambert, (1972); and Lukmani, (1972) did
not support the model either because it was
found that instrumental orientation predicted
L2 outcomes as well as, or better than,
integrative orientation, or because
integrative orientation had a negative
correlation with proficiency.
In Tanzania, Mwalimu (1997) noted that
students in tertiary colleges (e.g IDM
Mzumbe and Moshi Cooperative College)
who were instrumentally motivated
performed better in their Communication
Skills course. The students had a positive
attitude towards the course because the
course assisted them to achieve other ends
such as improving their study skills and
improving their English. On the other hand,
he noted that those students with
unfavorable attitude and low motivation did
not conceive the utilitarian value of the
course for their academic achievement
hence scored low in this subject. A similar
argument is also put forward by Brown
