Page 1 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 7

July 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 12

Comparative study of perceived service quality between Bank of

Ceylon and Commercial Bank in Batticaloa District

Mr. V.J. Delima ; Mr. V. Pioshan

Assistant Lecturer in Management, Department of Management, Eastern University, Sri Lanka

d_jeniston@hotmail.com

Graduate, Department of Commerce, Eastern University, Sri Lanka

pioshanb2@gmail.com

Abstract

Banks are financial institution where

accept the deposits from their customers

and providing loan facilities to them.

Nowadays banks are very important service

provider in the world .Providing the quality

of service has gained momentum and in

particular the banking sector is the main

focus of attention for its quality of services.

This study is based on SERVQUAL scale

model. A sample size of 200 was taken

using convenient sampling method

covering BOC and Commercial bank in

Batticaloa district. This research aimed at

applying SERVQUAL model to examine the

service quality between BOC and

Commercial Bank in Batticaloa district.

While the previous researchers had already

examined the qualities services on banking,

the current research attempted to fill the

gap in the literature by applying

SERVQUAL model to study the quality of

banking services rendered by the banks in

Batticaloa district. The researcher has used

five dimensions of service quality; namely,

tangibles, reliability, responsiveness,

assurance and empathy, as the independent

variables. The result reveals that service

quality of Commercial bank is fairly

satisfied on reliability, responsiveness,

tangible empathy and assurance

dimensions than service quality of BOC in

Batticaloa district.

Keywords: Service quality, SERVQUAl

model

Abbreviation: BOC – Bank of Ceylon

1. Introduction

Banks are most significant financial

institution which provide numerous

financial services to the bank users and

make an impact on nation’s economy. In Sri

Lankan context, banking industry picked up

its progress with new arrival of private

banks. Since that period, banking industry

has been facing forces of competition and

impacts of globalization. Due to the

increasing competition, several new

elements have been included in banking

services. Service quality has become an

important part of a banks. Because both

marketing and service marketing literatures

keep service quality as a critical measure of

organizational performance. It has become

an essential element for achieving

competitive advantage and build customer

satisfaction (Palmer, 1995). According to

Hill and Alexander (2006), customer

satisfaction is inner feelings of customers

how well organization’s products and

services. Service quality can be defined as

the extent to which service fulfills the

customer’s needs or expectations (Lewis

and Mitchell, 1990; Wisniewski and

Donnelly, 1996). According to Spreng and

Machoy (1996), service quality is an

important determinant for achieving

competitive advantage by satisfying

relationship with customers. Moore (1987)

stated that organization which gives an

priority to service quality that can

differentiate form other competitive

organization and it simply earns

competitive advantage. Today banking

industry assumes service quality as an

essential factor. Banks must provide

Page 2 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 7

July 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 13

marketing orientation to their organization

by engaging certain policies and tactics.

Customers’ expectations have been

changing over the years due to

technological advancement and

globalization. Therefore, banks need to

meet the customers’ expectation by

changing the service quality concept over

the years. Because banks have to attract

their customers with high value service

quality to sustain in the market. Nowadays,

many organizations understand that it is

more difficult to make their physical

product to differ from their competitors

than before. As a result, most of them turn

to seek differentiated services.

Organizations build their competitive

advantage by delivering the services on

time, having better trained personal, and

quick resolution for customer complaints.

These activities can gain more attention by

managers with the increasing competition

in market. Nowadays, government and

private banks are providing better services

to their customers to achieve the leader in

the market place and to keep the positive

customer retention. But there is clear

knowledge gap regarding service quality of

government bank and private bank. To

analysis the research problem, Bank of

Ceylon and Commercial Bank are taken.

This knowledge gap becomes a problem of

“whether there is a different between the

service quality of Bank of Ceylon and

Commercial Bank from the perception of

both bank’s customers?” Bank of Ceylon

and Commercial Bank both have own

history in Sri Lankan banking industry.

Both banks are offering similar products

and services to their customers. Therefore,

this research paper gives a better

comparison of service quality between

Bank of Ceylon and Commercial Bank.

2. Research Objectives

1. To identify the service quality of

Bank of Ceylon and Commercial Bank.

