Page 1 of 5
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 471
Doctrine of Ultra Vires-Effects and Exceptions
Karamdeep Saini
Asst. Professor Institute of law Kurukshetra University kurukshetra
Abstract
Company is an artificial legal person that is incorporated by law, which generally emphasize on the
fact that when it comes to incorporation of a company Memorandum of Association and Articles of
Association are the core documents without which a company's incorporation is impossible.
Memorandum of association limits the company's operation and authorities, beyond which the acts are
ultra-vires. The present paper focuses on the Ultra vires transactions, their exceptions and the leading
cases for Ultra vires transactions.
Introduction
The Memorandum of Association is the charter
of the company. It is the document that
specifies the relation of the company with the
outsiders. The memorandum is divided into six
clauses i.e. Name, Object, Situation, Liability,
Capital and Association clause. It is divided
into paragraphs. Memorandum is the
foundation on which the edifice of the
company is built. Its basic importance lies in
the fact that a company cannot undertake any
activity that is not listed in its memorandum of
association.
Literature Review
Journal on Contemporary issue of law has
been reviewed which is based on critical
analysis of the doctrine of ultra virus.
Company Act, 2013 has been studied in
reference to study the prospective of company
formation if ultra virus doctrine is made in
order to regulate the functioning of companies.
Statement of Problem
Every activity or transaction which is beyond
the purview of memorandum of association
leads to the creation of ultra virus transactions.
So the present paper will reveal that what the
ultra vires transactions are? What are their
exceptions and the leading cases of ultra vires
transactions.
Objectives of paper
To study the ultra vires transactions and
their exceptions;
To study the leading cases of ultra vires
transactions
To study the current scenario of doctrine of
ultra vires in india
Research Methodology
This paper is of descriptive nature. Secondary
data has been analyzed in order to derive the
legal framework of ultra vires by studying its
various variable, which can be best suited to
serve the purpose of study.
Analysis and Interpretation
1. Ultra vires transactions.
Any act or transaction that is beyond the
objective of the company mentioned in the
memorandum of association or which is not
related with the purpose of the business
mentioned in the company's memorandum is
known as ultra vires transactions. Such an act,
which is beyond the company rights defined in
it's memorandum, is void and the law doesn't
recognize it. even if all the members of the
company unanimously support the company's
action, it is not legally valid or acceptable.
Objectives of adding the concept of ultra vires
transactions in company's Act
To protect the interest of the investors
especially shareholders i.e. the money
invested by them must only be used for the
commercial objectives of the company.
To protect the interest of the outsiders dealing
with the company to assure the legal utilization
of their funds lent to the company.
Actions beyond the power of the company
Any act that is not explicitly explained or
mentioned in the company's memorandum is
known to be ultra vires, it is void and cannot be
Page 2 of 5
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 472
legally executed. Any act which is mentioned
or under the purview of memorandum of
association but is not favored or stated in
Articles is said to be ultra vires and void unless
it is amended by a special resolution. Any
activity or transaction done by the director of
the company beyond his authority is ultra vires
till a special resolution is not passed for giving
the legal effect to same.
Exceptions to the Doctrine of Ultra Vires
Activities beyond the authority of the directors
but within the limits of the company and it's
authority is valid. Activities beyond the Article
of Association can be made valid by passing a
special resolution and altering the articles.
Actions within the limits of the memorandum
of company done in irregular manner can be
approved by shareholders and will be valid.
Lending beyond the company's memorandum
limit to any outsider is valid and the third party
can be sued for repayment. Loan taken by
company beyond it's authority and the money is
utilized to pay off business debts, the creditors
will be valid and would be paid off.
Ultra vires transactions are void and the
member or director concerned will be
personally liable for the same. Ultra vires
acquired property by the directors will be the
company's fixed capital and the breach of the
authority by the directors will make them
personally liable. Even the actions done by the
employees beyond their scope will not make
the company liable for their void actions".
2. Leading Cases of Ultra Vires
The verdict of house of lords in the case of The
Directors, &C., of the Ashbury Railway
Carriage and Iron Company
(Limited) v Hector Riche, (1874-75) L.R. 7
H.L. 653.
The objects of this company, as stated in the
Memorandum of Association, were to supply
and sell the materials required to construct
railways, but not to undertake their
construction. The contract here was to
construct a railway. That was contrary to the
memorandum of association; what was done by
the directors in entering into that contract was
therefore in direct contravention of the
provisions of the Company Act, 1862
1.It was held that this contract, being of a nature
not included in the Memorandum of
Association, was ultra vires not only of the
directors but of the whole company, so that
even the subsequent assent of the whole body
of shareholders would have no power to ratify
it. The shareholders might have passed a
resolution sanctioning the release, or altering
the terms in the articles of association upon
which releases might be granted. If they had
sanctioned what had been done without the
formality of a resolution, that would have
been perfectly sufficient. Thus, the contract
entered into by the company was not a
voidable contract merely, but being in
violation of the prohibition contained in the
Companies Act , was absolutely void. It is
exactly in the same condition as if no contract
at all had been made, and therefore a
ratification of it is not possible. If there had
been an actual ratification, it could not have
given life to a contract which had no
existence in itself; but at the utmost it would
have amounted to a sanction by the
shareholders to the act of the directors, which,
if given before the contract was entered into,
would not have
2. A.lakshman Swami Mudaliar vs LIC is a
case which support doctrine of ultra vires. In
this case the director of the company were
authorized to make payment for any work
which is going to be useful for general public.
After getting shareholder resolution the
directors paid 2 laces to a trust formed for the
purpose of promoting technical and business
knowledge. L.I.C take over the company
business, it had no business left of its own. In
Result of it supreme court observed that any
act of the company that crossed the limits of
objects was void even if is unanimously
accepted by the company's shareholders. It
was ultra vires because directors were not
authorized to make spend company money on
any charitable or general objects. They could
spend only those activity which are meant to
promote the company's objects.
There was a problem loading this page. Retrying...
Page 3 of 5
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 473
Eley v The Positive Government Security
Life Assurance Company, Limited (1875-76)
L.R. 1 Ex. D. 88
It was held that the articles of association were
a matter between the shareholders inter se, or
the shareholders and the directors, and did not
create any contract between the plaintiff and
the company and article is either a stipulation
which would bind the members, or else a
mandate to the directors. In either case it is a
matter between the directors and shareholders,
and not between them and the plaintiff.
made it valid, as it does not relate to an object
within the scope of the memorandum of
association.
Shuttleworth v Cox Brothers and Company
(Maidenhead), Limited, and Others, [1927] 2
K.B. 9
It was held that
the contract, if any, between the plaintiff
and the company contained in the articles
in their original form was subject to the
statutory power of alteration and
if the alteration was bona fide for the
benefit of the company it was valid and
there was no breach of that contract;
there was no ground for saying that the
alteration could not reasonably be
considered for the benefit of the company;
there being no evidence of bad faith, there
was no ground for questioning the decision
of the shareholders that the alteration was
for the benefit of the company; and,
the plaintiff was not entitled to the relief
claimed.
In Re New British Iron Company, [1898] 1
Ch. 324
It was held that the article is not in itself a
contract between the company and the
directors; it is only part of the contract
constituted by the articles of association
between the members of the company inter se.
But where on the footing of that article the
directors are employed by the company and
accept office the terms of art. 62 are embodied
in and form part of the contract between the
company and the directors. Under the article as
thus embodied the directors obtain a
contractual right to an annual sum of 1000l as
remuneration. It was held also that although
these provisions in the articles were only part
of the contract between the shareholders inter
se, the provisions were, on the directors being
employed and accepting office on the footing
of them, embodied in the contract between the
company and the directors; that the
remuneration was not due to the directors in
their character of members, but under the
contract so embodying the provisions; and that,
in the winding-up of the company, the directors
were entitled to rank as ordinary creditors in
respect of the remuneration due to them at the
commencement of the winding-up.
Rayfield v Hands and Others, [1957 R. No.
603.]
Field-Davis Ltd. was a private company
carrying on business as builders and
contractors, incorporated in 1941 under the
Companies Act, 1929 , as a company limited
by shares, having a share capital of £4,000,
divided into 4,000 ordinary shares of £1 each,
of which 2,900 fully-paid shares had been
issued. The plaintiff, Frank Leslie Rayfield,
was the registered holder of 725 of those
shares, and the defendants, Gordon Wyndham
Hands, Alfred William Scales and Donald
Davies were at all material times the sole
directors of the company. The plaintiff was a
shareholder in a company. Article 11 of the
articles of association of the company required
to inform the directors of his intention to
transfer shares in the company, and which
provided that the directors “will take the said
shares equally between them at a fair value.” In
accordance with this the plaintiff so notified the
directors, who contended that they need not
take and pay for the plaintiff’s shares, on the
ground that the articles imposed no such
liability upon them.
The plaintiffs claimed for the determination of
the fair value of his shares, and for an order
that the directors should purchase such shares
at a fair value. It was found that the true
There was a problem loading this page. Retrying...
