Page 1 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 02 I s s ue 12

Dec ember 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 187

An Empirical Study Of Service Quality Measurements & Gap Analysis With

Special Referenes Of Govt/Charitable Hospitals In Haryana

Mr. Hawa Singh

Research Scholar, IMSAR,

M.D.University,Rohtak(Hr).

Email id:hawasingh2009@gmail.com

Abstract: India has been able to keep pace

with the latest in information technology and

its applications in services in the ongoing

highly competitive business environment and

this change has been particularly visible in the

Indian healthcare sector. The professionals in

the service sector are increasingly under

pressure to demonstrate their services as

customer- focused and that continuous

performance improvements are being

delivered. Thus, it is important to analyze and

critically review the services on regular basis

to identify and correct gaps between desired

levels and actual levels of performances.

SERVQUAL model is used as a framework for

defining the real meaning of customer

satisfaction and Gap analysis has been

undertaken to demonstrate the gaps for

measuring patients perception-expectation of

health care services in Govt/Charitable eye

hospitals in India. Finally, the empirical study

concludes that service quality and its

evaluation /measurement is a necessary and

winning strategy in the health care industry

for the new millennium.

Keywords: SERVQUAL, Perceptions,

Expectations, Service, Gaps.

Introduction: In the most apt words of

wisdom by Mahatma Gandhi, importance of

customer can be understood and there is

nothing better than serving customer in right

spirit. He said, “A customer is the most

important visitor on our premises. He is not

dependent on us. We are dependent on him.

He is not an interruption of our work. He is

the purpose of it. He is not an outsider to our

business. He is part of it. We are not doing

him a favour by serving him. He is doing us a

favour by giving us the opportunity to do so.”

World class hospitals/eye care

organizations gain competitive advantage and

greater market shares through extraordinary

levels of performance and commitment in

providing the kind of quality products and

services, demanded by customers cutting

across national borders. Corporate are being

required to conform to international

standards such as ISO 9000 and have to focus

their resources to attain high quality

standards in their eye care products and

services. There has been marked use of

quality management practices by

manufacturing and service organizations.

Increased recognition and awareness of

different dimensions of services like

intangibility, inseparability and heterogeneity

has led the businesses to evolve service

centric strategies around three additional

marketing mix variables [people, physical

process & physical ambience] of services

marketing in addition to the existing variables

i.e. product, placement, promotion & pricing.

The quality of service both technical and

functional is a key ingredient in achieving the

customer satisfaction and in turn, in the

success of service organizations (Gronroos,

1984). Quality is abstract characteristic that

encompasses a variety of more or less

physical attributes. Philip Crosby (1979)

Page 2 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 02 I s s ue 12

Dec ember 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 188

Quality in healthcare cannot be measured

directly but must be judgmentally assessed by

considering entity attributes that are more

directly perceptible.

Review of Literature: Research has shown that

quality indeed has a significant effect on market

share and return on investment (e.g. Anderson

and Zeithaml, 1984; Phillips, Chang, and Buzzell,

1983). It is further upheld that positive

consumer’s perceptions of service quality also

contribute to enhance customer satisfaction

(Durvasual and Mehta, 1998; and Durvashula, et

al, 2004). Quality may be understood as Quality is

the goodness or excellence of services provided

by all the components of the eye care system.

Quality service is not only a patient’s weapon in a

hospital's competitive arsenal, it is the driving

force behind profitability. Hospitals can only

become or remain profitable if they first identify

the right things and then do them right. Johnson

(1988) notes that hospitals are much more than

buildings and machines, they are human

organizations meeting human needs, and to

remain successful in a competitive eye care

market, they must outperform their competitors

on the human dimensions.

