Page 1 of 11

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 7

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 247

Framework for urban flood vulnerability assessment

Case of Bhopal

Dr. Rajshree Kamat1 & Rudrapriya Yadav2

1 Department of Architecture and Planning, Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology, Bhopal, India

E-mail- Kamatrajshree@yahoo.co.in

2 Department of Architecture and Planning, Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology, Bhopal, India

Abs tract:

Urban Flood impact is one of the most notable disasters in the world.

Asia is considered to be the most vulnerable as more than half of

global flood damages occurs over here. Causes of these floods are

due to natural factors such as high floods, heavy rainfall and high

tides, etc., and blocking of channels or aggravation of drainage

channels, improper land use, deforestation in headwater regions, etc.,

are human factors The focus of this study is mainly upon the urban

flooding scenarios. The paper is based on studying the physical and

socio- economic indicators causing urban floods and their impacts on

the city Bhopal. Since Bhopal has been repeatedly subjected to stress

and strains of sudden increase and decrease in population. City being

a highly urbanized Municipal area has given many challenges to be

tackle through planning interventions. Urban floods are one those

challenges. Bhopal city has no significant history of urban floods.

But from last one decade we have faced many situations of urban

flooding during the monsoon season. The un-even distribution of

rainfall coupled with Mindless urbanization, encroaching upon and

filling up natural drainage channels and urban lakes to use the high- value urban land for buildings are the cause of urban flooding.

Vulnerability is the main construct in flood risk management. One of

the most significant aims of flood vulnerability assessment is to make

a clear association between the theoretical conceptions of flood

vulnerability and the daily administrative process. Variety of

indicators can be introduced to assess vulnerability therefore

selection of more appropriate methodology is vital for authorities.

The more accepted assessing method could be used to assess and

identify the most vulnerable areas. This paper also includes a suitable

framework to assess problematic flood vulnerability in urban areas.

Keywords Urban floods, flood impacts, Flood vulnerability

assessment; Flood control measures; Risk management

1. Introduction

Flooding in general and urban flooding in particular is not a

unknown event in world and in India. The un- even

distribution of rainfall coupled with Mindless urbanization,

encroaching upon and filling up natural drainage channels and

urban lakes to use the high-value urban land for buildings are

the cause of urban flooding. Unregulated development in

urban area makes the people in developing countries to occupy

the hazardous area, thus, making them vulnerable to disasters

(Kamat R. 2013)

Vulnerability is the main construct in flood risk

management. One of the most significant aims of flood

vulnerability assessment is to make a clear association

between the theoretical conceptions of flood vulnerability and

the daily administrative process (Hajar Nasiri, 2016).

2. About the study area: Bhopal

Bhopal is located in the central part of India, witnessing

rapid urban development and industrialization. Over the

decade of 1991-2001, its population had grown at about 3.5

per cent per year, higher than the national average of 2 per

cent.

2.1. Need for the study

City of Bhopal lies in the southern part of the district, and the

majority of the population resides within Bhopal municipality.

Bhopal has been repeatedly subjected to stress and strains of

sudden increase and decrease in population. After

independence, the rehabilitation of migrant population and

establishment of BHEL added to the sharp increase in the

population during the post independence era.

Table 1. Population of Bhopal, Census 2011

Description 2011 2001

Actual Population 2,371,061 1,843,510

Population Growth 28.62% 36.40%

Area (Sq. Km.) 2,772 2,772

Population density/

sq.km, 855 665

Source: Census of India, 2011 & 2001

Due to fast urbanization in Delhi during last four decades

resulting in increase in paved area and decreases in the

agricultural land, which used to act as a percolation zone and

is continuously depleting.

Figure 1. Newspaper clippings of urban flood in Bhopal

Page 2 of 11

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 7

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 248

Bhopal gets 297.4 mm in 24 hrs by 5.30 pm on, July 9, 2016,

breaking the record earlier one was 275.7mm on July 22,

1973. (SANDRP, 2016) And we also came across the same

situation in the year 2006 where Bhopal received 29cms of

rain in a span of 5 hours in the month of August. Water filled

to as high as three to four feet in about 15 low lying areas of

Bhopal.

