Page 1 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 6
May 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 254
Competitiveness of Indian Agriculture: A Case Study of Tea,
Cashew and Spices
Sunil Phougat
Assistant Professor, Department of Economics, Govt. College Jassia, Rohtak (Haryana)
Abstract
The present study is an attempt to analyze the
tea, cashew and spices competitiveness of
Indian agriculture under WTO regime. It is
found that NPC and EPC have been easy
indicators of the price movements and
direction of trading i.e. at which prices, it
was advisable to export and when it was
advisable to import. As far as performance of
Indian agricultural commodities is
concerned, we find that spices, tea and
cashew had been having considerable
competitiveness in the international market.
These commodities had more of exports than
imports for most of the period under this
study. In total, it is concluded that Indian
agriculture is getting competitive advantage
in international trade provided it needs more
structured and sophisticated information
sharing system in place and improved
infrastructure for handling of surplus stocks.
Keywords: WTO, India, Agriculture,
Competitiveness, Tea, Spices
I Introduction
India has a competitive advantage in several
commodities for agricultural exports because
of near self sufficiency of inputs, relatively
low labour costs and diverse agro-climatic
conditions. These factors have enabled export
of several agricultural commodities over the
years such as tea, cashew and spices. For
certain commodities like basmati rice, India
have a niche market access in spite of
competition. Trade competitiveness of
commodities is largely influenced by cost,
output prices, production structure and
quality. It is because of commodities varies
space and time. Export of agricultural
commodities from developing countries like
India is posed to a risk in term of gap in
quality and food safety standards at the
international markets. To bridge those gaps
and improve competitiveness of agricultural
commodities at world markets, India has
made several significant reforms at
institutional level. These reforms enhanced
the access to international markets with
sanitary and phytosanitary measures and
TRIPS.
Competitiveness of agricultural commodities
in international market is said to be favorable
if the agricultural commodities from one
particular nation gets quoted and traded at a
prices which is considerably higher than total
of the cost of production, storage,
transportation and value difference created by
currency exchange. If one of the agricultural
commodities fetches lower price than above
mentioned costs, it is not competitive for the
producing country. However, in recession,
downtrend in international market or in case
of bumper production or holding of excessive
stocks, producing countries usually offer a
price which remains lower than total of these
costs or in other terms, they offer a price
which is lower than the cost of acquisition of
the particular agricultural commodity. Main
reasons behind this can be contributed to the
perishability or short life of some of the
agricultural commodities. Such agricultural
commodities have to be sold at the earliest in
Page 2 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 6
May 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 255
the market. For these agricultural
commodities the highest bid price offered by
the market at one particular time is the best
price to trade. Large volume of the sea
products like fisheries can’t be stored for
long and must be traded within shortest
possible span of time. Earlier such
commodities are sold; likelihood of getting
better prices remains high. In this case,
competitiveness factor depends on price
quotations and early trading.
In international trade, initiation of the
Uruguay round of General Agreement on
Trade and tariff, led to the inclusion of
agriculture into world trading system. Since
then, in every participating nation, many
studies have been undertaken to study the
impact of agricultural trade on liberalizations
(Gulati Ashok and Kelley, Tim 1999). These
studies, on the basis of their findings, have
paved the way for some useful changes in the
domestic and foreign trade policies of these
nations. In India too, slew of such studies
have been undertaken and these studies have
also suggested various strategies and changes
in domestic policy to adjust the various
provisions of “Agreement of Agriculture”
incorporated into GATT. Base for most of
these studies have been the export
competitiveness on measures like “Nominal
Protection Coefficient (NPC) and Effective
Protection Coefficient (EPC) to suggest
whether the country has advantage in
exporting and importing different agricultural
commodities. As international price scenario
changed dramatically after 1996, it has
seriously affected the trade and
competitiveness of the agricultural
commodities. In this chapter, an attempt is
made to examine the most recent changes in
export competitiveness of selected
agricultural commodities in reference to
domestic and global prices and market trends.
