Page 1 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07
June 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 32
INDIVIDUAL LEVEL DETERMINANTS OF WORKPLACE DEVIANCE
ANJUM TANWAR
(ASSISTANT PROFESSOR- INSTITUTE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT,INDIA)
ABSTRACT
Workplace deviance is turning into an
increasingly vital issue for organization.
Destructive deviant behaviors, like as theft
workplace aggression and sabotage may end
up in substantial economic and social costs for
organizations. To date, employee deviance has
usually been conceptualized as destructive.
Whereas deviant behavior may be harmful,
employee deviance can be constructive and
functional as well. Employees, who participate
in constructive deviance like innovative
behaviors, will offer organizations with
necessary creativity.
Despite the importance of understanding
employee deviance, very little is recognized on
the determinants of employee deviant
behavior. Within the study, the determinants of
both destructive and constructive deviance
were investigated. The relationship between
deviance and individual, job, organization and
cultural factors were examined. Furthermore,
it was proposed that the extent to which people
feel confident in performing their roles would
have an impact on the relationship between job
factors and workplace deviance.
By identifying the major factors relating to
employee deviance, this study attempts to
increase our understanding of the determinants
of both destructive and constructive deviance.
The findings can provide managers with new
insights in finding ways to prevent destructive
deviant behaviors, such as petty theft, and to
enhance constructive behaviors such as role
innovation.
Key Words: Workplace Deviance,
Constructive Deviance, Destructive Deviance,
Individual Determinants
1. INTRODUCTION
Workplace deviance is becoming an
increasingly important issue for organizations.
The prevalence of destructive and harmful
behaviors is surprisingly common in the
workplace. Approximately 70% of employees
have engaged in some form of destructive
deviant behavior such as losing their temper at
work (Bennett & Robinson, 2000).
Furthermore, it is estimated that annually more
than two million people become victims of
work-related crimes (Kondrasuk, Moore, &
Wang, 2001).
Destructive deviant behavior can result in
substantial economic and social costs for
organizations. According to the National Safe
Workplace Institute, dysfunctional workplace
behaviors can cost organizations
approximately 4.2 billion U.S. dollars in lost
productivity and legal expenses. Other costs
include tarnished reputations and weakened
employee morale (Filipezak, 1993).
Page 2 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07
June 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 33
To date, employee deviance has generally
been conceptualized as destructive. While
deviant behavior may be harmful, employees
who voluntarily violate the organizational
norms may be important sources of innovation
and entrepreneurship. Employees who engage
in nonconforming behaviors, such as
champions of innovations or corporate
entrepreneurs, can contribute to the innovation
process and competitive advantage of
organizations (Howell & Higgins, 1990; Shea,
& Higgins, 1998). Organizations which are
unable to tolerate deviation are often unable to
adapt, and consequently are more likely to fail
(Dehler & Welsh, 1998).
This study attempts to address the weaknesses
in the workplace deviance literature. First, this
research examines a wider range of destructive
deviant workplace behaviors rather than
specific destructive deviant behavior, such as
theft or sexual harassment. Focusing on a
broader range of destructive deviant behaviors
may provide us with a more comprehensive
understanding of destructive deviance.
Moreover, Robinson and Bennett (1997) argue
that examining a wider range of deviant
behaviors will increase our ability to predict
workplace deviant behavior.
In addition, a conceptualization of deviance as
destructive or dysfunctional, as well as
constructive or functional is presented. Unlike
the majority of the literature in workplace
deviance, this study argues that deviance may
play a constructive role in enhancing the
organization’s wellbeing. For example,
employees who engage in constructive deviant
behavior, such as innovative behavior, may
increase the organization’s competitive
advantage. By conceptualizing deviance as
constructive and destructive, one is able to
gain a more complex and complete
understanding of workplace deviance.
Jaeger and Kanungo (1990) argue the
importance of taking a cultural perspective
when examining employee behavior in a
managerial context. By using cultural
dimensions, such as
individualism/collectivism, it is possible to
identify how management behaviors differ
across developed and developing countries
(Jaeger, 1990). In an attempt to gain a better
understanding of the relationship between
cultural factors and deviance, the relationship
between individualism/collectivism and
employee deviant behavior is studied.
Although there are a number of cultural
dimensions that have been used to compare
countries, research suggests that the
individualism/collectivism dimension is a
functional dimension that differentiates
cultures (Earley, 1993; Hofstede, 1980).
Appelbaum, Iaconi and Matousek (2008)
noted that constructive or positive deviant
behaviors include behaviors that employers do
not authorize, but assist the organization in
reaching its financial and economic objectives.
The behaviors such as innovative and
creativity, noncompliance with dysfunctional
Page 3 of 16
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
I SSN: 2395-0463
Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07
June 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 34
directives, and criticizing incompetent
superiors contribute to the organization’s
competitive advantage, as well as to societal
wellbeing. On the other hand, destructive
deviant behavior involves sexual harassment,
vandalism, rumor spreading or otherwise, it
has negative consequences for the entity and
its affiliates. Workplace deviant behavior is an
occupational crime that may vary along a
continuum of severity, from minor acts to
major acts (Bennett & Robinson, 2000). Some
examples of destructive deviant behaviors are
destroying organizational property, purposely
doing work incorrectly, taking unauthorized
work breaks, hitting a coworker, insulting
others, yelling at someone, talking loudly on
the phone about personal matters during work
hours, not sharing information, making
accusations about lack of knowledge or
undermining an employee’s credibility in front
of others, shouting, gossiping and snapping at
coworkers to arrest other’s attention (Hutton,
2006; Johnson & Indvik, 2001; Pearson,
1999). Further examples of intense form of
workplace deviant behaviors include physical
aggression and violence (Dietz, Robinson,
Folger, Baron, & Schulz, 2003).
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
1. Tamir Levy and Aharon Tziner 30 August
2009 mentioned increasing attention of
destructive deviant behavior in
organizations in early years. The economic
value of deviant conduct is bearable (i.e.,
the pros from using the deviant employee
exceed the money prices of his/her
deviance) and once it becomes unbearable
(i.e., exceeds the money value of the
deviance and the benefits accrued from
his/her service). Mathematical model was
presented, which can find out this lacuna.
Likewise, a simulation exercise was
carried out and its results were reportable
so as for instance the quality of the
planned mathematical model. Later it
concluded, this model can be any studied
by trial and error within the real work.
2. Othman Mohd Yunus et al. 29 May 2012
mentioned the relationships between
employees’ temperament attribute of
emotional intelligence and workplace
intelligences. Unquestionable results
indicated a negative however vital
relationship between emotional
intelligence and workplace deviant
behaviors. Respondent’s emotional
intelligence and workplace deviance were
measured according to demographic
factors.
3. Usmani, Sania et al. October 2013 paper
examines the result of sleep deprivation on
workplace deviance through self- regulatory mechanism. The self- regulatory mechanism contains state
hostility and self-discipline. Sleep
deprivation reduces individual’s self- control whereas increasing state hostility
results in hyperbolic work deviance.