2.2. Reasons for urban flooding

Disasters can result in failed development, but failures in

development planning can also lead to disaster risk. (Kamat

R. , 2015) Despite spending a huge amount on urban

infrastructure and planning over the years, the question

emerges why Bhopal still remains susceptible to waterlogging

within a few hours of heavy showers. If the damage is

assessed before the occurance of a disaster measures can be

taken beforehand to minimise the damages (Kamat R. 2009).

The following are the reasons identified for urban flood in the

city:

i. City’s Geographical Character

 Bhopal slopes towards north and southeast.

 Hillocks of different altitudes are situated along the

southwest and northwest parts of the urban area.

 Forming a continuous belt from the Singarcholi up to

the Vindhyachal, to an elevation of 625 metres.

ii. Dens e Urban Growth In The City

 Putting more burdens on the low- lying area.

 Due to slopes in Bhopal, rainwater water flows fast

towards low-lying areas, creating waterlogging and

flooding.

 Population density has been increases from 855 to

665 people per sq. km.

 Unauthorized development in the peripheral areas.

Source: Bhopal Development Plan, 2005

Figure 2. Growth of the city and direction of growth sprawl period area

iii. Inadequate s ewerage and Storm water drainage

 Nearly two-thirds of city does not have a proper

sewerage system, especially in the peripheral areas.

 The city’s closed drains reach only 28-30 percent of

its population.

 The sewerage system in New Bhopal (the state

capital) area is almost 40 years old. The system

operates through a 108-km sewer line

 There is no storm water drain network for the entire

city.

 The BMC has drawn up a 2,200 crore detailed project

report for setting up a sewerage network and a

`1,200 crore for setting up a storm water drain

network. But both the mega-projects are yet to get

operational on ground

iv. W ater logging

 The existing drainage system is stifled by

encroachments, which create bottlenecks in

nallahs, leading to waterlogging and flooding every

year.

 Absence of integrated sewerage or storm water

drainage network in the city.

Source: Based on data received from Bhopal Municipal Corporation, 2005-06

Development alters natural systems as vegetation and open

spaces are replaced with new areas of impervious surfaces

such as roads, parking lots, roofs, and turf, which greatly

reduce infiltration and thus ground water recharge.

Uncontrolled storm water runoff develops into Floods

Urbanization. (Sheetal Sharma, 2013)

3. Aim and Objectives of the Study

Before we discuss the Aim and Objectives of this paper,

few research questions have been prepared to reach till the

objectives of our study:

i. What are the factors influencing the flood risk in the

study area, including Land use/Land cover type?

ii. How those factors can become a set of indicators, which

can be used as a tool for flood risk analysis so that we

can assess the most vulnerable zone of the city?

iii. Which conceptual framework can be used to capture,

analyse and assess the flood risk in growing urban areas

of the city?

iv. What physical and socio- economic measures could be

taken to decrease the flood risk in the most vulnerable

area?

3.1. Aim

To develop a framework for urban flood vulnerability

assessment in the case of Bhopal.

3.2. Objectives

 To study the Socio- economic and environmental

parameters of the city along with factors influencing

the urban flood risk.

 To prepare a set of Vulnerability indicators from the

identified factors.

 To assess the identified vulnerability indicators

through a suitable framework in the city.

 To give physical proposals and planning provisions

for the most vulnerable area.

3.3. Methodology

The study was conducted in five stages, (i) Topic Selection,

which was done on the basis of researcher’s area of interest

Page 3 of 11

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 I s s ue 0 7

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 249

and also the theme of the journal given, (ii) Literature Review

was further divided in two parts where, the first one was Base

line literature review (the need of the study and the problems

were identified) and another was Detailed literature review

(understanding vulnerability concept and the types of

assessment methods). (iii) Indicator development and

evaluation of indicators based on expert survey, (iv)

Suitability of indicators and finding the most vulnerable zone

and (v) Suggestive measures & Recommendations.

