Page 1 of 13
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page 93
Journal for Studies in Management & Planning
Available at
https://edupediapublications.org/ journals/index.php/jsmap
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 04
March 2017
The Use of Internet in Financial Reporting: A Review of Empirical
Research
Dr. Manjinder Singh
Assistant Professor, Department of Commerce, S.G.G.S. College, Sector-26,
Chandigarh, India
Email: mssaini77@yahoo.co.in
Abstract
Internet has been used increasingly as a new communication channel in global business and its role
expanded to include internet financial reporting. The rapid use of internet in financial reporting is translated
into an increasing number of accounting research studies that address this topic. Firstly, accounting
research aims to portray the use of internet in financial reporting and documents the variation in internet
reporting practices. Secondly, accounting research takes a further step by investigating the relationship
between firm-specific characteristics, corporate governance and internet reporting. Given the fact that the
literature concerning nature and extent of internet financial reporting has proliferated in the last two
decades and that a number of different methodologies have appeared in the literature, it is worthwhile to
offer an updated review of what has been accomplished in the last two decades. This review is focused on the
accounting literature, published between 1997 and 2016, aiming to portray the use of internet in financial
reporting and documents the variation in internet reporting practices. The goal is to trace the progress in the
last two decades and identify trends in internet reporting research.
Keywords: Internet, Web, Internet Financial Reporting, Financial Information, Literature.
Introduction
Internet has been used increasingly as a new communication channel in global business and its role expanded to
include internet financial reporting (Ettredge et al., 2002; Jones and Xiao, 2004). In 2015, the number of internet
users was about 3.4 billion, representing 46.40 percent of the world population, and the growth rate of internet
users from 2000 to 2015 was 832.50 percent (Internet World Stats, 2015). This rapid growth of internet adoption
draws the attention of several regulators bodies such as Financial Accounting Standard Board and the Canadian
Institute of Chartered Accountants to adopt research or policy initiatives on internet financial reporting
(Debreceny et al., 2002; Gowthorpe, 2000). The increasing use of internet financial reporting raised many
questions regarding the motives and costs of such disclosure. On the one hand, FASB (2000) indicates several
motives for the adoption of internet financial reporting such as reduction in distribution cost, providing timely
information, best medium of communication with previously unidentified consumers of information, provides
information at different aggregation levels, provision of raw data for analysis, flexibility of presentation, global
reach access to historical data and up-to-date information. On the other hand, internet financial reporting may
raise the incremental cost of preparing financial reports, the cost of providing additional assurance on internet
financial reporting and the litigation cost resulting from relying on unaudited financial information in decision- making proposes (Gowthorpe, 2000; Xiao et al., 2002).
The rapid use of internet in financial reporting is translated into an increasing number of accounting research
studies that address this topic. Firstly, accounting research aims to portray the use of internet in financial
reporting and documents the variation in internet reporting practices ( Ashbaugh et al., 1999; Craven and
Marston, 1999; Lybaert, 2003). Secondly, accounting research takes a further step by investigating the
relationship between firm-specific characteristics, corporate governance and internet reporting (Abdelsalam et
al., 2007; Al-Htaybay, 2011; Aly et al., 2010; Xiao et al., 2004; Andrikopoulus and Diakidis, 2007).
Given the fact that the literature concerning nature and extent of internet financial reporting has proliferated in
the last two decades and that a number of different methodologies have appeared in the literature, it is
worthwhile to offer an updated review of what has been accomplished in the last two decades. The purpose of
Page 2 of 13
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page 94
Journal for Studies in Management & Planning
Available at
https://edupediapublications.org/ journals/index.php/jsmap
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 04
March 2017
this study is to provide an updated review and synthesis of the empirical literature on internet reporting to
discover any systematic patterns in internet reporting practices.
The remainder of the paper is structured as follows. The next section describes the methodology of the study.
The following section provides the review of relevant studies focusing on descriptive nature of internet financial
reporting practices. The penultimate section concludes, discusses the research limitations and provides lines for
further research.
Methodology of the Study
This review is focused on the accounting literature, published between 1997 and 2016, aiming to portray the use
of internet in financial reporting and documents the variation in internet reporting practices. The goal is to trace
the progress in the last two decades and identify trends in internet reporting research. Searching a variety of
databases is important to find relevant literature related to the current status of internet financial reporting.
Keywords such as nature and extent of internet financial reporting, current status of internet financial reporting,
financial reporting on the internet, digital reporting, online reporting, electronic reporting, investor relations on
internet, business reporting on the internet, corporate reporting on the internet, internet based reporting,
corporate disclosure through web, corporate disclosure on websites are used to locate the relevant literature in
ScienceDirect, Emerald, Springer, Jstore, EBSCO, SSRN and Wiley online library. In addition, the study uses
the reference list of the collected studies to find more studies relevant to the analysis of internet financial
reporting practices. The initial sample includes 61 studies (Table I). However, 12 papers are excluded because
of theoretical base. These papers do not provide descriptive statistics. The identified studies come from some of
the most popular journals in accounting, auditing, finance, management, economics, international business,
marketing and human resources, including The Journal of Applied Business Research, African Journal of
Business Management, Asian Review of Accounting, Journal of Economic & Administrative Sciences,
Corporate Ownership and Control, The South African Journal of Information Management, International
Journal of Accounting and Business Finance, The Cost & Management, International Journal of Accounting and
Financial Reporting, The International Journal of Digital Accounting Research, IUP Journal of Accounting
Research and Audit Practices, Corporate Governance, International Journal of Emerging Research in
Management and Technology, The European Accounting Review, International Journal of Arts and Sciences,
Asian Journal of Research in Banking and Finance, Malaysian Accounting Review, Accounting and Taxation,
Asian Journal of Accounting and Governance, The Romanian Economic Journal, IUP Journal of Corporate
Governance, Corporate Communication, International Journal of Business and Society, ICFAI Journal of Bank
Management, The Chartered Accountant, among others. Like other reviews, the current review is limited by its
inclusion of only English studies.
