Page 1 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 5
Apri l 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 34
Making Effective Board Decisions
By
Nickson Ongaki & George Macharia
(The Centre For Corporate Governance, Nairobi, Kenya.)
Here we have developed seventeen
strategies, seven for directors as
individuals and ten for Boards as a whole,
that can help you and your Board make
better decisions.
1. Be clear on
your roles and
responsibilities
as a director:
Clarity on your
roles and
responsibilities
as a director
means that you are less likely to waste time
on issues or areas that are not your
responsibility, allowing you to focus on the
truly important issues that must be dealt
with in the boardroom.
More importantly, the responsibilities of a
director are a solid starting place for good
decision-making as they provide a crystal- clear framework in which you as a director
must operate. They also provide a lens
through which to view decisions once they
are in the later stages of finalisation.
For example, as a director you are bound by
law to act in the organisation’s best
interests. In order to improve decision- making, you should be constantly framing
decisions through this lens. It is easy to get
caught up in the details or hubbub of making
a decision and miss the most basic elements
such as whether the decision will lead to an
outcome that is actually in the
organisation’s best interests. On the
surface, it may often seem that a decision
will be in the organisation’s best interests,
however, if the wrong frame of reference is
used it could be that the decision is aligned
in the short term but not in the long term or
vice versa.
2. Acknowledge your biases and work to
balance them: As human beings, we have a
wide range of biases, both known and
unknown. Directors must work to ferret out
their biases, acknowledge them and to
compensate for them when making
decisions. However, do not forget that when
you are trying to take bias out of decision- making, you need to be cautious not to take
instinct, courage, and gut out as well. These
do form important parts of decision-making.
3. Understand that you are dealing with
uncertainty: When making strategic
decisions, you should realise that when you
are discussing risk you are dealing with
A. INDIVIDUAL
DIRECTORS
“Everyone thinks of
changing the world,
but no one thinks of
changing himself” –
Tolstoy
Page 2 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 5
Apri l 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 35
uncertainty and ambiguity. In the
boardroom, we often focus on risk as being
something that can be clearly identified, the
likelihood calculated or assigned a high or
low ranking and therefore mitigated. The
underlying assumption here is that we can
accurately predict the future outcomes and
associated probabilities of a particular event
or course of action. Research and history
has repeatedly shown that as humans we are
notoriously terrible at predicting the future.
One of the key reasons for this is because
we underestimate or fail to account for the
effects of uncertainty. This is equally true
we when are attempting to identify and
codify risks. We often like to believe that we
can see all the outcomes and that we are
certain about these, but certainty is an
illusion. As Ben Franklin famously said “In
this world nothing can be said to be certain,
except death and taxes.”
The ISO 31000 (2009) developed by a panel
of over 30 international experts defines risk
as the ‘effect of uncertainty on objectives’.
Risk is an intentional interaction with
uncertainty and needs to be treated
accordingly.
There are essentially three types of
situations in which we all make decisions:
i. Outcomes are known (Certainty)
ii. Outcomes are unknown, but
probabilities are known (Risk)
iii. Outcomes are unknown and
probabilities are unknown.
(Uncertainty)
We would like the world to operate like #i,
we typically think we are making decisions
in #ii, but we are often actually making
decisions in #iii.
“Risk applies when probabilities are known,
as they are at gambling tables, or for
insurance companies that have vast amounts
of data on individual risks. Uncertainty
prevails when even those probabilities are
unknown, as they are for virtually all real- life decisions.”
Although they often discuss risk, it is more
common that Boards are actually dealing
with uncertainty – where outcomes cannot
be accurately predicted and the
probabilities of those outcomes occurring
are difficult or even impossible to predict.
Uncertainty arises due to the complex and
chaotic nature of the environment in which
non-profit organisations operate.
Recognising that you may be discussing
uncertainty rather than risk around your
Board table is important as there is a
distinct difference between the two and they
both require different thinking and
approaches.
Successful navigation of uncertainty
requires that directors take a much bigger
picture approach. Directors who are
generalists, as opposed to specialists, are
more suited to dealing with the bigger
picture, uncertainty and ambiguity.
Generalists tend to focus on connecting
dots rather than working on developing
them. They look at issues through multiple
Page 3 of 6
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 5
Apri l 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 36
lenses and are therefore able to draw a
signal from the noise where others cannot.
Conversely, specialists – who often have
very deep knowledge of a particular area of
expertise – are talented at diving deep into
a very specific and well defined issue and
calculating the outcomes and associated
probabilities, which is a behaviour more
suited to dealing with risk than uncertainty.
4. Reframe: Flip the situation or issue
around in order to reframe it. For example,
what if you were on the Board of a
competing organisation, how might you
respond to your organisation making a
certain decision? Or what might the
outcome be if you decided to do the
opposite? Alternatively, frame the problem
as if you were an outside consultant brought
in to provide advice to your Board on the
issue. This can help you to look at decisions
from another perspective and therefore
enable you to cultivate more valuable
insights about an issue that your Board is
grappling with.
5. Be mindful:
Mindfulness is often viewed as an abstract
practice; however, it is becoming widely
used by the directors and executives of
some of the largest corporations on the
planet due to its many tangible benefits.
“Mindfulness means paying attention in a
particular way; On purpose, in the present
moment, and nonjudgmentally.” Mindfulness
is working to be more aware of the present
moment and the situation. There is much
written on mindfulness and its links to
decision-making. Some quick research will
provide further information on this, but at
its core, mindfulness can help you to work
toward being more present-state aware
when considering complex Board issues.
Present state awareness is where you are
more able to recognise what is driving you
at the moment you take action or make a
decision. An example of present-state
awareness is being aware of whether you are
exhibiting a negative behavior (e.g. being a
“control freak”) in the moment you are
making the decision. Unless you are mindful
and present-state aware you may not realise
you are exhibiting negative behavior until
well after you have started to do so. By that
point, particularly with Board decisions and
discussions during the decision-making
process, the damage is already done.
6. Use a decision-making process and
framework: Research from McKinsey
highlights that while analysis is important in
decision-making, the process used matters
more than analysis by a factor of six.
Implementing a decision-making framework
to improve the process you and your Board
use to make decisions can lead to better
quality decisions and outcomes for your
organisation. There are several decision- making frameworks available, however, a
straightforward one to use as a starting
point is the WRAP framework that Chip &
Dan Heath outline in their book Decisive.
