Page 1 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 170
Assessment of Factors of Motorcycle
Accident in Urban Centre: A Case Study of
Ado-Ekiti. Ekiti State, Nigeria
Sanmi Adeoti (Mnitp, Rtp)1 Anthony Peter (Mnia)2
1
Senior Lecturer Department of Urban and Regional Planning, The Federal Polytechnic, Ado Ekiti
e- Mail: adeoti.sanmi@yahoo.com
2
Principal Lecturer Department of Architectural Technology, The Federal Polytechnic, Ado Ekiti e- Mail: anthonypeter56@yahoo,com
.
Abstract
Road accidents, particularly motorcycle accidents, have not only become a normal and re-occurring phenomenon in
developing countries but equally constitute a major emerging public health problem in Nigeria and contribute
significantly to the overall road traffic injuries. Unfortunately, motorcycle accidents which cause injuries and death
have not received the adequate attention deserved as the situation is worsening in our major cities. These eventually
made this paper to appraise the contributing factors of motorcycle accidents in Ado-Ekiti. The study designed 460
questionnaires to collect primary data from 460 samples, representing 10 percent of the commercial motorcycle
operators in the study area. The secondary data were also collected from Ekiti State Teaching Hospital. The collected
data were subjected to descriptive and inferential statistics analysis of simple frequency percentage and regression
analysis. The result of Findings revealed that the annual increase in rate of commercial motorcycle accident is as a
result of many factors which include lack of training exposure, poor physical environment together with population
growth including the manner of Okada riders. On this note, the training and retraining of motorcycle riders should be
encouraged while the segregation of cyclist route from arterials will go a long way in reducing motorcycle accidents.
Keywords: Population; Motorcycles; Training; Accidents; Traffic; Fatality.
1.0 Introduction
Accident is generally considered as an
unintentional and unforeseen event which normally
results to property damage, personal injury and even
death. However, it is regarded as road traffic accidents
(RTAs) when the incidents occur through collision of
anything with moving objects particularly vehicles at a
road or street that open to public traffic and result in -
one or more persons being killed or injured. For
instance, transport accident as defined by [1] is any
accident involving a device designed primarily for, or
being used at the time primarily for, conveying persons
or goods from one place to another Therefore, RTA
could be motor vehicles accidents that involve buses,
cars and motorcycles or non-motor vehicles accident in
form of bicycle, animal or man drowns carts.
It is important to note that majority of road
accidents which are not severe or involved lost of life
are settled at the spot of the accident with mutual
understanding of both parties. At the same time,
available studies revealed that road traffic accidents are
major cause of death and disability globally with a
disproportionate number occurring in developing
countries where the usage of motorcycle dominate
public transport.
This paper therefore takes into consideration
the concept of traffic management to properly reviews
relevant issues on traffic accidents globally, determine
the rate of motorcycle accident and also assess the
contributing factor in Ado Ekiti.
2.0 Conceptual Framework and Review of Literature
A conceptual framework as pointed out in [2] is defined as a diagram of proposed causal linkages among a set
of concepts which are considered to be related to a particular public problem. In this study the conceptual framework is
based on theory of traffic management system of humans, institutions vehicles and the road infrastructure components.
The failure and the improper interaction of these components as result of constraints are weakness that always results to
road traffic accident. Hence, every accident is not usually attributable to a single cause but to a chain of unique multiple
factors or failures as shown in figure 1
Page 2 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 171
Fig 1: Traffic management problems as accidents
The human failure is attributed to road user’s
errors while the road design deficiency is the major
road problem. The vehicle failure is as result of vehicle
defects while the institutional failure could be
attributed to the poor legal framework
Generally, the efficiency and safety of road
traffic depends on the performance and interaction of
these components, [3].,However, as in [4] it was also of
the opinion that road traffic accident is a rare, random,
multiple factor event, always preceded by a situation in
which one or more road users failed to cope with the
road and its environment. As a random event of time
and location (space), it is impossible to predict actually
where or when the next road accident will occur.
Among the human factors, alcohol
consumption is known to impair driving and riding
performance and is more implicated frequently in fatal
crashes than non - fatal crashes.[5]. It is equally
pointed out as in [6] that the impairment by alcohol and
other drugs is potentially more risky for motorcyclists
than for car drivers due to the balance and
awareness required to ride in the traffic
environment. At the same time, under age and lack of
proper and adequate training of the job as well as non
compliance to traffic rule are contributing factors to
road accident as in [7]
The identifying road hazards that contribute to
vehicular accident are numerous. These include
potholes, slippery road conditions, wet roads, loose
stone or gravel, winding roads, blind spots as in [8].
Other factors in term of Poor weather conditions as
pointed out in [9] include rain, fog, or even snow while
[10] concluded that the condition of the road, in term of
lack of visibility, obstructions, unclean road, poor road
materials and horizontal curvature actively contributed
to about15% of the crashes. It is also noted that Vehicle
defects is another major and significant factor of traffic
accident. Hence as explained in.[11] and [12] explained
that lack of regular maintenance, of which defective
tires and brakes failure are mostly frequently. This
made vehicle defects to contribute not less than 5% of
crashes.
