Page 1 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 8
August 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 42
Nigeria’s Economic Growth: The Impact of Deregulation of
Telecommunication Sector (1999-2013)
Onoja Daniel Abel
Department of Economics, Kogi State University, Anyigba, Kogi State, Nigeria. evelynity@yahoo.com
Tel: +2347033275646
Emmanuel OkokondemOkon
Department of Economics, Kogi State University, Anyigba, Kogi State, Nigeria. E-mail: tonydom57@yahoo.com
Tel: +2348023275716
Abstract
The study examines the impact of deregulation of telecommunication sector on economic growth of Nigeria, 1999-
2013. The main and minor objectives were: to examine the impact of telecommunication infrastructure development
on Nigeria economy: during post deregulation period and to examine how GSM has reduced transport cost in the
course of daily business transactions. Chi-square and econometrics technique were used to analyze the data collected
in order to capture both the main objective and the minor objectives. However, the findings revealed that GSM has
enabled Nigerians to transact their businesses easily by reducing so much transportation cost resulting in higher
productivity. The paper therefore recommends that government should provide non-monetary incentives including
the funding of development of other infrastructure including electricity
Keywords:telecommunication sector, economic growth, Nigeria, post deregulation period, transport cost
1. Introduction
The world has become a global village with
telecommunication being an indispensable tool in the
entire process of globalization. However, it is not in
dispute that telecommunication and information
technology (IT) play essential roles in this process
(Asogwa, 2013). This is obviously why development
in this vital sector over the years has been
phenomenal all over the world. In fact, this is why
emerging trend in socio-economic growth shows high
premium been placed on information and
communication technology (ICT), by nations,
organizations and homes (Lee, 2003).
However, Nigeria today has not been left of
this race for rapid development in this sector, after
years of gross under-development; the nation’s
telecommunication was liberated with the return of
democracy in 1999 and deregulation of
telecommunication sector. This led to the granting of
global system for mobile telecommunication (GSM)
licenses by the Nigeria Communication Commission
(NCC) to three providers like ECONET, MTN, and
M-TEL. This was followed by the licensing of the
Second National Operators (SNO), in 2003. That is,
Global COM and Universal Access services licenses
of 2006 which include fixed telephony, VSAT and
internet service providers. Also in March 2008 the
(NCC) gave license to another GSM operator known
as Etisalat (Aigbinode, 2008). The industry has
enhanced both foreign direct investment (FDI) and
private investment in Nigeria after deregulation which
Page 2 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 8
August 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 43
account for at 18 billion dollar in December, 2010
(NCC, 2011).
The paper considers two main questions:
What is the impact of deregulation of
telecommunication infrastructure development on
Nigeria economy? Has GSM penetration enable
Nigerians to reduce transport cost in the course of
daily business transactions? The paper is organized as
follows: Section 2 overviews; Section 3 presents;
Section 4 addresses some pertinent issues on; Section
5 concludes the paper. Section 2 comprises Literature
review, section 3 discusses the model specification and
methodology, section 4 contains empirical evidences
and their interpretations, and finally section 5 gives
conclusion.
2. Literature Review
Early work on economic growth and
development highlight the necessity of adequate
infrastructure as a basic for development. To Star and
Bowker (2001) infrastructure is embedded within
other structures and technologies. It is transparent in
use, not needing to be reinvented at each use and only
becoming evident when it breaks down. Riketts
(2002) viewed telecommunication as aiding the
coordination of information flow, provides
opportunities for increasing the efficiency of
interaction and coordination, and in this manner
influences the success of economic activities.
Economic activities require significant of interaction
and coordination in order for them to be conducted
successfully and efficiently.
Alleman et a (2004) asserted that a modern
telecommunication infrastructure is not only essential
for domestic economic growth, but also a prerequisite
for participating in increasingly competitive world
market and for attracting new agencies in both
developed and less developed countries, as they
spend large sums of capital on infrastructure
investment so as to positively influence economic
activities in terms of employment, value added,
productivity, capital formation and income.
Furthermore investing in telecommunication like
other infrastructure investments will increase the
demand for the goods and services used in their
production and increase total national output.
According to Belaid (2002) most telecommunication
investment positively affects economy in three ways:
first, reduce the cost of production, second, it
increase employment through both direct and indirect
effects, third, it increases revenue. Vuong (2008)
reported how mobile phones promote economic
growth through an example of fisher men in the south
of Indian by communicating through mobile phones;
they were able to sell their fish in markets where the
demand was high. This resulted in less wasted of fish,
higher benefits and lower cost of doing business,
more access to information, which leads to more
efficient operations which in the end affect the
economic growth positively.