A methodology that uses indicators derived from geo-data and

census data to analyze the vulnerability to floods in a dense

urban setting. A research framework will be developed to

assess and to identify problematic areas, for example, areas

with a high number of people exposed or areas with

unfavorable usage.

The study will show that variables referring to the physical

exposure of the affected population are ranked as much more

important for the present case than social characteristics, such

as age and gender, which again underlines the suitability of the

selected method.

4. Literature review

4.1. Vulnerability concept

Study aims to develop a framework for flood vulnerability

assessment using a set of indicators to identify the most

vulnerable area within the city.

(Vulnerability= Exposure+ Sensitivity- Resilience)

Vulnerability covers variety characteristics of risk such as

social, environmental physical and economic.

Vulnerability may be defined as “Vulnerabilities must always

be assessed in relation to a specified threat (or hazard): which

groups of people are vulnerable to what and why.” (IFRC,

1996)

Table 2. An overview of concept of Vulnerability

So urce Defin it io n

United nations

(1982)

Vulnerability is a degree of damage to a certain

objects at flood risk with specified amount and

present in a scale from 0 to 1 (no damage to full

damage)

Cannon (1994)

People’s conditions and their social, political and

economic behaviors in the face of risks provide

different degrees of vulnerability

Menoni and

Pergalani (1996)

Vulnerability term is damage goods, people,

buildings, infrastructures and activities in hazard

condition

Alexander

(2002)

The vulnerability of people and things to losses

attribute to a certain amount of danger and

probability that it will visible in a special

condition and with a certain degree

UNDP (2004)

Vulnerability is a condition which is influenced

by physical, social, economic and environmental

factors that raises the susceptibility of people to

the hazard impact

Wisner (2004)

The characteristics of an individual or group of

people and their condition that affect their ability

to predict, tackling, struggle, and recover from

the effects of environmental threats

Adger (2006)

Susceptibility to harm from exposure to pressures

related with environmental and social changes,

So urce Defin it io n

and in lack of adaptation ability

Næss (2006)

A function of exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive

capacity, generated by multiple factors and

processes

Balica and

Wright (2010)

Vulnerability is defined with interaction between

Exposure, susceptibility and resilience of each

community in risk condition

Borden et al.

(2007)

Distinct vulnerability means potential or

sensitivity to losses or harm. Social vulnerability

contains the susceptibility of society or social

groups to potential losses from hazards

Source: (Hajar Nasiri, 2016)

4.2. Urban floods

In urban regions there are multiple types of floods that can

occur: costal flooding, riverine flooding, flash floods, urban

floods, and drainage system floods. Urban flooding is a

growing environmental concern in cities. Accordingly,

urbanization has a significant influence on flood behavioral

changes in urban areas. The scenario study is the basic

ingredient for development of disaster management plan for

vulnerable area (Kamat R. , 2007)

Cons equences of Urban Flooding

Urban Floods results in stagnation of water on roads, railway

tracks and in few cases even at airports because of the

inadequate storm water drainage capacity. This results in

traffic jams and traffic diversions resulting in loss of man- hours.

 Communication ‐ Urban Floods results in

stagnation of water on roads, railway tracks and in

few cases even at airports because of the inadequate

storm water drainage capacity.

 Economical – As communications is disrupted

industrial production gets hampered. Prices of

essential commodities shoot up.

 Social – There is a psychological stress as safe

returns of family members are not sure. Schools and

colleges get closed. Displacement of population in

low-lying areas and collapsed structures generally

meets stiff resistance.

 Environmental – Water bodies get polluted. Waste

disposal gets hampered due to traffic disruption.

 Health ‐The stagnation of water, pollution of

potable water and accumulation of waste at dustbins

result in epidemics.

(ENVIS, 2015)

4.3. Urban flood vulnerability factors

All societies are vulnerable to floods, under different cases

and situations, which make them somewhat unique;

understanding the distinctions amongst them, may help to plan

ahead and provide policy ideas to improve the quality of

people living in them. Vulnerability assessment is done on the

basis of this equation:

(Vulnerability= Exposure+ Susceptibility- Resilien ce)

Source: (UNESCO-IHE)