Page 1 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 1
Experimental study on the behaviour of
reinforced concrete thin-walled open
section compression members
1K.Nagaraju, 14FF1D8702, nagarajukaneti.ec@gmail.com
Mandava Institute of Engineering and Technology,
Vidya Nagar, Krishna District, Jaggayyapet, Andhra Pradesh, 521175
2Mr. D. Aditya Sairam, M-Tech. Assistant Professor.
Abstract:
Reinforced cement concrete wall panels are load
bearing integral structural elements of a building
system. The conventional wall panels are heavy,
reinforced at least with minimum percentage of
compression steel and possess handling and erection
problems. Thin-walled reinforced concrete wall
panels may eliminate the above shortcomings of the
conventional wall panels. They are also highly
suitable for modern construction as well as
economical. A thin-walled open section compression
member may be a suitable alternative to the
rectangular thin wall panels to overcome the
stability problems. Various geometrical sections like
channel, trapezoidal and curved sections can be used
in place of conventional wall panels. By virtue of
their geometrical shape, the slenderness effect, hence
the stability problem can be minimized if not
completely eliminated.
The main objective of the investigation is to
study the behaviour of reinforced concrete thin- walled open section compression members with web
stiffener in terms of load bearing capacity, lateral
deflection and failure mode and formulate suitable
design equations if the existing popular equations
are not compatible. Regression analysis based on
experimental data is carried out to suggest minimal
changes to the existing design equations of IS 456 –
2000 and ACI 318 – 1989.
Suitable buckling factors were identified,
optimized and incorporated in the above formulae
without altering the present form of these equations.
The compatibility of the modified IS and ACI
expressions has been tested for channel and
trapezoidal specimens and found to be satisfactory.
Finally comparison of theoretical ultimate loads of
empirical equation, modified ACI precast wall
equation and IS 456 – 2000 short column equation
were made. In order to simplify the modified IS short
column, buckling coefficient for channel and
trapezoidal sections have been computed. All the
three proposed equations are simple to use and yield
reliable estimation of ultimate load. Out of the three
suggested equations, the proposed empirical
equation is the most reliable, very simple to use with
buckling coefficient and nominally conservative in
estimating the ultimate failure load. The maximum
limits of slenderness ratio, height to flange width
ratio, height to thickness ratio and web width to
flange width ratio are suggested to exploit the
section efficiency and material strength effectively. .
Keywords
Reinforced Concrete Thin-Walled Open Section
Compression Members, Regression analysis,
Trapezoidal and Curved Sections.
1. Introduction
Poor people of rural India especially in backward
states and districts are living in kutcha houses or
makeshift shelters. Every year during monsoon
season and associated floods, their living conditions,
sufferings and loss of properties were reported quite
frequently. It is an issue to be addressed immediately
by all stake holders. Most of these houses are built
with mud walls reinforced with paddy straw or
thatched walls made with bamboo reapers and
coconut or palm leaves. The government endeavor in
providing low cost engineered structures is not as
successful as desired. The low cost houses executed
as pilot projects were found to be good and durable.
When the same is executed in rural areas through
contractors and NGO‟s, the ground realities and
ethical values of people involved in execution leaves
much to be desired in terms of quality and
workmanship. These projects in most of the states
are not yielding the expected change in the rural
society.
The solution lies in mass production of elements
of low cost houses in a mechanized and controlled
environment. One of the ways to infuse quality in
such constructions is to go for the mass production of
Page 2 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 2
precast elements of low cost houses as mentioned
above. These precast elements can be assembled at
the site of construction with bare minimum use of
cement and cement concrete, thereby eliminating
avenues of mass profits and unethical activities.
Precast roofing elements are already quite popular
among engineers and are available in wide variety of
structural forms and shapes. These precast roof
elements are thin, light in weight, easy to cast and
handle. Sufficient amount of theoretical procedures
are available to design them to any desired shape and
size. But the precast wall elements are not as popular
as they should be. The reasons may be the heavy
weight of elements, cumbersome construction joints,
handling difficulties and erection problems. These
conventional heavy wall panels also need
conventional foundation, thereby increase the cost of
house. All these inherent disadvantages of traditional
wall panels may be eliminated by reducing the
weight of wall panels without compromising on the
strength, stiffness and stability.
Thin-Walled Open Sections
An ideal precast concrete wall panel fulfilling the
dual functions of load bearing and space covering
need to be strong and light with a wide range of
aesthetic forms. In this context, the advanced
technologies such as high strength concrete,
mechanized casting and logistic techniques appear to
hold much potential in the development of reinforced
concrete thin-walled open section wall elements as a
practical proposition. Such load bearing concrete
thin-walls can even have all types of cross sections,
hitherto familiar to roof panels, such as angular,
folded, ribbed panel, trapezoidal, tee and curved
sections.
