Page 1 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Is s ue 04
March 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 1
A Comparison and Evaluation of Administration and Security
Tool of Open Source Learning Management Systems
Research Scholar- Sheetal Uplenchwar # 1
, Ph.D. Guide - Dr. Manimala Puri# 2
1Assistant Professor, Allana Institute of Management Sciences, Pune,
2 Director, Jayawant Shikshan Prasarak Mandal, Group of Institutes
1
sheetaluplenchwar@gmail.com,
2 manimalap@yahoo.com
Abstract
Online Learning is becoming an
important tool to allow the flexibility and
quality requested by learning process. In the
recent past, a great number of open source
learning management system (OSLMS) has
been introduced in the market showing different
characteristics and services. All these OSLMS
reduces cost acquired by proprietary LMS.
Market is occupied with large number of
OSLMS. So before selecting any OSLMS it is
necessary to consider series of features, function
and usability of the overall learning system.
The main purpose of this study is to
analyze and explore the right decision when
choosing a suitable OSLMS platform to meet
the requirements of education system.
A different criterion needs to be
considered while evaluating OSLMS. These
criteria includes communication tool,
productivity tool, student involvement tool,
administration tool, course delivery tool,
curriculum design, course delivery tool,
software and hardware requirement, pricing and
licensing issues.
This study focuses on evaluation of
curriculum design tool of seven OSLMS which
includes Moodle, Atutor, Sakai, Ilias, Claroline,
Olat and Dokeos.
Keywords
Learning management systems (LMS),
Open-source learning management systems
(OSLMS),
1. Introduction
In the last decade the usage of Internet has
been increased exponentially and new
technologies have improved students education.
Based on the new technologies, learning
environments are able to provide a wide range
of educational alternatives. Distance learning is
one of these alternatives where student and
instructor are remotely located and are flexible
with respect to time and place constraint [1].
LMS have significant role in distance
learning, which is also known as virtual learning
environment (VLE). Halls defines LMS as,
“Software that automates administration of
training events” [2].
In distance learning process OSLMS are
widely used. OSS represents a social dimension
of learning through a Persistent, Unified, Multi- User, and Self-Organizing environment
extending beyond the traditional classroom
where learners build knowledge and
understanding through collaborative exchanges
both within and across subject area boundaries.
For the selection of best OSLMS, it is
necessary to establish proper evaluation criteria.
Page 2 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Is s ue 04
March 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 2
This paper evaluates seven OSLMS. Each
OSLMS program is based on the ability to
accommodate different active learning
experiences in online courses. The selected
OSLMS are Moodle, Atutor, Olat, Sakai, Ilias,
Claroline, and Dokeos.
The comparison has different perspective
which includes administrative, faculty and
student perspectives. A LMS must address the
needs of the ultimate end user: the learner. Each
LMS has key features that allow students to be
actively involved in their courses.
This paper is organized as follows. Section
1 represents brief introduction of paper. In
Section 2, literature review has been carried out.
Section 3 shows base for the selection of LMS,
need of comparison for selected LMS and
general information about selected LMS. A
comparative study of selected OSLMS is
presented in Sections 4. Section 5 displays
results of the study. Section 6 represents
conclusion of the study.
2. Literature Review
Jamil Ahmad Itmazi and Miguel
Gea (2005) [3] have carried out paper surveys of
58 studies of comparison and evaluation of
OSLMS and proprietary system by comparing
functionality. They have recommended the most
widely used OSLMS. Result of the study shows
that WebCT is the mostly used proprietary LMS
and Moodle is the mostly used OSLMS.
Matjaz Kljun, Jernej Vicic, and
Branko Kavsek (2007) [4] have reviewed 31
LMS comparison and evaluation (written
between 1998 and 2006) papers. Comparison
methods includes Feature comparison ,
Learning paths support, SCORM specs, OSS
compliance, Student centered, Learning tools
based, Technical specs, Conversational
Framework, Questionnaire based, Features
usability, and Use-case and feedback .The study
reveals that present LMS development tries to
catch up with standards, although the SCORM
standard is unfortunately not as widely
supported.
