Page 1 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 7
July 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 55
On The Fisher Effect: A Review
Mpho Bosupeng
Institution: University of Botswana Finance Graduate Country: Botswana
Email: bosupengmpho@hotmail.com
Abstract
The Fisher effect proposes that in the long
run, nominal interest rates trend positively
with inflation. In numerous studies the
long run Fisher effect has been proved
several times as compared to the short run
Fisher effect phenomenon. The reason is in
the long run, interest rates exhibit
minimum volatility therefore resulting in
the long run association. Even though the
literature has been impressive in terms of
validating the hypothesis, many central
banks and policy makers have been lost in
the lurch regarding the overall standpoint
of the Fisher parity. This paper reviews the
Fisher effect and examines factors that
impinge on the hypothesis namely:
inflation targeting, data set range and the
regulation of the financial system.
JEL: E43
KEYWORDS: Fisher effect; interest
rates; inflation
INTRODUCTION
The Fisher effect is an equilibrium relation
every central bank values and appreciates.
The theory postulates that nominal interest
rates rise together with inflation in the long
run while real interest rates remain
indifferent to this transaction following
Fisher (1930). Many central banks
securities such as certificates and bonds
usually have fixed real interest rates. In
practical terms, real interests are not
always stagnant. In effect, the direct
relationship between nominal interest rates
and inflation changes over time which
impinges on the Fisher effect.
When carrying out univariate tests such as
the Augmented Dickey Fuller test (ADF),
KPSS and the Phillips and Perron test, the
stationarity of interest rates differs as you
carry out the tests at different levels such
as level, first and second difference. An
overview of the literature shows that the
Fisher effect is not conclusive. The
relationship differs from one study to
another and results range from
nullification to full Fisher effect. In many
studies, the Fisher effect surfaces more
when the data in consideration is large thus
affirming the long run Fisher effect. In
comparison, the short run Fisher effect
does not appear often because in the short
term, inflation and real interest rates are
volatile. This in consequence, invalidates
the Fisher parity. Many central banks are
aware of the failure of this phenomenon in
the short run. Practically, the Fisher effect
is a useful tool in inflation targeting
because nominal interest can be set to
control inflation to a certain extent.
Inflation targeting has been useful to many
central banks because it provides a
roadmap of a particular country’s inflation.
Also, since inflation cannot be controlled
directly, the Fisher parity is the mainstay
of inflation targeting. The hypothesis has
also been an important concept in the field
of financial asset returns because it
provides an approximation of the actual
returns while accounting for changes in
inflation.
Even though studies have examined the
Fisher effect globally, numerous studies
focused on the Fisher effect in the United
Page 2 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 7
July 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 56
States of America (US). This is probably
because the US affects the world greatly in
many macroeconomic factors such as
interest rates, exchange rates, gross
domestic product, and inflation. To a
reasonable extent, these factors could be
examined separately when considering
spillovers especially interest rates and
inflation (see Bosupeng, 2015). The
literature on the Fisher effect is numerous
but few papers have been documented to
reveal the overall standpoint of the Fisher
effect. Therefore, there is a need to provide
central banks with a clear direction to be
able to make informed decisions about the
overall standpoint of the literature. The
focus with most studies has been to
validate the hypothesis using advanced
methodology and policy makers have been
lost in the lurch as the results were not
consistent. This paper solves the glitch by
attempting to provide a review of the
extant literature and a conclusion based on
the numerous studies. In short, this study
answers the question: where is the Fisher
effect heading? In general, most studies
which examined the Fisher effect do not
account for several factors that can
impinge on the validity of the Fisher
effect. For instance, the Fisher effect in
one country may not surface due to factors
such as inflation targeting, monetary
policy shocks and the deregulation of the
financial system. These factors have to be
accounted for and can impinge on the
anticipated positive relationship between
nominal interest rates and inflation. For
instance, in some economies such as
Australia the Fisher effect fails prior to the
financial deregulation but appears to
surface after the liberation of the financial
system. This paper is structured as follows.
Next is the literature review section and
will be followed by different factors
affecting the Fisher effect. Then a
conclusion and summary of the study
follows with implications.
The Fisher Effect Affirmation
The Fisher effect has been affirmed in
many studies especially those which used
a wider data span. Malliaropulos (2000)
aimed to investigate if inflation and
interest rates in the US are trend
stationary. Using Vector Autoregressive
(VAR) models, the author concluded that
the Fisher effect holds in the medium to
the long term. The results of this study are
proportionate to the study carried out by
Million (2004). The author examined the
long run relationship between nominal
interest rates and inflation while
accounting for structural breaks and mean- reversion using the Threshold
Autoregressive (TAR) test. Further
analysis employed cointegration tests.
