Page 1 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 01

January 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 87

The Strategic Fit of Multiple Strategic Orientations and New Product

Development Performance in Malaysian Manufacturing Firms: A

Conceptual Framework

1Siti Norhasmaedayu Mohd Zamani ; 2Hasbullah Ashari; 3Asmat Nizam Abdul Talib

1School of Technology Management & Logistic, College of Business, Universiti Utara

Malaysia, Malaysia

2School of International Business, College of Law, Government & International Studies,

Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia

edayu@uum.edu.my

Abstract

Resource orientation (RO) and market orientation

(MO) are two important strategic orientations that

have significant impact towards new product

development (NPD) performance. Although research

has examined the RO and MO individually, limited

research has evaluated and compared their effect on

new product success in one study. Furthermore, only

a few have matched the fit between both strategies and

tests their effect on firm performance and none of them

so far has study the role of external environment

factors on the relationship between the fit of both

strategies towards NPD performance. The purpose of

this paper is to develop a conceptual framework of the

impact of strategic fit towards NPD performance. The

objective of the study is to determine the effect of

strategic fit between RO and MO towards new product

development performance. Specifically, it aims to

evaluate whether single strategy or the fit between

both strategies will have the greater impact on new

product development performance. More importantly,

the research will investigate the role of external

environmental variables (i.e., market turbulence and

technological turbulence) on the relationship between

two strategic orientations and performance. In this

paper, the researchers conducted a desk research by

reviewing the literature to understand the impact of

resource orientation, market orientation and

environmental factors towards NPD performance. The

practitioners and academicians will find this

framework beneficial in their own, various scope as

this study provide a clear guideline on how the

variables interact with each other.

Keywords: Strategic orientation; Strategic fit;

NPD performance; Environmental factors;

Malaysia.

1. Introduction

New product development (NPD) is an

engine of economic growth (Schumpeter,

1934). It is frequently expressed in the

marketing and management literatures that

product development is important because

new products are becoming the nexus of

competition of many organizations (Brown &

Eisenhardt, 1995; Clark & Fujimoto, 1991).

In order for firms to have sustained

competitive advantage in the long run, firms

should continuously engage in creating new

products and services (Hunt, 2000; Hunt &

Morgan, 1995; Schumpeter, 1934).

In current years, there has been a

considerable interest in Malaysian

manufacturing firms in New Product

Development (NPD) which is considered to

be indirectly a booster for the success of a

firm. This is based on the fact that Malaysia

was heavily dependent on agriculture which

was gradually shifted to manufacturing (Al- Shalabi, Omar, & Rundquist, 2007).

Page 2 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 01

January 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 88

Since it is well recognized that new products

are the life-blood of an organization (Perks,

2000), scholars have recently turned their

attention toward understanding the success

factors of new product development. The last

three decades have witnessed considerable

research on new product development

(NPD), particularly on determinants of new

product performance (Cooper, 1979; Cooper

& Kleinschmidt, 1987; Rubinstein, 1976). As

a result, a lot of factors influencing the

outcomes of NPD have been identified,

including strategy, product, market,

environment, organization, project team, and

management (Craig & Hart, 1992; Brown &

Eisenhardt, 1995; Montoya-Weiss &

Calantone, 1994).

These studies have lead to a number of

recommendations for industrial managers to

improve their management of NPD activities.

Improvement in NPD could enhance the

industry’s competitive position. An

understanding of NPD practice could assist

both government and industry to formulate

innovation policy and strategies during

critical economic reform period (G. Huang,

Huang, & Mak, 2000).

Resource orientation (RO) and market

orientation (MO) are among the strategic

orientation that has been recognized as the

drivers of the NPD. RO, originated from the

theory of Resource-based View (RBV) were

aims to clarify how a firm’s resources drive

its performance in a dynamic competitive

environment (Collis & Montgomery, 1995).

The RBV is primarily internally oriented, in

that its focus lies with the development and

deployment of unique firm resources. It is

concerned with accumulating a unique

resource base that is immobile and

heterogeneous (Barney, 1991).