Fig 1: The building is covered by a thin six- petaled reinforced concrete shell.
2. Objective of our Research
The main objective of the investigation is to
establish thin-walled open section reinforced
concrete compression members with web stiffener as
a unique category of load bearing elements such as
reinforced concrete columns and to formulate design
expressions based on experiments. The investigation
is accordingly planned to include the following
aspects.
In the first phase of investigation, literature survey
was carried out covering the analytical and
experimental works so far conducted in the area of
the research. A critical review of the published
literature indicates that research work available on
thin-walled compression members is only related to
steel and research on reinforced concrete thin-walled
compression members is few. Moreover no literature
is available on reinforced concrete thin-walled open
section compression members with web stiffener.
However, review of published literature in the area
of the investigation either in reinforced concrete or
otherwise was taken up to identify the parameters of
investigation.
In the second phase of investigation, test
specimens were cast. Forty-eighty numbers of
channel section specimens and thirty-six numbers of
trapezoidal section specimens were cast. The height,
wall thickness, flange width and web width of the
test specimens were varied to effect the change in the
behaviour and load bearing capacity. All the test
specimens were tested to failure in loading frames.
First crack load, lateral deflection, failure load and
failure mode were studied. The modes of failure
were identified as torsional-flexural failure and
flexural failure.
In the third phase, the effect of vertical web
stiffener, increase in wall thickness, slenderness ratio
and height to flange width ratio were examined and
quantified in terms of lateral deflection, first crack
load, failure load, stiffness and ductility factors. A
series of graphs were drawn to illustrate the influence
of above parameters. It is observed that torsional
flexural failure takes place in channel specimens
with slenderness ratio less than 40 and beyond which
flexural failure takes place. The same limit in case of
trapezoidal specimens found to be 30. The above
limit in case of height to flange width ratio is 12 and
10 for channel and trapezoidal specimens
respectively. The web stiffener provided has
significantly enhanced the ultimate load in all the
four series of test specimens, but its contribution is
influenced by the slenderness ratio and height to
flange width ratio. The contribution of web stiffener
in reducing the ultimate lateral deflection is quite
effective but again highly influenced by the above
two parameters. The experimental data of one third
number of specimens were used for validation
purpose.
In the fourth phase, comparison of the
experimental failure load was made with the existing
equations of concrete wall design. Their
compatibility to the types of open sections tested has
been evaluated. Due to lack of compatibility and
Page 3 of 7
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
e-ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 02 Issue 10
October 2016
Available online:http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 3
inconsistent estimation of failure load in different
ranges of slenderness ratio, it was decided to
formulate an empirical expression for open section
compression members without altering the basic
form of existing referred equations. The strength
ratio degradation of test specimens with increase in
slenderness ratio is the basis on which the empirical
equation is formulated. The validity of the proposed
empirical equation for other type of specimens has
been established using validation tests data. In the
second stage of this phase, regression analysis of
channel and trapezoidal specimens data have been
carried out using two exclusive PSO programs
written in MATLAB to suggest minimal
modification to the existing IS 456 – 2000 and ACI –
318 concrete column/wall formulae.
3. Experimental Design
This chapter presents a summary of the
experimental works conducted on thin-walled open
section reinforced concrete compression members
with vertical web stiffener. The experimental work
described in this chapter is the base of the present
investigation. The main objectives of the
experimental work are summarized as follows:
i. To get an insight of the behaviour and the
mode failure of thin-walled singly symmetric open
section reinforced concrete compression members
with vertical web stiffener under axial load.
ii. To find the influence of vertical web
stiffener, slenderness ratio and height to flange width
ratio on the behaviour and load bearing capacity.
iii. To find the beneficial effect vertical web
stiffener in reducing the torsional-flexural buckling
and flexural buckling.
iv. To find the compatibility/suitability of the
existing wall equations to predict the failure load of
thin-walled singly symmetric open section reinforced
concrete compression members with vertical web
stiffener under axial load.
v. To get adequate experimental data to
formulate necessary design expression empirically as
well as based on regression analysis.
vi. To verify and validate the proposed design
equations with additional experiments.
To achieve the above objectives, thin-walled
reinforced concrete singly symmetric open section
compression members made of channel and
trapezoidal sections were tested.
Test Specimens
The thin-walled reinforced concrete compression
members of above mentioned open sections tested in
the present study are classified under the following
two major categories as shown in Figure below:
Series C - Compression members with
singly symmetric channel section.
Series T - Compression members with
singly symmetric trapezoidal section.
Figure 2: 3D View and Sectional Plan of Channel
and Trapezoidal Test Specimens
The details of cross section of the test specimens
are shown in Figure below:
Figure 3: Cross Sectional Details of Channel and
Trapezoidal Test Specimens
The details of the channel section specimens
tested are given in Figure below:
