Page 1 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
Entrepreneurial Orientation and Women-owned SMEs
Business Performance in Malaysia: Ethics as Mediator
1Umi Kartini Rashid, 2Rosli Mahmood
1Faculty of Technology Management and Business, UniversitiTun Hussein Onn
Malaysia.kartini@uthm.edu.my
2School of Business Management, College of Business, Universiti Utara
Malaysia.rosli@uum.edu.my
Abstract
The contribution of women-owned SMEs
to the economic growth cannot be denied.
This study intends to examine the
possibility of ethics as a mediator on the
relationships between entrepreneurial
orientation’s dimensions and women- owned SMEs business performance in
Malaysia.Hypotheses were built based on
three dimensions of entrepreneurial
orientation that had been widely used by
the researchers, namelyinnovativeness,
proactiveness and risk taking. This study
involved the women-owned SMEs from all
over the country and data collection was
made through questionnaires where the
constructs used were adapted from past
studies and already examined for
reliability. By using multiple regression
analysis, statistical results supported all of
the direct hypotheses confirming the
significant relationships between
innovativeness, proactiveness and risk
taking, and women-owned SMEs business
performance. Ethics was then found to
mediate the relationships between
proactiveness, risk taking and women- owned SMEs business performance.
Theoretical contributions and practical
implications from this study not
onlyimportant for the women-owned SMEs,
but also to the government for the women
entrepreneurial development in the
country. The future implications and
conclusions are also discussed.
Keywords: Entrepreneurial Orientation,
Business Performance, Ethics, Women- owned SMEs, Mediating Effect.
1.0 Introduction
According to Fairlie (2009) in the
Kauffman Index of Entrepreneurial
Activity (1996–2009) Report 2010, every
month more than 550,000 new businesses
were launched by the entrepreneurs in the
United States. In 2007 itself, women
owned 7.8 million businesses and
accounted for 28.7 per cent of all
businesses nationwide (U.S. Census
Bureau, 2010).
In Malaysia as well, 19.7 per cent of
645,136 active business organizations
operating in the country until end of 2010
were owned by women (DOSM, 2011a).
Out of the number, majority of them were
involved in service sector (91.7 per cent),
followed by manufacturing sector with 7
per cent, and less than 1.0 per cent were in
the sectors of construction, agriculture,
mining and quarrying(DOSM, 2011b).
Page 2 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
From the above state, it is clear that year
by year, women participations in the
businesses around the world were
increasing. That is to say, not only they
contribute to the country’s gross domestic
product (GDP), but also enhance another
important role of SMEs to the nation
including the poverty reduction among
women through job creation (Moghadam,
2005; UNDP, 2010a, 2010b; Al-Sadi,
Belwal, & Al-Badi, 2011).
In Malaysia, women-owned SMEs
underperformed is most probably due to
lack of intangible resources: different
behaviour or characteristics of women
entrepreneurs compared to their male
counterparts (Teoh & Chong, 2007). The
authors found that five factors, namely
individual characteristics, management
practices, goals and motivations,
networkingand finallyentrepreneurial
orientation, were found to influence the
performance of Malaysian women
entrepreneurs(Teoh & Chong, 2007). In
other study, Knotts, Jones, and LaPreze
(2004) revealed that women business
owners were less successful, had lower
profits, and engaged in weaker
management practices than their male
counterparts, which further suggested the
unique challenges for women entrepreneur.
The above findings clarified that there
were many factors that contributed to the
success of the women-owned businesses.
Thus, the study attempts to examine the
factors that relate to the success of the
women entrepreneurs, for instance
entrepreneurial orientation (EO) and ethics.
2.0 Literature Review and
Hypothesis Development
2.1 Entrepreneurial
Orientation(EO)
In firm level entrepreneurship literature,
entrepreneurial orientation (EO) is one of
the most common concepts and has been
taken as a strategic dimension.In this study,
EO was conceptualised as consisting of the
variables; 1) innovativeness - the
development of new and unique products,
services or processes; 2) risk taking - a will
to pursue risky opportunities, taking the
chance of failing; and 3) proactiveness - an
emphasis in the persistence and creativity
to overcome obstacles, until the innovator
concept is completely implemented (Miller,
1983), the three dominant dimensions that
are being focused by most of the EO
relevant studies to explain the variance in
the construct, and being considered to give
a great impact in firm’s growth (Miller,
1987; Lumpkin & Dess, 1996).