On the other hand, MO ‘‘creates the

necessary behaviors for the creation of

superior value for buyers and thus,

continuous superior performance for the

business’’ (Narver & Slater, 1990). Hence,

this orientation is externally oriented in that

its primary focus resides with the satisfaction

of market needs and then attention is drawn

to internal processes (Paladino, 2008).

Market orientation permeates the

organization, impacting all business

activities. Many researchers are increasingly

referring to market orientation as a strategy,

recognizing the impact that its pursuit has on

a firm’s long-term decision-making

strategies (Greenley, 1995).

Previous studies have tested the single (e.g:

Paladino, 2007, 2008) and integrated effect

(e.g: Paladino, 2009) of RO and MO towards

company performance, however none of

them have specifically studied the effect of fit

between both orientations towards NPD

performance, and also the impact of

environmental factors towards strategic fit- NPD performance relationship. This paper

will provide the conceptual framework, thus

fulfill the stated gaps by clarifying the roles

of strategic fit between resource and market

orientation as the drivers of NPD

performance and the roles of environmental

factors in determining the relationship

between strategic fit and NPD performance

in Malaysian Manufacturing firm.

2. Problem Statement

Many studies have examined the RO and MO

individually (e.g: Kohli & Jaworski, 1990;

Baker & Sinkula, 2005; Narver & Slater,

1990; Sharma & Vredenburg, 1998; Slater &

Mohr, 2006; Wernerfelt, 1984) and limited

research has evaluated and compared their

single (e.g: Paladino 2007, 2008) and

integrated effect (e.g: Paladino 2009) on firm

Page 3 of 15

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 01

January 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 89

performance in one study. However, none of

them have specifically studied the effect of

strategic fit of both orientations towards NPD

performance. Furthermore, no research to

date has the studied the roles of

environmental factors towards NPD

performance.

Paladino (2007, 2008) has come out with the

research that seeks to clarify the best strategy

between RO and MO towards business

performance where NPD success is one of the

dimensions involved. Specifically, Paladino

(2008) evaluated whether a focus on the

customer or the firm will impact firm

success, and the result shows that RO have a

greater impact on NPD performance

compared to MO.

Paladino (2009) has expended the strategy- performance study by matching two strategic

orientations (i.e., resource orientation and

market orientation) and test the integrated

effect of both orientations towards firm

performance which has the element of

innovation as one of the dimensions.

However as mention before, no research to

date has specifically determine 1) the impact

of strategic fit between both orientations

towards NPD performance as a whole and 2)

the effect of internal and external

environmental factors on the relationship

between the matched strategic orientation

and NPD performance.

In order to thoroughly study the above issues,

we believed that a proper framework is

needed as a guide to set the focus of the

research. Thus, this study will provide the

strong justification and argument based on

the literature in order to develop a research

framework that will capture the relationship

between resource orientation, market

orientation, environmental factors and NPD

performance. To the best of our knowledge,

no research framework exists to guide the

study of these variables in the Malaysian

context.

3. Objectives of the Study

This study seeks to understand the

relationship between resource orientation,

market orientation, environmental factors

and NPD performance by reviewing the

literature. At the end of the study, it is hoped

that a conceptual framework can be

developed based on the literature review in

order to guide further study on the stated

issues and problems. This framework can

helps practitioners and academicians to

initially understand the relationship between

the variables before analytically justifying

the study using empirical analysis.

4. Methodology

This study applied secondary research or also

known as desk research which involves the

summary, collation and/or synthesis of

existing research. Secondary research is

defined as an analysis and interpretation of

primary research. The method of writing

secondary research is to collect primary

research that is relevant to a writing topic and

interpret what the primary research found. In

this study, secondary research or desk

research was conducted by reviewing the

literature leading to identification of

variables incorporated into the conceptual

framework (Dzansi & Tasssin-Njike, 2014).

5. Literature Review

5.1 New product development

New product development (NPD) has long

been recognized as one of the corporate core

functions (X. Huang, Soutar, & Brown,

2002) and a key to corporate prosperity