PeterLengyel MiklosHerdon and
Robert Szilagyil (2006)[5] have done the
comparison amongst Atutor, Moodle and
OLAT by considering various parameters like
support and compatibility to standards, content
development and content authoring / editing
tools, modularity, backup tools, user
authentication, video conferencing, group
facility, chat facility, XML support, system
requirements. The study shows that Moodle is
at higher position supporting 13 features out of
14. Atutor and OLAT support 9 features.
Guzin Tirkes (2010) has [6] done
the comparison amongst Atutor, Moodle and
OLAT and Dokeos by considering support and
compatibility, content development and
editing tool, modularity, backup ,user
authentication, video conferencing, online
examination question, group, chat, email etc.
Result of their study is shows that Moodle
possesses all 17 features, Atutor and OLAT
supports 12 features, whereas Dokeos support
15 features.
Barbar A.Lewis and Virginia M.
MacEntee (2005) [7] have evaluated WebCT,
v.4.1; BlackBoard, v. 6.1; Jones E-education;
Educator; Angel; .LRN; McGraw Hill
Pageout; Moodle; and e-College AU. They
considered various comparison features like
content development, discussion area, group
participation, calendar, chat, student study
Page 3 of 12
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Is s ue 04
March 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 3
tool, audio, video, student progress and email.
Study shows that amongst the proprietary
LMS WebcCT is at topmost position.
Amongst OLSMS, DotLRN is at topmost
position and Moodle is at second position.
The report of commonwealth (2003)
of learning [8] has evaluated OSLMS Moodle,
Lon-Capa, Ilias, DotLRN, and Atutor.
Comparison parameter includes features,
maintainability, usability, reliability,
scalability etc. each feature is evaluated on the
basis of 0-5 scale. Study shows that Atutor is
having highest scale of 42. Ilias is having 41
scales. Moodle is having 37 scales and LON- Capa is having 37 scales.
Sabine Graf & Beate List (2005)
[9] have evaluated 9 OSLMS. The main focus
is on adaptation issue. Qualitative Weight and
Sum Approach is used for this purpose.
Comparison includes Atutor, Dokeos,
DotLRN, ILIAS,Lon-Capa,Moodle, OpnUSS,
Sakai, Spaghetti learning. The adaptation
issues include communication tools, learning
objects, user data management, usability,
adaptation ha, technical aspects,
administration, and course management. Rank
was given to each platform. Moodle s
achieved the best evaluation values. Ilias has
second rank and Dokeos has third rank.
ATutor, LON-CAPA, Spaghettilearning, and
Open-USS are ranked equally at the fourth
position, whereas Sakai and dotLRN are
ranked last.
Jing Liu, Men and Jun Han (2009)
[10] have compared and evaluated 5 OSLMS
namely Atutor, Moodle, Sakai, Calroline and
Dokeos. They have not ranked the LMS. The
study shows that Moodle is better for process
assessment. Sakai can be used for better
summary assessment. For community purpose
Sakai is perfect. If the teacher is novice user in
teaching Claroline can be used. For
functioning of videos Dokeos is best.
3. Selection of OSLMS
From the above literature review it
is clearly observed that most of the studies
include comparison and evaluation of Moodle,
Atutor, Olat, Dokeos, Sakai, Claroline,
Ilias,LON-CAPA, OpenUSS, ADA,
Spaghettilearning, DotLRN and Olat. Selection
of OSLMS is based on rating given by this
study. Again evaluated research papers are
backdated. Current comparison and evaluation
in today’s scenario is not available. So it is
necessary to carry out latest evaluation of all
these OSLMS to know its current capabilities.
With the help of result of past studies, the
selected OSLMS are Moodle, Atutor, Olat,
Sakai, Ilias, Claroline, and Dokeos.
4. Comparative study of OSLMS
features
OSLMS features are divided into
category as learner tool, support tool and
technical specification. Each of these
categories has different types of subcategories.
Support tool includes curriculum design
tool, administration tool and course design
tool.
Each of them has different features.
Following figure shows architectural design
view of administration and security tool.
