Page 1 of 14

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 10

September 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 256

Increasing Metro Ridership among HIG Neighbourhoods: Case Study Delhi

Amit Bhardwaj

(amit.bhardwaj@gov.in, Mobile, +919958712060)

NITI Aayog, Government of India

&

Vaibhav Kukreja

(vaibhav_kukreja@isb.edu, Mobile: +91-9999923754)

Indian School of Business, Hyderabad

&

Madhur Kukreja

(mkukreja26@gmail.com, Mobile, +91-8719820130)

School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi

ABSTRACT

Rapid urbanization is considered as the most significant activity of the 21st Century. As India transforms

from an agrarian economy to services driven nation, the spatial domain is undergoing transformation,

evolving towards an urban dominant nation by 2050. Against this backdrop, the mobility needs of the

people are set to increase at a rapid pace.

Perpetual congestion on urban roads in India despite the relatively lower private vehicular ownership

and the poor state of public transport scenario calls for promoting other options which can enhance the

quality of mobility for the citizens.

The magnitude of this colossal issue which is transforming into a menace has advertently led us to think

of better ways of managing the mobility of our urban centres. One such solution which many cities have

adopted for, is the greater emphasis on public transportation. Within public transport, to enhance its

quality, the emphasis on the mass transits. Delhi being one of the early adopters of Rail based mass

transit has witnessed Delhi Metro sprung up from virtually nowhere to now becoming the lifeline of

Delhi-ites.

But whether the metro has achieved what it was aimed and envisaged for, in quantitative basis, is a point

worth debating. A closer analysis reveals that though Metro has finally provided a superior public

transport experience to the city’s residents, its actual usability in terms of the modal share it has

managed to garner, does remain a point of major contention for the transport planners as well as the

other cities who are emulating similar solutions.

The study emphasises on exploring the reasons for the low metro usage for the Higher SEC

Households and suggest measures to increase the patronage of public transport, specifically Delhi

Metro amongst them. Therefore, an alternative approach to increasing the usage of metro, which is

based on the type of income group present in the vicinity of the metro stations has been explored and

results derived thereof.

___________________________________________________________________________

Page 2 of 14

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 10

September 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 257

INTRODUCTION

India has become the fastest growing major

economy in the world in 2015, outpacing

the Chinese economic growth rate last year.

As the country enters into this phase

marked with high economic growth,

urbanisation, an inevitable process, is set to

further expand its tentacles. According to

World Bank, the urbanisation rate in India

has already surpassed 35%. It is projected

to surpass 50% in the next decade.

Against this backdrop, as planners, we have

to be prepared for the ramifications

resulting from the widespread urban

demeanour of our settlements. Issues

prominent to the urban realm like housing,

mobility, environment and governance,

must be emphasised more and the actions

should be in sync with the changing

paradigm of technologies, socio- economic

character and the demands of the populace.

This thesis explicitly deals with one of the

major issues which has morphed into a

noteworthy perturbation- the mobility and

transport needs of the urban community.

Congestion, traffic jams and the blurring of

hors have become come to be associated

with an almost semblance with the major

cities, corroborating the depth of the

problem. The average travel time for

metros has already tripled in the past

decade.

The magnitude of this colossal issue which

is transforming into a menace has

advertently led us to think of better ways of

managing the mobility of our urban centres.

One such solution which many cities have

adopted for, is the greater emphasis on

public transportation. Within public

transport, to enhance its quality, the

emphasis on the mass transits. Delhi being

one of the early adopters of Rail based

mass transit has witnessed Delhi Metro

sprung up from virtually nowhere to now

becoming the lifeline of Delhi-ites.

But whether the metro has achieved what it

was aimed and envisaged for, in quantitative

basis, is a point worth debating. A closer

analysis reveals that though Metro has

finally provided a superior public transport

experience to the city’s residents, its actual

usability in terms of the modal share it has

managed to garner, does remain a point of

major contention for the transport planners

as well as the other cities who are emulating

similar solutions.

The ridership trends suggest a healthy

growth of over 20% CAGR, but research

has suggested that much of that ridership is

accrued to the shift in ridership of the

erstwhile bus users rather than the private

vehicle owners. The gap is extenuated with

data points which reveal that people

running closest to the metro, use the least

of it. The very objective of providing a state

of the art metro being accessible to all, has

been severely impacted because of it.

The study emphasises on exploring the

reasons for the low metro usage for the

Higher SEC Households and suggest

measures to increase the patronage of

public transport, specifically Delhi Metro

amongst them. Therefore, an alternative

approach to increasing the usage of metro,

which is based on the type of income group

present in the vicinity of the metro stations

has been explored and results derived

thereof.

PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION AND

NEED OF STUDY

We have seen that Delhi Metro has a

swanky infrastructure that spans over 55%

of the geographical area of the city within its

4 km buffer. This is an indication of the

fact that its accessibility is quite fantastic.

Page 3 of 14

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 10

September 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 258

The headway between the trains is 3- 4

minutes on peak time, indicating that the

capacity to cater to the population is there.

Also the trains have very high level of

punctuality.

Problem Statement

The existing metro ridership data portrays

the phenomenon of the erstwhile bus users

and auto users having shifted to the Delhi

Metro, but it hasn’t had any measurable

impact on the private vehicle users. Matter

of fact the vehicle growth rate has far super

ceded the growth rate in the metro users by

a wide margin.

It has been found that the residential

plotted areas surrounding the metro

stations are generally higher SEC

households. The metro usage amongst

them is found to be very low, despite the

metro stations being less than 2 miles away

from their homes. Interestingly, there

workplace destination too, is within a feeder

distance of Delhi metro stations. Despite

this being the scenario, the data points of

ridership segmentation shows the scenario

to the otherwise.

AIM

To increase the public transport usage for

work based trips amongst HIG

Neighbourhoods.

OBJECTIVE

 Assess the travel patterns of

identified HIG neighbourhood

 Examine the Key Performance

Indicators (KPIs) of existing trips in

metro vis-à-vis private mode.

 Segmentation of reasons for

choosing private mode over metro

 Propose planning interventions and

guidelines for enhancing metro

ridership

 Examination of potential impact of

interventions on travel

characteristics

EXPECTED OUTCOME

a. The research outcome would be a

set of approaches and interventions

to be taken in order to increase the

modal share of mass transit amongst

the higher SEC households.

METHODOLOGY

The methodology of the study is explained

as follows in a step by step direction

OVERVIEW OF DELHI METRO

TRANSIT SYSTEM

Delhi, the capital city of India, has been

blessed with one of the best and arguably,

the most successful MRTS System in the

country. With ridership figures creating a

record new high every quarter, one could

think that the monstrous problems of

mobility in urban areas have found an

effective tonic of public transport- The

mass rapid transit system.

Modal Share of Delhi

The modal share of Delhi metro as a

percentage of total trips is as shown.