The ultimate goal of service quality

measurement is to assist managers in

ensuring service quality and customer

satisfaction (Webster, 1988). If service quality

is to become the cornerstone of marketing

strategy, the marketer must have the means

to measure it. Measurement is a necessary

step towards devising any action plan. Even as

the US is exploring the possibility of six sigma

in eye care. India is struggling to identify the

"right" model to assess quality. Rating

agencies and ISO may be the only markers for

assessing quality at present, but every

hospital must make conscious efforts to move

towards delivering quality eye care. Several

theories and instruments (SERVPERF,

LibQUAL+,and SERVUSE etc.) have been

proposed and have been implemented, as to

what quality in eye care pertains to the minds

of the patients and one of them is SERVQUAL.

A very short and somewhat rude

definition of which is that it is a methodology

to measure the gap between customers'

expectations and their perceptions or

experiences with aspects of a given service. A

SERVQUAL study will normally investigate the

relationship between users' perception of the

quality of a service and their experience of

the quality of the given service.

Research Methodology: The present study by

providing the Perception-Expectation Gap

Score will help hospitals in identifying the

deficiencies and excesses in quality as regards

to various dimensions of quality.

Objectives of the Study:

 To critically examine the quality

parameters of services provided by

Govt/Charitable eye hospitals in

Haryana.

 To know how the patients actually

perceive service quality of

Govt/Charitable eye hospitals in India.

 To test whether there is any significant

difference between perceptions and

expectations of the patients of

Govt/Charitable eye hospitals in India.

 To provide suggestive measures to the

Govt/Charitable eye hospitals in

Haryana so that their service-quality

endeavors are perceived well by the

patients.

The present study was carried out

between January to November, 2010 with

some modifications supporting earlier study

which was conducted from June to

November, 2008 in GOVT/Charitable eye

Page 3 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

e-I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 02 I s s ue 12

Dec ember 2016

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 189

hospitals in India.Convenience & Judgment

sampling was used for sample selection.

Sample : A total of 190 patients were

surveyed. In the present study the researcher

approached only those prospective

respondents who have selected

Govt/Charitable eye hospitals for their eye

surgery and also do not had any previous

experience related to eye care services

offered in Govt/Charitable eye hospitals in

Haryana.

Instrument Used :

This study used the SERVQUAL scale

questionnaire designed by Parasuraman et al.

(1988) to measure the expected and

perceived quality of eye care services

provided by GOVT/Charitable eye hospitals in

Haryana.The present study was carried out

between January to November, 2010 with

some modifications supporting earlier study

which was conducted from June to

November, 2008 in Govt/Charitable eye

hospitals in Haryana. Convenience &

Judgment sampling was used for sample

selection.

SERVQUAL Scores: TO ASSESS THE LEVEL OF

PERCEIVED QUALITY OF SERVICES OFFERED BY

SELECTED CHARITABLE EYE HOSPITALS OF

HARYANA :

 Overall SERVQUAL Score Of All

govt/Charitable Eye Hospitals Of Haryana :

SERVQUAL Scores both Un-weighted and

Weighted have been tabulated in Table No.1.0 All

values are explained by mean, median and

standard deviation.

Table No. 1.0

SERVQUAL Score in the study group (n=190)

MEAN MEDIAN STD. DEVIATON

Un weighted SERVQUAL Score 0.86 1.26 1.16

Weighted SERVQUAL Score 16.54 22.74 23.02

Average Unweighted SERVQUAL Score

for the total of 190 respondents was 0.86. It is

in positive zone meaning thereby that the

respondents’ perceptions were more than

their expectations. They perceived the

services provided to them as of good quality.

When importance weights were also taken

into consideration the resultant Weighted

SEVQUAL Score (16.54) is also positive. In

USA-General sample in 1990, East Midlands

UK outpatients in 1995 & Vassa Finland

outpatients in 1996, Average Weighted

SERVQUAL Score was negative, while it was

zero in Scottish-Public Library services in 1995

and was positive in Scottish-Home Help

service in 1995 (Dalrymple, 1995). This

reaffirmed that charitable eye hospitals of the

state of Haryana (India) are providing the

quality eye care treatment to patients.

 Importance Weights For Dimensions :

Average Importance Weights were compiled and tabulated in Table No. 2.0.