Also Roller and Waveman (2001) and
Waverman et al (2005) in their studies on telecoms,
opined that telecoms growth through many different
ways firstly, according to them, investing in the
telecom sector itself leads to growth, secondly,
increased demand in telecom related goods and
services. Example, producing cables, machines, extra
workloads etc contributes to growth. More
importantly, as telephone technology improves
people communicated more regularly over bigger
distances. It therefore, interesting to note that
telecoms infrastructure has strong positive effects on
economic growth especially for a developing country
like Nigeria(Gold, 2011).
There is also a plethora of evidence in both
the theoretical literature and theoretical framework
on the relationship between telecommunications
infrastructure and economic growth. Saunders et al
(1994) cited by Ding and Haynes (2004) provide a
positive relationship between telecommunications
and economic growth. Intensive review based on the
works of Canning (1998), Cronin et al (1993), Wang
(1999), Schreyer (2000), Yilmaz et al (2001),
International Telecommunication Union- ITU (2003),
Datta and Agarwal (2004), Lam and Siu (2010),
Show a positive and significant causal link between
telecommunications infrastructure and economic
growth.
3 Overview of Telecommunications
Industry in Nigeria: Post-Deregulation
Period
The establishment of Nigeria
communication commission (NCC) in 1992 removes
the monopoly enjoyed by the government
communication institution and by 2002 three GSM
operators (MTEL limited, ECONET Nigeria Ltd and
MTN communications Nigeria Ltd were licensed.
This major achievement in telecommunication
infrastructure increased the tele-density from 0.7 in
2001 to 63.11 in December 2010 (NCC, 2011).
During the count in 2012 telephone penetration stood
Page 3 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 8
August 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 44
at 81 percent at the end of December, 2012,
according to statistics published by the (Nigeria
Communication Commission, 2013). Tele-density
hits 85.25 percent; Nigeria tele-density has increase
from less than 63. 11 percent by end year 2010 to
25.25 percent rise and mobile subscribers in Nigeria
have grown to over 120 million in 12 year (NCC,
2012). The NCC (2013) said active
telecommunication subscriber’s base in the country
peaked at 114.1 million as at the end of January,
2013, an increase of 198.3 million lines over the
figure in the correspondent period at last year. The
major operators, the private investments as well as
the growth tele-density of telecommunication in
Nigeria are depicted in table 1 below.
Table 1: Operators, Investment and Tele-density of Telecom in Nigeria
National carrier Dec.1999 June. 2006 Dec. 2010 Dec.2012
1 1 2
Number of licensed
Mobile Operation (GSM)
and (DNA)
1 10 including operator
with unified license
9(are operatively)
GSM (MTN,
ETISALAT,
CELTEL (NOW
AIRTEL) MTEL,
GLO)SDMA (STAR
COMMS,
VISAFONE,
MULTILINKS and
Zoom)
9(are operatively) GSM
(MTN, ETISALAT,
CELTEL (NOW
AIRTEL) MTEL,
GLO)SDMA (STAR
COMMS, VISAFONE,
MULTILINKS and
Zoom)
Number of active licensed 9 27 16 17
Fixed line operator
private investment
$50M
USD
$8.150M USD $18,000MUSD $25M USD
Tele-density 0.41 23.79 63.11 85.25
Source: NCC (2012) and Adegbemi et al(2012).
The industry received global acclaim as one of the fastest growing mobile market in the world (Ndukwe,
2006) and has enhanced both foreign direct investment (FDI) and private investment in Nigeria, which account for
at $ 18 billion (USD) in December 2010 (NCC, 2011).
The contribution of the communication sector to economic growth is that GDP increased from an average
of 0.4 percent between 1986 and 1989 to about an average of 5 percent between 2006 and 2010, the average annual
growth rate of the GDP rose from about 3.7 percent average between 1986 and 1989 to about an average of 8
percent between 2006 and 2010 (National Bureau of statistics, 1986 and 2007), (Central Bank of Nigeria 2007 and
2009). The industry recorded a real GDP growth of 24.42 percent in the third quarter of 2013 up from 22.12 percent
recorded in the second quarter of the year. Year-on year however, growth has slowed by 7.2 percent points as 31.57
percent was recorded in the third quarter of 2012 (National Bureau of statistics, 2012). (Table 2) show the big leap
observed in the annual growth of telecommunications from 2000 (6 percent) and 2001 (30 percent) can be linked to
the fact that most of the licensed were granted to the GSM provider around this period.
Years Average GDP at
1990 constant base
price=N= million
Average telco
contribution=N=
million
Telco contribution
to GDP %
Average annual
GDP growth rate
%
Average annual
telco growth rate %
1986 – 1989 267, 847 1,073 0. 38 3.71 1.17
1990 – 1993 334,270 1,171 0.35 3.89 2.77
1994 – 1997 360,731 1,340 0. 37 2.49 4.24
1998 – 2001 406, 423 1,757 0.43 3.41 11.57
