Page 1 of 16

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 32

INDIVIDUAL LEVEL DETERMINANTS OF WORKPLACE DEVIANCE

ANJUM TANWAR

(ASSISTANT PROFESSOR- INSTITUTE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT,INDIA)

ABSTRACT

Workplace deviance is turning into an

increasingly vital issue for organization.

Destructive deviant behaviors, like as theft

workplace aggression and sabotage may end

up in substantial economic and social costs for

organizations. To date, employee deviance has

usually been conceptualized as destructive.

Whereas deviant behavior may be harmful,

employee deviance can be constructive and

functional as well. Employees, who participate

in constructive deviance like innovative

behaviors, will offer organizations with

necessary creativity.

Despite the importance of understanding

employee deviance, very little is recognized on

the determinants of employee deviant

behavior. Within the study, the determinants of

both destructive and constructive deviance

were investigated. The relationship between

deviance and individual, job, organization and

cultural factors were examined. Furthermore,

it was proposed that the extent to which people

feel confident in performing their roles would

have an impact on the relationship between job

factors and workplace deviance.

By identifying the major factors relating to

employee deviance, this study attempts to

increase our understanding of the determinants

of both destructive and constructive deviance.

The findings can provide managers with new

insights in finding ways to prevent destructive

deviant behaviors, such as petty theft, and to

enhance constructive behaviors such as role

innovation.

Key Words: Workplace Deviance,

Constructive Deviance, Destructive Deviance,

Individual Determinants

1. INTRODUCTION

Workplace deviance is becoming an

increasingly important issue for organizations.

The prevalence of destructive and harmful

behaviors is surprisingly common in the

workplace. Approximately 70% of employees

have engaged in some form of destructive

deviant behavior such as losing their temper at

work (Bennett & Robinson, 2000).

Furthermore, it is estimated that annually more

than two million people become victims of

work-related crimes (Kondrasuk, Moore, &

Wang, 2001).

Destructive deviant behavior can result in

substantial economic and social costs for

organizations. According to the National Safe

Workplace Institute, dysfunctional workplace

behaviors can cost organizations

approximately 4.2 billion U.S. dollars in lost

productivity and legal expenses. Other costs

include tarnished reputations and weakened

employee morale (Filipezak, 1993).

Page 2 of 16

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 33

To date, employee deviance has generally

been conceptualized as destructive. While

deviant behavior may be harmful, employees

who voluntarily violate the organizational

norms may be important sources of innovation

and entrepreneurship. Employees who engage

in nonconforming behaviors, such as

champions of innovations or corporate

entrepreneurs, can contribute to the innovation

process and competitive advantage of

organizations (Howell & Higgins, 1990; Shea,

& Higgins, 1998). Organizations which are

unable to tolerate deviation are often unable to

adapt, and consequently are more likely to fail

(Dehler & Welsh, 1998).

This study attempts to address the weaknesses

in the workplace deviance literature. First, this

research examines a wider range of destructive

deviant workplace behaviors rather than

specific destructive deviant behavior, such as

theft or sexual harassment. Focusing on a

broader range of destructive deviant behaviors

may provide us with a more comprehensive

understanding of destructive deviance.

Moreover, Robinson and Bennett (1997) argue

that examining a wider range of deviant

behaviors will increase our ability to predict

workplace deviant behavior.

In addition, a conceptualization of deviance as

destructive or dysfunctional, as well as

constructive or functional is presented. Unlike

the majority of the literature in workplace

deviance, this study argues that deviance may

play a constructive role in enhancing the

organization’s wellbeing. For example,

employees who engage in constructive deviant

behavior, such as innovative behavior, may

increase the organization’s competitive

advantage. By conceptualizing deviance as

constructive and destructive, one is able to

gain a more complex and complete

understanding of workplace deviance.

Jaeger and Kanungo (1990) argue the

importance of taking a cultural perspective

when examining employee behavior in a

managerial context. By using cultural

dimensions, such as

individualism/collectivism, it is possible to

identify how management behaviors differ

across developed and developing countries

(Jaeger, 1990). In an attempt to gain a better

understanding of the relationship between

cultural factors and deviance, the relationship

between individualism/collectivism and

employee deviant behavior is studied.

Although there are a number of cultural

dimensions that have been used to compare

countries, research suggests that the

individualism/collectivism dimension is a

functional dimension that differentiates

cultures (Earley, 1993; Hofstede, 1980).

Appelbaum, Iaconi and Matousek (2008)

noted that constructive or positive deviant

behaviors include behaviors that employers do

not authorize, but assist the organization in

reaching its financial and economic objectives.

The behaviors such as innovative and

creativity, noncompliance with dysfunctional

Page 3 of 16

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

I SSN: 2395-0463

Vol ume 03 Is s ue 07

June 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 34

directives, and criticizing incompetent

superiors contribute to the organization’s

competitive advantage, as well as to societal

wellbeing. On the other hand, destructive

deviant behavior involves sexual harassment,

vandalism, rumor spreading or otherwise, it

has negative consequences for the entity and

its affiliates. Workplace deviant behavior is an

occupational crime that may vary along a

continuum of severity, from minor acts to

major acts (Bennett & Robinson, 2000). Some

examples of destructive deviant behaviors are

destroying organizational property, purposely

doing work incorrectly, taking unauthorized

work breaks, hitting a coworker, insulting

others, yelling at someone, talking loudly on

the phone about personal matters during work

hours, not sharing information, making

accusations about lack of knowledge or

undermining an employee’s credibility in front

of others, shouting, gossiping and snapping at

coworkers to arrest other’s attention (Hutton,

2006; Johnson & Indvik, 2001; Pearson,

1999). Further examples of intense form of

workplace deviant behaviors include physical

aggression and violence (Dietz, Robinson,

Folger, Baron, & Schulz, 2003).

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

1. Tamir Levy and Aharon Tziner 30 August

2009 mentioned increasing attention of

destructive deviant behavior in

organizations in early years. The economic

value of deviant conduct is bearable (i.e.,

the pros from using the deviant employee

exceed the money prices of his/her

deviance) and once it becomes unbearable

(i.e., exceeds the money value of the

deviance and the benefits accrued from

his/her service). Mathematical model was

presented, which can find out this lacuna.

Likewise, a simulation exercise was

carried out and its results were reportable

so as for instance the quality of the

planned mathematical model. Later it

concluded, this model can be any studied

by trial and error within the real work.

2. Othman Mohd Yunus et al. 29 May 2012

mentioned the relationships between

employees’ temperament attribute of

emotional intelligence and workplace

intelligences. Unquestionable results

indicated a negative however vital

relationship between emotional

intelligence and workplace deviant

behaviors. Respondent’s emotional

intelligence and workplace deviance were

measured according to demographic

factors.

3. Usmani, Sania et al. October 2013 paper

examines the result of sleep deprivation on

workplace deviance through self- regulatory mechanism. The self- regulatory mechanism contains state

hostility and self-discipline. Sleep

deprivation reduces individual’s self- control whereas increasing state hostility

results in hyperbolic work deviance.