Page 1 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 05
April 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 101
Managerial Efficiency and Profitability Performance of Public Sector Banks
in India
Dr. Kulbir Singh
Associate Professor, Deptt. of Commerce
C R Kisan College, Jind(Haryana)
Abstract :
The study of Indian Banking sector occupies an important place in the development of economy
in India especially after Banking Sector Reforms introduced in 1991. Before financial sector
reforms, Indian banks were operating in a protected environment with a strong cushion of the
government. This had made them operationally inefficient and commercially almost wreck. An
attempt has been made with the help of this study for the evaluation of managerial efficiency and
profitability performance. All public sector banks i.e. 26 have been selected for the study. Period
of the study ranged from 2007 to 2012. All the banks were first individually ranked for each ratio
on the basis of managerial efficiency and profitability parameter. Then the composite score for
each bank has been calculated on the basis of average of the individual score. Friedman rank test
has been used to test the hypothesis. At 4 degree of freedom, the hypothesis i.e. H1 is rejected.
Therefore we can conclude that the performance of all public sector banks is not uniform in both
the parameter i.e. managerial efficiency and profitability.
Keywords: Managerial Efficiency, Profitability, Banking System, Resource Mobilization.
Introduction:
The Indian Banking system is distinctive
and possibly has no parallel in the banking
history of any country in the world. It is very
interesting to study the evolution of Indian
Banking over the Last five decades, in terms
of organization, functions, resource
mobilization, Socio-economic roles,
problems and solutions. The period of five
decades witnessed many macro-economic
developments, monetary and banking
policies and the external situation, which
influenced the evolution of Indian banking
in different ways and in different periods
The banking sector in India started its
history (phase 1) with the General Bank of
Page 2 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 05
April 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 102
India and The Bank of Hindustan in 1786.
After the defunct of these two banks three
new presidency banks were came in
existence namely The Bank of Calcutta
(1840), The Bank of Bombay (1840) and
The Bank of Madras established by East
India Company. In 1865 Allahabad Bank
and in 1895 Punjab National Bank were set
up. Then Imperial bank of India came into
existence in 1921. The Imperial bank of
India acted as a central bank and as a banker
for other banks. After that a series of bank
started its operation. Reserve Bank of India
was set up in 1935. In 1950 (phase 2) the
Indian banking system compromised of the
Reserve Bank of India, The Imperial Bank
of India, Cooperative Banks, Exchange
Banks and Indian Joint stock Banks. After
independence, in 1951, the all India Rural
Credit Survey and Committee of Direction
with Shri A.D. Gorwala as Chairman
recommended amalgamation of the Imperial
Bank of India and ten other banks into a
newly established bank called State Bank of
India (SBI). Imperial Bank of India was
nationalized in 1955 as the State Bank of
India. In 1959 the SBI (Subsidiary Bank)
Act was proposed and the following eight
State associated banks were taken over by
the SBI as its subsidiaries. On 19th July
1969, the Prime Minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi
announced the nationalization of 14 major
scheduled commercial banks each having
deposits worth Rs. 50 crores and above. This
was the turning point in Indian commercial
banking in India. Later on 15th April 1980,
six more commercial private sector banks
with deposit liability of not less than Rs. 200
crores were also nationalized. In 1975
Regional Rural Banks came into existence to
supplement the activities of the commercial
banks and to especially meet the credit
needs of the rural society. At present total
number of banks in public sector are 26 i.e.
SBI and its associates (6) & nationalized
banks (20). IDBI bank ltd. which was earlier
a new private sector bank now converted
into public sector bank. Old private sector
banks are 13, New private sector banks are 7
and foreign banks are 41 in number.
Financial sector reforms were initiated as
part of overall economic reforms in the
country and wide ranging reforms covering
industry, trade, taxation, external sector,
banking and financial market have been
carried out since the mid of 1991. The most
significant achievement of the financial
sector reforms has been the marked
improvement in the financial health of
commercial banks in terms of capital
adequacy, profitability and asset quality as
Page 3 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 05
April 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 103
also greater attention to risk management.
Further, deregulation has opened up new
opportunities for banks to increase revenues
by diversifying into investment banking,
insurance, credit cards, depository services,
mortgage financing, securitization etc. At
the same time, liberalization has brought
greater competition among banks, both
domestic and foreign, as well as competition
from mutual funds, NBFCs; post office etc.
After reforms, competition will only get
intensified, as large global players emerge
on the scene. Increasing competition is
squeezing profitability and forcing banks to
work efficiently on shrinking spreads.
Positive fallout of competition is the greater
choice available to consumers, and the
increased level of sophistication and
technology in banks.
Review of literature
The literature review section examines
recent (or historically significant) research
studies, company data or industry reports
that act as a basis for the proposed study. It
may also explain the need for the proposed
work to appraise the shortcomings and
informational gaps in secondary data
sources.
Dhanabhakyam and Kavitha (2002) in
their study observed the financial
performance of the selected public sector
banks with different norms. Ratio analysis,
correlation and regression were applied on
the data. It was concluded that public sector
banks performed well on economic
development and financial efficiency.
Further, the old private sector banks and
new private sector banks have given a big
contribution in advertising new types of
deposits and advances schemes.
Sharma (2005) attempted a study on critical
evaluation of Indian banking sector. The
study period was of five years including
1988-89 for public sector banks and private
sector banks. Data were analysed with the
help of Descriptive statistics, Ratio analyses,
Common size statement analysis and F test.
The study suggested that the banks should
make appropriate use of technology for
improvement in the quality of customer
service.
Varadi Mavaluri and Boppana (2006)
evaluated the efficiency of banks in India.
The study measured the performance of the
banks with the help of non parametric
techniques i.e. Data Envelopment Analysis
(DEA). The study concluded that public
sector banks were having high efficiency in
