Page 1 of 4
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 350
A Study on Impact of Forward Trading On the
Spot Market Prices with Special Reference to
Gold
Sanikeneni Sravanthi
M.Com(IS), UCC&BM, Osmania University, Hyderabad, Telangana State
Abstract
Trade in gold was as normal as any other commodity until the speculators have made a foray into
the bullion market and started hoarding a sheer quantum of gold either to resell at higher price or
to reap arbitrage advantage. This phenomenon is emerged as a new Alchemy which has started
forging gold from the stage of mere commodity to that of a sterling investment avenue and led to the
dawn of investment mechanics like forward trading in the segment of Yellow Metals either.
Forward trading in gold has crossed its basic frontiers of hedging with the active participation of
speculators and arbitragers hovering between spot and forward markets inflating the prices of
underlying commodity. Such price inflation would not have come to the fore if it is confined to the
Bullion markets alone. But, the cascading impact of proliferated prices in gold on other economic
variants like import bills of the country, exchange rates and collateral problems in financial system
had become a major concern why researchers and policy makers have been attempting to find the
causes and effects of gold price volatility. Thus it is strongly felt necessary to analyze how far
forward trading affects the price of gold. It is with this intention a paper titled “Impact of Forward
Trading on the Spot Market Prices” is proposed with the twin objectives of studying the trends of
spot and forward market prices of gold in India and quantifying the impact of forward rates on spot
rates in long run.
Key Words: Forward rates, Spot rate, Bullion Market.
Introduction
The concept of Delta hedging which
determines the price of a derivative contract
on the basis of the price movement of the
underlying asset seems to have been capsized
owing to the autonomous volatility and
speculative trends in forward markets which
in turn has been causing abnormal
fluctuations in the spot market prices of the
underlying assets.
Review of Literature
Mohapatra (2010) this phenomenon is
observed to be more persistent in Indian
bullion market where precious metals like
gold and silver are not bought and sold by the
traders and investors alone. Rather,
households also occupy an impeccable
position in buying, hoarding and reselling
such metals in the form of ornaments who
exhibits a herd behavior under the conditions
Page 2 of 4
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 351
of semi strong form of market efficiency
hypothesis
Singh & Goyal (2011) More often than not,
individuals who are not prone to the
mechanics of commodity exchanges take the
cognizance of information available in news
papers with respect to the prices of forward
and future contracts of gold and starts forming
assumptions on the spot market prices
Lokare (2007) Therefore, an obvious
question arises at this juncture whether spot
market prices have been determining the
prices of forward contracts or the forward
trading trends have been furthering the spot
prices in Indian Bullion Market? The question
is attempted with the following two
objectives.
Alexander (2013) Apart from these primary
reasons, there are few more causes of spot
market volatility of gold prices which mainly
includes corrections in financial markets,
parking of gold in safe havens, bullish
expectations on speculative profits,
smuggling of gold across the international
frontiers and the like.
Guptha S. N (2013) Guptha also argued in
his paper that lack of quantitative restrictions
on the volumes of forward trading is also a
prime reason for occurring price currents in
the forward markets from which the spot
market mechanism is not insulated.
Objectives of the Study
The main objectives of the study are,
1. To study the reasons for price
volatility in Indian bullion market
with reference to gold.
2. To assess the impact of forward prices
of gold on the spot prices.
Research Methodology
The first objective shall be accomplished
through reviewing the expert opinions
available in professional blogs and research
journals to trace the reasons for volatility in
Indian bullion market. The second objective
which forms the core of this paper shall be
tested with the following hypothesis.
Null Hypothesis (H0): forward prices of gold
could not impact the spot market prices of
gold in India.
Alternative Hypothesis (H1): forward prices
of gold have been impacting the spot prices of
gold in India.
The null hypothesis is tested with the help of
a bivariate linear regression as shown bellow.
∑Yi = β1+ β2∑Xi +μ
Where, Y = spot market price of gold
X = forward price of gold
β1, β2 and μ represents slope coefficient,
parameter coefficient and error value
respectively for the given observations of I =
1. . .n.
Assumptions based on which the regression
line is established
1. There is a positive correlation between
the forward and spot market prices of
gold.
2. Error value μ is assumed to be
nullified under the conditions of
goodness of fit.
Sample Size
This paper is animated with the sample size of
secondary data of forward and spot prices of
gold for three years i.e. from April 2011 to
March 2014which is deemed to be a long run
time period in the spectrum of investments.
Bimonthly average of both forward and spot
Page 3 of 4
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 352
prices are obtained under the ambit of sample
size of this study.
Reasons for Price Volatility in Indian
Bullion Market
It is hardly feasible to extract the exact list of
reasons why gold prices are volatile in the
feeble markets like India having a chequered
history of more than two thousand years of
buying and selling gold as an asset, ornament
and of course as an instrument of speculation.
But a thorough review of literature and expert
opinions enables us to codify the following
contemporary reasons for the volatility of
gold prices.
Price Manipulation: according to The
World Gold Council central banks of all the
countries have been hoarding more than thirty
two thousand ton of gold and among whom
the powerful economies having control on the
supply side economies of the global bullion
markets have been seamlessly endeavoring to
inflate the prices of gold to square off their
position and to augment international
currency flows into their countries.
Forward Trading: ever since India has
legalized forward trading, markets have
acquired new facets of speculation from
which bullion markets are not an exemption.
Indeed, inflationary pressures are mounting
up day by day in both essential commodities
and investment instruments like gold and
silver due to the unveiling of opportunities in
framing forward contracts.
Currency Debasement and Hedging
Policies: most of the central banks have been
hoarding gold as an instrument of hedging.
The strategy underlying is very simple. If the
exchange rate of home currency is
depreciated to an undesirable level against the
strong currency. The central bank can dispose
the gold in international market and ensure
the inflow of such strong currency into the
country through which currency debasement
is avoided. But such strategy creates huge
gaps between the supply and demand sides of
domestic bullion markets and enhances the
spot market prices of gold.
Data Analysis
Table-1 Regression analysis
Multiple R 0.881362
R Square 0.776799
Adjusted R Square 0.762849
Standard Error 1358.761
Observations 18
