Page 1 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 13

December 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 552

Self Help Groups: A Comparative Study of Two Groups

Dr Sukh Raj Singh

Asst. Professor

Post Graduate Department of Commerce

SGGS College, Sector 26,Chandigarh.

E-mail : sukhraj007_sandhu@yahoo.com

Abstract

Indian economy is cursed by the private money lenders particularly in the rural areas by

centuries. To curve them, a concept of Self Help Group was evolved in India. In this study

attempt has been made to check the performance of SHGs by taking one village of District

Nawanshahr (Punjab). A sample of 30 women is taken and a questionnaire containing 18

questions is prepared to collect the data. The research shows that without any shred of doubt

these SHGs are performing in a fantastic way for improving the standard of living of poor

villagers by providing them financial facilities. But as these groups are new establishments

some weaknesses are also there but they can be improved.

Introduction

An important character of Indian economy is non-involvement of the people in

developmental efforts and total dependence on the government. Some of the developing

countries like Bangladesh, Kenya, Korea and Nepal experienced better impact and results

when the various credit programmes for agriculture and rural development were modeled on

participatory approach. Seeing the good results, the international agencies like World Bank

and International Labour Organization tried to link various developmental programmes with

people’s movement. Against this backdrop, the concept of Self Help Groups (SHG) appears

to be a good alternative strategy to involve people in the developmental process. The

Agriculture Credit Review Committee (1989) had identified a number of weaknesses in the

Page 2 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 13

December 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 553

Indian banking system such as low recovery, poor recycling of funds, poor deposits

mobilization and ineffective lending. Apart from the weaknesses the banking sector has been

able to reach only about 36% of the rural families’ inspite of vast expansion. On the other

hand, most of the informal finance in the rural money market comes from two main sources

i.e. professional money lenders and traders but the rate of interest demanded by them is

exorbitant and sometimes usurious which leads to perpetual indebtedness of the rural poor.

However, the easy and timely availability, flexibility in delivery to the needy clientele places

them better as compared to the formal financial agencies. The SHG linkage to banking sector

is expected to combine specific advantage of both the above systems and also enable larger

and faster coverage of rural poor.

A Self Help Group is an organization of such poor people whose social and economic

condition is almost the same i.e. homogeneous. They organize the group voluntarily and its

members make small savings equally out of their income. The savings can be made at the

time of weekly, fortnightly or monthly meetings. The savings so made are used for lending to

the needy members of the group to meet their pressing demand on account of illness,

marriage, employment or agricultural purpose. These groups can also be named as ‘Micro

Bank’ of the poor. In a nut shell, SHG can be considered as a small, economically weak and

affinity group of rural poor, voluntarily formed to save and mutually agree to contribute to a

common fund to be lent to its members as per group decision. The objective of the present

study is to measure the performance of SHGs by comparing two groups i.e. Dashmesh SHG

and Mahavir SHG of Bhan Mazara village of district Nawanshahr.

Research Methodology

(I) Questionnaire Design

Questionnaire was non-disguised and in structured form so as to draw maximum

information. This questionnaire includes personal profile so as to know about the marital

status, occupation and income of the members of the groups which helped in explaining

uniqueness of the groups. 18 questions were asked from member of both the groups. These

questions were designed to help in knowing about the saving habits, need for joining the

Page 3 of 10

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 03 Issue 13

December 2017

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 554

group, benefits received from the group, working habit, dealing with banks and suggestion

from them.

(II) Selection of Groups

Data was collected from two groups i.e. Dashmesh SHG and Mahavir SHG of Bhan

Mazara village of Nawanshahr district.

(III) Population and Sample

The survey was conducted at Nawanshahr district, from which two groups of one

village is chosen on the basis of convenience. Sample size of 30 was randomly taken from

two groups. This sample included only females as they were the only members of the groups.

(IV) Techniques of data collection

Data was collected from two sources-

(a) Primary Sources – This source consists of direct interview of members of

groups of village Bhan Mazara who are chosen on the basis of convenience from Nawanshahr

district by asking them to fill a questionnaire especially designed for this study.

(b) Secondary Sources – For this study, the information was also taken from

internet, journals, books and literature from Jalandhar Central Cooperative Bank.

Assessment of SHGs

Two groups i.e. Dashmesh SHG and Mahavir SHG of Bhan Mazara village of

Nawanshahr district comprising 30 women were assessed on 18 indicators given by

NABARD as follows:-

Indicator 1 – Feeling of homogeneity/solidarity

Name of SHG Ranking