In addition, the majority of the EO relevant
studies focused only on innovativeness,
proactiveness, and risk taking as the
dominant dimensions to explain the
variance in the construct (Zahra, 1993;
Morris & Sexton, 1996; George & Marino,
2011). This is in line with the study by
Miller (1983) that entrepreneurship
typically would encompass risk taking,
innovation, and proactiveness, and that if
any of these elements were missing
entirely, the process might be considered
“less than entrepreneurial.”
Again, as the three dimensions have been
noted as the essential dimensions of
entrepreneurship and being considered to
give a great impact in firm’s growth
(Miller, 1983; Lumpkin & Dess, 1996).
Furthermore, innovative and proactive
firms that manage risk in rational way will
be more successful by capturing
opportunities that rise in changing
environment and develop new capacity to
attain better performance (Ali & Ali, 2013).
Therefore, “risk taking”, “innovation”, and
“proactiveness” are the dimensions in EO
that will be used in this study as regard to
most of the research in this field (Miller,
1983; Covin & Slevin, 1989, 1990, 1991;
Page 3 of 14
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
Dess, Lumpkin, & Covin, 1997; Wiklund,
1999; Wiklund & Shepherd, 2005).
2.2 Business Performance
To date, research on small and medium
enterprises (SMEs) does not adequately
address the success of socially embedded
subsistence businesses (Paige & Littrell,
2002; Shivani, Mukherjee, & Sharan,
2006). More importantly, due to the
smaller size and slower in growth of the
firms owned by women entrepreneurs
(Hanson, 2009), people might not view a
majority ofwomen-owned businesses as
successful since most people commonly
considermoney and profits as the best way
to measure individual and business success
(Sabarwal & Terrell, 2008; Alam, Mohd
Jani, & Omar, 2011). Therefore, there are
essential problems with measuring
enterprise performance and success in pure
economic outcome terms (Franck, 2012).
Despite various definitions of business
performance in the literature, this study
will be considering business performance
as success from an economic point of view
since business performance is usually
measured from the economicperspectives
of growth in sales or employees; and/or by
the increase in profits(Buttner & Moore,
1997). Masuo et al. (2001) then added that
business success is commonly defined in
terms of economic or financial measures
which include return on assets, sales,
profits, employees and survival rates; and
non-pecuniary measures, such as customer
satisfaction, personal development and
personal achievement. Subjective
measures of financial data will also be
adopted in this study.
2.3 Entrepreneurial
Orientation (EO) and
Women-owned Business
Performance Relationship
Entrepreneurial orientation (EO) is defined
as strategic posture of a firm which
captures specific aspects of the firm’s
decision-making styles, practices, and
methods (Wiklund & Shepherd, 2005), or
in short, indicates a firm’s overall
competitive orientation (Covin & Slevin,
1989, 1990). It has also been proved as one
of the determinant factors that contribute
to the business success (Lumpkin & Dess,
1996). Dess et al. (1997) then further
confirmed that EO is critical for the overall
performance as it demonstrates the use of a
combination of other new strategies to be
able to get the full advantage of the
available business opportunities.
Despite being noted as the essential
dimensions of entrepreneurship and being
considered to give a great impact in firm’s
growth (Miller, 1987; Lumpkin & Dess,
1996), to date, the examination on the
relationship between EO and business
performance has also been conducted
intensively although the available
empirical findings are mixed. Some
studies supported the facts that EO impact
performance positively (Wiklund &
Shepherd, 2005; Walter, Auer, & Ritter,
2006; Wang, 2008; Rauch, Wiklund,
Lumpkin, & Frese, 2009; Davis, Bell,
Payne, & Kreiser, 2010; Kraus, Rigtering,
Hughes, & Hosman, 2011; Al-Swidi &
Mahmood, 2012; Anderson & Eshima,
2013), while others confirmed that the two
variables were not correlated at all
(Andersén, 2010; Messersmith & Wales,
2011). In other cases, some even found
that the dimensions of EO supported
performance partially (Ambad & Abdul
Wahab, 2013; Kreiser, Marino, Kuratko, &
Weaver, 2013; Musa, Ghani, & Ahmad,
2014).
Similarly, studies on the relationships
between EO and women-owned SMEs