Transport regulations in developing countries in term
of weak and inadequate traffic laws have impact on
road accident. At the same time, there are inefficient
regulatory authorities to monitor user requirements and
to provide an environment conducive for transport
services. This no doubt as explained in [13] creates
room for motorists to break traffic rules and hence lead
to accidents. As a matter of fact, ineffectiveness in
traffic law enforcement by the police is perceived as a
major motivation for aspects of careless driving in
Ghana [14]. In a more comprehensive dimension as
considered in [15], dangerous driving and excessive
speeding; traffic conflicts of the motorized and the
non-motorized in the urban built environment;
inclement weather condition; lack of pedestrian
facilities; narrow roads and poor maintenance of roads
as well as in adequate or absence of road signs are
notable factors of road transport accident
It is estimated that 3,000 people die and
30,000 are seriously injured on the world's roads every
day [16]. The number of life lost globally in road
traffic accident (RTA) each year as revealed in [1] was
estimated to be between1.2 and 1.3 million with the
number of injury people as high as 50 million
representing 2 lost lives per minute of which about
90% occurred in low and middle income countries.
This translates to 2 lost lives per minute.
. The small size and the unprotected nature of
motorcycles make them to be most dangerous and
highly risky mode of transport. Contrary to a car crash,
HUMAN FAILURE ROAD INFRASTRUCTURE
VEHICLE FAILURE INSTITUTIONAL FAILURE
Road Traffic Accident
(Causes)
Page 3 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 03 Issue 13
December 2017
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 172
in a motorcycle crash, the riders often absorb all kinetic
and compressive energy resulting from the crash [17].
These actually make many research studies to consider
motorcycle riders the most vulnerable group of road
users. As revealed in [18],[19] motorcycle injuries are
among the leading causes of disability and deaths and
the main victims are the motorcyclists, passengers and
pedestrians in their young reproductive age group.
Likewise,[20] in his paper explained that motorcyclists
are about three times more likely than car occupants to
be injured in a crash, and 16 times more likely to die.
The problem is increasing at a fast rate in
developing countries due to rapid motorization and
other factors [21]. For instance, the rate of registered
motorcycles drastically increased in Thailand in recent
years, with 35.1 per 1,000 population in 2013
compared to 26.3 per 1,000 population in 2008 while
Nigeria witnessed a mushrooming of imported
motorcycles between year 2007 and 2009 from 6700 to
85000 respectively[19] Africa is equally noted to have
the highest fatality rate of 28.3 per 100,000 population
as against developed world of North America with12.1
to 16.2 per 100,000 population [22], [23]..In fact,[24].
Libya has the highest rate of accident in the world with
73.4 per 100000 population while Nigeria recorded the
list in West Africa with 20.5 per 100000 population.
The social and economic impacts of road
traffic accident are very sensitive as they are not only
affect the life of individual family and the government
but also have cost implications on affected properties
of the society at large. The record of [24] as pointed
out by [16] revealed that the global economic cost of
road traffic accident was estimated at $518 billion per
year in 2003 and $100 billion out of which many occur
in poor developing countries and Nigeria lost about 80
billion naira. It is equally revealed as in [25] that more
than a million people die each year on the world’s
roads while, the cost of dealing with the consequences
of these crashes runs to billions of dollars The
economic burden of motorcycle accidents was
estimated to be about US$1.2 million, of which, 52%
were accident-related costs (i.e. property damage and
administration) and 48% casualty-related costs (i.e.
medical costs, out-of-pocket expenses, lost labour
outputs, intangible costs and funeral expenses).[26] .
3.0 Study Area and Methods.
The study area is in Ado Ekiti is located on
latitude 74’ north of the Equator and 5 east of the
Greenwich Meridian. The physical development of the
city actually contributes a lot to the rapid population
growth and spatial expansion. In fact,as pointed out
by[27] the population of the city which was about
20,000 in 1921 rose to over 150,000 in 1963 and
jumped to almost 400,000 with 2006 population census
and projected to almost 500,000 for 2016. At the time,
the area of the town increased from 6.9km2 in 1961 to
about 36.7km2 in 2006. This development makes the
volume of registered motorcycle as public transport
(Okada) in Ado Ekiri which was about 623 in 1996 to
jumpe to 6042 in 2006 and by 2016 the number of
okada plying the city has increased to almost
10000.These motorcycles are grouped under four zonal
areas and operate within 46 terminal routes.
The method of study made use of both
primary and secondary sources of data collections. The
primary data relates to information generated through
field work exercise. This involves the design of 460
questionnaires for selected Okada riders through
stratified random sample technique. The secondary
data is all about information gathered from journal and
relevant data collected from Ekiti State University
Teaching Hospital and Okada Riders Association in
Ado-Ekiti through oral interview.
The collected data were subjected to
descriptive and inferential statistics. The descriptive
analysis involves the use of quantitative tables for the
presentation of the data while multiple regression
analysis model was employed to determine the
influence of human, physical environmental and
institutional factors on the accident rate. The model is
presented as LnY = a + b1X1 + b2X2 + b3X3 + e
where Y stands for the accident rate X1 for human
factors, X2 for physical environment X3 for
technology or vehicle condition and e as error term.
4.0 Analysis of Findings and Discussion
4.1 Analysis of Findings: The analysis of findings is based on two major areas, namely descriptive and inferential
analysis
The descriptive analysis focused on general background, exposure and behaviour of Okada riders as well as
accident rate and safety indices. For instance, the general background in table 1clearly indicated that the respondents
that were between the age of 25 and 50 years constituted the majority with 52.17. It is also noted that married status