Competitiveness is basically studied by
choosing a fairly long period which covers
full range of international prices from 1995
when international prices were at peak to the
year 2014-15. This duration of the study has
witnessed many peaks and downfalls in
international prices and market trends. The
focus of analysis will remain on major crops
namely Rice (Basmati & Non Basmati),
wheat, pulses, cashew, spices, tea, sugar,
cotton and other cereals.
II Objectives of the Study
The present paper is an attempt to examine
the competitiveness of Indian agricultural
under WTO regime. Thus, the objective of
the study is to analyze the tea, cashew and
spices competitiveness of Indian agriculture
under WTO regime.
III Methodology
Export competitiveness of rice have studied
for a period of 20 years i.e. from 1995-96 to
2014-15. This study is based on the
secondary data. The data has been collected
from various sources i.e. DGCIS, FAO,
Agriculture Statistics at a Glance etc. There
are mainly two types of measures which have
been widely used to reveal trade
competitiveness.
1. Nominal Protection Coefficient (NPC):
NPC is the simplest indicator of domestic
protection and export competitiveness. The
measure is given by:
NPCi = Pid /Piw
Where,
NPCi = Nominal Protection Coefficient of
the Commodity i
Pid = Domestic Price of Commodity i
Piw = World reference price (border price
equivalent) of commodity i, adjusted
for transportation, handling and
marketing expenses.
Page 3 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 6
May 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 256
NPC less than 1 indicates that the commodity
is exportable and NPC greater than 1
indicates that the commodity is importable.
2. Effective Protection Coefficient (EPC):
EPC is an improvement over NPC to the
extent that it takes care of variation in
domestic and international prices of tradable
inputs. It is defined as the ratio of value
added at domestic prices to the value added
at border prices expressed in local currency
and is given by:
EPCi= Vi
d / Vi
w
Where,
EPCi= Efficient Protection Coefficient of the
Commodity i,
Vi
d = Value added at domestic Prices
Vi
w
= Value added at world reference prices
(border price equivalents).
Like NPC, EPC greater than 1 indicates
effective incentives to producers compared to
free trade scenario and vice-versa.
In calculating EPC, fertilizers, seeds,
insecticides, pesticides and fuel used in
agricultural machinery have been treated as
tradable inputs while land, labour and capital
have been treated as primary non-tradable
inputs. Cost of cultivation data as reported by
Economic and Statistics Advisor to
government of India has been used as
available for this study to estimate various
indicators of competitiveness. While
measuring NPC and EPC, care should be
taken to use appropriate world reference
prices.
IV Tea Competitiveness of Indian
Agriculture
Several categories with wide quality
variations are produced into India. Similarly,
India’s tea export also consists of several
type of tea like green tea, black tea, dust tea
etc. The most common is dust tea and the
same has been selected to compare the
domestic and export prices.
Table 1
Domestic and International Price of Tea
(Rs/Kg)
Year Domestic
Price
World
Price NPC Value Added
Domestic Price
Border
Price EPC
1995-96 46.41 71.40 0.65 52.44 73.86 0.71
1996-97 49.20 65.60 0.75 55.60 69.50 0.80
1997-98 78.53 104.71 0.75 88.74 108.22 0.82
1998-99 80.03 102.60 0.78 90.43 113.04 0.80
1999-00 147.90 182.59 0.81 167.13 196.62 0.85
2000-01 153.65 182.92 0.84 173.62 199.57 0.87
2001-02 161.00 189.41 0.85 181.93 202.14 0.90
2002-03 160.50 203.16 0.79 181.37 215.91 0.84
2003-04 168.97 206.06 0.82 190.94 222.02 0.86
2004-05 173.74 206.83 0.84 196.33 230.97 0.85
2005-06 178.44 209.93 0.85 201.64 224.04 0.90
2006-07 201.66 245.93 0.82 227.88 264.97 0.86
2007-08 221.65 254.77 0.87 250.46 278.29 0.90
2008-09 215.64 242.29 0.89 243.67 286.67 0.85