2. To identify the difference of service

quality dimensions between Bank of

Ceylon and Commercial Bank

3. To identify the perception of

service quality varies with demographic

factors of the customers

3. Research Questions

1. What is the level of the service

quality of Bank of Ceylon and Commercial

Bank?

2. What are the level of differences of

service quality dimensions between Bank

of Ceylon and Commercial Bank

3. What is perception of service

quality varies with demographic factors of

the customers

4. Significance of the Study

Customers are the key to achieve

competitive advantage by providing high

quality of services. Customers’

expectations and high concern of customers

can generate high quality of services.

Service quality is a vital issue to banks by

attaining customer assessment. Because

customers make comparison between the

services they anticipate with perceptions of

the services they obtain. It can be concluded

that the quality of service is dependent on

two variables expected services and

perceived service. Quality of service should

minimize the gap between expected

services and perceived service. By this way,

banks can build strong reputation and

sustaining ability by continuously meeting

customers’ expectation. This study gives

better comparison of fulfillment of

customer expectation between government

bank and private bank.

5. Literature Review

Service could be defined as activities,

efforts, and performance provided for sales

or related with the sales of goods (Bateson

and Hoffman, 1999; Regan, 1963).

According to Johns (1999), service could

be performance or output or offering or

process. Service providing organization

requires better employees’ interaction with

customers. Customers’ favorable

Page 3 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 02 Issue 7

July 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 14

perception is associated with behavior of

employees. Consequently, customers seek

service as an experience of day to day life

which consists of elements of core need,

choice, and emotional content (Johns,

1999). This service elements could produce

different service output and affect each in

individuals experience differently.

According to Gupta et al. (2005),

researchers started to pay an attention in

service quality when organizations

accepted service quality as a vital factor to

differentiate their services from

competitors. On other hand, Eshghi et al.

(2008) stated that service quality is an

assessment of service by the customers.

According to Wisniewski and Donnelly

(1996), they pointed out that how service

meets customer’s needs or expectations.

Lewis and Booms (1983) defined the

service quality “as a measure of how well

the service level delivered matches

customer expectations”. Parasuraman et al.

(1988) argues that “service quality is the

measure of service delivered as against

expected service performance”. Numerous

service quality models have been identified

to measure in various aspects. Expectancy

disconfirmation model compares

customers’ expectation and their actual

experience of service (Oliver, 1980).

Performance only model focuses on quality

of service by examining level of customers’

satisfaction level with various features of

service (Babakus and Boller, 1992).

Technical and functional dichotomy model

consisted of two elements such as technical

quality and functional quality. Technical

quality is based on product characteristics

such as durability, security, and physical

features. Functional quality is based on

interrelationship between customer and

service provider such as courtesy, speed of

delivery and helpfulness (Gronroos, 1984).

Most studies have been conducted by using

SERVQUAL model which was developed

by Parasuraman et al. (1985). This model

evaluates customers’ expectation and

quality of service by minimizing difference

between expectation and experience.

Nyeck et al. (2002) confirmed that

SERVQUAL model is most comprehensive

model to measure service quality. This

model is widely used to measure service

quality in literature of researches. This

model includes tangibility, reliability,

responsiveness, assurance, and empathy.

According to van Iwaarden et al. (2003),

Tangibility refers to physical facilities bank

employees, equipment, and material

associated with service which are visually

appearing to customers. Reliability denotes

the ability to perform the promised service

on time with error free, complete, and better

information to customers. Responsiveness

refers to level of involvement of employees

to assist the customers and provide them

quick services. Assurance consisted of

courtesy and knowledge of employees and

their ability to build trust of customers.

Empathy is a relationship between

customers and employees and individual

caring that employees provide. Evaluating

service quality is not a simple process

because of difficulty in measuring

customers’ perception. Service quality

concept must be approached from

customers’ perception because it would

provide more accurate findings.

6. Conceptual Framework

(Source: Parasuraman et al., 1985)

7. Methodology

7.1. Population, Sample and Sampling

Procedure

Tangibility

Reliability

Responsiveness

Assurance

Empathy

Service

quality