Consequently, the study proved that the
Fisher effect appears to be strong in the
US. In Asia, the Fisher effect was valid for
eight economies under investigation
(China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Korea,
Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and
Thailand) following Ahmad (2010). In the
UK, the Fisher hypothesis was examined
by Granville & Mallick (2004). The study
supported the validity of the Fisher effect
using a wide data span. The Turkish
economy’s Fisher effect was proved by
Incekara et al. (2012) using cointegration
methodology. The study revealed that in
the long run, the Fisher effect is valid but
fails to hold in the short term. Many
studies generally channelled much
attention to validate the hypothesis in each
economy. Toyoshima & Hamori (2011) in
consequence, examined the Fisher effect
using a panel of monthly data from 1990
to 2010 for the US, UK and Japan. The
study applied cointegration tests and
supported the existence of the Fisher effect
in the three economies. The investigation
supported previous studies which have
validated the Fisher effect such as Bassil,
(2010); Ito, (2009); Westerlund, (2008)
and Atkins & Coe (2002). The hypothesis
Page 3 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 7
July 2016
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 57
was further validated by Berument &
Jelassi (2002) through multi country
analysis.
Tsong and Lee (2009) aimed to provide
possible explanations for the empirical
failure of the Fisher effect in terms of
economic shocks by using quantile
cointegration methodology proposed by
Xiao (2009). The investigation analysed
six OECD countries from 1957 to 2012
and the results suggested that nominal
interest rates move together in the long
run. In contribution, Pelaez (1995) aimed
to test for a long run equilibrium
relationship between expected inflation
and actual inflation. The study tested for
cointegration between the variables using
Treasury bills data from 1959 to 1993. The
results proved that the variables were
cointegral over the period of examination.
Lanne (2001) examined monthly US data
covering the period 1953 to 1990 and
further supported the Fisher effect in the
interest rate targeting period of 1953 to
1979. In Europe, Jareno & Tolentino
(2013) found positive affiliations between
variations in the current expected inflation
rate and the variations in nominal interest
rates. The Fisher effect was examined
using causality test by Daniels et al.
(1996). The research proved that in the
long run, there is a unidirectional causality
from inflation rates to the rate of interest.
This implies a long term relationship and
affirms the Fisher effect. A summary of
the results of the aforementioned studies is
that the Fisher effect surfaces more in the
long term than in the short run. This is
because in the short run, interest rates and
inflation dynamics are highly unstable
which nullifies the expected positive
relationship. Even though recent studies
use advanced methodologies the results
commensurate with those of previous
studies such as Mishkin (1992); Wallace &
Warner, (1993); Evans & Lewis, (1995);
Paul, (1984); and Crowder, & Hoffman
(1996). Even though advances in
methodology and design are important, the
Fisher parity has been nullified in several
economies. The next section of the
literature now focuses on studies that
rejected the Fisher hypothesis.
Comparatively, the short run Fisher effect
has not been supported in many studies.
The Fisher Effect Nullification
Generally, when examining the Fisher
effect over a wide span there is a high
probability that the positive relationship
between nominal interest rates and
inflation may hold. Asemota & Bala
(2011) for instance aimed to investigate
the presence of the Fisher effect in Nigeria
using unit root test and cointegration
methodology. The study failed to find
evidence of the long run Fisher effect from
1961 to 2009. Koustas and Lamarche
(2010) used tests for unit roots and argued
that nominal interest rates and inflation
can drift apart from one another
indefinitely which invalidate the Fisher
effect. The Fisher effect was further
annulled by Koustas & Serletis (1999)
using the King & Watson (1997)
methodology. The study rejected the
Fisherian link between inflation and
nominal interest rates. The failure of the
Fisher effect was further provided by
Arisoy (2013) using data from 1987 to
2010 for the Turkish economy. The study
used cointegration tests and time varying
parameters approach.
Ghazali & Ramlee (2003) examined the
presence of the Fisher effect in G7
countries using an Autoregressive
Fractionally Integrated Moving average
model. The study showed that interest
rates in the G7 countries are not linked to
inflation rates in the long run (1974-1996).
In extension to the extant literature,
Coppock & Poitras (2000) found evidence