Table I
Sample Selection Criteria
Initial Sample 61
Exclusion Criteria
Theoretical Papers (without descriptive analysis) 12
Final Sample 49
Review of Descriptive Studies on Internet Financial Reporting
The increasing use of internet has been reflected in the increasing number of research papers that discuss that
analyse the use of internet in financial reporting (Xiao et al., 2002). Two streams of accounting literature that
discuss web-based reporting have been identified: the first stream aims to describe the use of internet reporting
by companies as a means to have a dialogue with their stakeholders (Gowthorpe, 2004), while the second stream
of literature aims to measure the extent of internet reporting and its determinants (AI-Htaybat, 2011). The first
stream of accounting literature, flourished in the 1990s, uses descriptive and bivariate statistics to portray the
use of internet reporting (Allam and Lymer, 2003; Ashbaugh et al., 1999; Craven and Marston, 1999;
Gowthorpe, 2004). This stream of literature aims to test the differences in internet reporting practices between
companies with websites and their counterparts without websites or to examine the differences between
Page 3 of 13
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ Page 95
Journal for Studies in Management & Planning
Available at
https://edupediapublications.org/ journals/index.php/jsmap
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 04
March 2017
companies that provide and those that do not provide financial information in their websites. Following
paragraphs provide the review of relevant literature describing the use of the internet in financial reporting.
Lymer (1997) carried out a survey o the extent of the internet corporate reporting practices, especially financial
and non-financial information, amongst 50 companies listed on LSE in 1997. The study concluded that 92
percent of the study sample had active websites. 60 percent of these companies disclosed their reports and
accounts on their websites, and 32 percent out of these firms published full accounts.
Lymer and Tallberg (1997) conducted a study of the website reporting practices in 1997, over 50 top UK and
72 Finland companies listed on Helsinki Stock Exchange (HSE). The results indicated that possession of active
websites was 92 and 90.20 percent for the UK and Finnish companies respectively. Out of these 7 and 5
companies provided full accounts from each country respectively.
Martson and Leow (1998) analysed FTSE-100 firms in the UK to determine the status of corporate web
disclosure. The study found that 63 percent of the sample firms examined had homepages, 45 percent provided
some form of financial information, and 34 percent of these, provided detailed annual reports (11 disclosed only
parts or summaries of their annual reports).
Deller et al. (1999) conducted a comparative study using a checklist consisting of 19 items to measure the
extent of financial reporting for investor relations on the internet over 300 companies selected from three
countries, USA, UK and Germany, 100 largest companies from each country. The results showed that the
percentage of the web presence of the companies in the three countries was 95 percent in USA, 85 percent in
UK, and 7776 percent in Germany. The results also indicated that for these companies the percentage of website
usage for investor relations reporting was 91 percent of the US companies compared to 72 percent for UK and
71 percent for Germany.
Heldin (1999) conducted a survey to explore the position of 60 Swedish companies from three identified
generations of websites reporting development in 1998. The results indicated that 99 percent of the companies
had a usable website. 83 percent of the companies published full financial statements. It also concluded that the
Swedish companies located in the second generation of the internet reporting development.
Lymer et al. (1999) surveyed web based financial reporting practices of the 660 public corporations in 22
countries in Europe, Asia Pacific, North and South America. It was found that 86 percent of the sample
companies had websites while 410 (72%) companies had some form of financial reporting on their websites. Of
these, 234 (57%) companies had in-depth reports on their websites in HTML, indicating a higher level of
investment in making information available than merely by electronic paper. The study concluded that a
significant number of companies in many countries used the web for communication of business performance to
stakeholders.
Pirchegger and Wagenhofer (1999) analyzed the use of Internet to present financial information by 32
Austrian companies and 30 German companies by using four criteria of website reporting, namely: the content,
technology, timeliness and user support criteria. The study found that percentage of web presence is close
between Austrian and German companies in 1998, which were 81% and 80% respectively. Comparison of
Austrian and German websites in 1998 showed that German websites did not substantially differ, on average,
but were much more homogeneous in the scores than Austrian companies.
Financial Accounting Standard Board (2000) carried out a survey of 100 US companies listed in Fortune 500
in 1998 on checklist consisted of 325 characteristics of the company website, separated into two main
categories: general characteristics of the website and investor relations characteristics. The survey results
showed that the entire sample had websites with graphic animations such as maps, 88 percent enclosed table of
contents, 64 percent with search boxes. In respect to investor relations information, the study found that 93
percent of the sample published such information on their websites.
Ponte et al. (2000) analyzed the financial contents of the websites of 50 companies listed on the Dow Jones
Eurostoxx 50 index as of October 1999. It was found that 100 percent of the companies had active websites and
100 percent supplied the full annual accounts. Interim statements (half yearly or quarterly) were provided by 90
percent companies, but they were not audited. A number of companies (62%) provided five year summary
accounts and a few of them (38%) included financial ratios. Environment information was disclosed by 20
companies (40%), 40 companies (80%) provided information on strategy, only 2 (4%) offered information about
