Page 1 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 01
January 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 141
The African Growth and Opportunity Act
(AGOA) and Poverty Reduction in Nigeria
(2000-2015) an Appraisal
Okiete Solomon
Department of Political/Admin. Studies, University of Port Harcourt, Choba, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
N.J Nna
Department of Political/Admin. Studies, University of Port Harcourt, Choba, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
Abstract
The paper analyzes the contributions of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), to poverty
reduction in Nigeria between 2000 and 2015. According to the proponents of the U.S. trade policy, it
is expected to promote prosperity in the beneficiary countries. But our findings have shown that AGOA
failed in reducing poverty in Nigeria, as poverty rates in the post-AGOA years are higher than in the
pre-AGOA years. This is because Nigeria’s export basket to the United States is still dominated by
crude oil, and the oil sectorhas limited job-creation capacity, which is a necessary prerequisite for
poverty reduction. The non-oil sector which has the capacity to create jobs due to its labor-intensive
nature has not shown any significant growth. The paper identifies the very high standard of the U.S
market and the inability of Nigeria’s firms to meet that standard as part of the constraint. And suggests
amongst other things that rather than depend on the developed countries for her economic salvation,
Nigeria should develop its own home grown development model.
Keywords: Economic, Development, Growth, Opportunity, Act, Poverty, Reduction.
1.0 Introduction
Poverty is a major problem in Africa. Onuoha
(2001) notes that there is a sharp contrast
between the pervasive poverty and
backwardness of Africa and the prosperity of
advanced capitalist societies. The World Bank
development Report 1990 estimates that more
than a billion people in most parts of the
developing world live on less than a dollar a
day. (Forae and Benedict, 2011).Chen and
Ravallion (2004) in Forae and Benedict (2011)
reports that in the early 1980s Sub-Saharan
Africa, with a head count ratio of 0.42, ranked
as the third highest poverty incident region.
And by 1987 it graduated to become the region
with the highest incidence of poverty.
According to a UNDP report, about 50 percent
of Nigerians live in abject poverty as at 1990.
And it became worse for about 17-18 percent
of household in the country from 1985 to 1992
(i.e. about 18 million people).
This development has elicited some form of
‘sympathy’ from the advanced western society
which over the decades has come up with one
program or the other to help lift the Sub- Saharan countries out of the shackles and
throes of poverty. Their intervention, according
to them is premised on the philosophy that
Page 2 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 01
January 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 142
poverty anywhere is a threat and danger to
prosperity everywhere and prosperity anywhere
must be shared everywhere (Jhingan,
1997).However, after decades of development
assistance in the form of aids and loans failed
to bring the needed development, they decided
to change to trade (Onimode, 2003; Naneen,
2015). The proponents of the ‘aid to trade’
policy argue that what Africa needed to defeat
poverty was ‘trade’ and not ‘aid’ (Naneen,
2015).This change of policy was borne out of
the belief by liberal economic scholars that the
benefits to trade will spread to all the parties in
the trade relationship, thereby inducing
development in the less developed countries.
(Neff, 1990).
Thus, in May, 2000, the Clinton administration
signed into law the African Growth and
Opportunity Act (AGOA), to give effect to the
‘aid to trade policy. AGOA is a preferential
trade policy of the United States, U.S. that
opens U.S. markets to about 6,400 products
from selected, Sub-Saharan Africa Countries,
duty-free and quota- free,www.agoa.gov.Retrieved20/11/16). It is
the cornerstone of U.S government’s economic
policy towards African (McCornic, 2006). And
is expected to boost economic development in
the beneficiary countries, through trade and
investments (Okolie, 2006).Nigeria is one of
the beneficiary countries, having been granted
eligibility status in October, 2000
(www.trade.gov./agoa/eligibility/index.asp).
This paper tries to analyze the effectiveness of
AGOA in reducing poverty in Nigeria between
2000 and 2015.
2.0 The Concept Of Poverty
Poverty is a state of economic and social
deprivation. The inability of a person to meet
his food, shelter, healthcare and educational
needs due to insufficient and inadequate
income (Okoh, 1998). Poverty manifests in
several ways, some of them are: lack of income
and food, hunger and malnutrition, ill health,
lack of limited access to education and other
basic needs. Others are: increment in mortality
rate, inadequate housing,unsafe and polluted
environment (UN, 1995). Yahie (1993) states
that poverty is caused by lack of skills, limited
resources, locational disadvantage, which he
refers to as structural causes. It is also caused
by transitional factors like changesin economic
policies that could lead to increase in prices
beyond the reach of most households, job
losses, natural disasters like famine, drought
and wars.Aluko (1975) conceptualize poverty
as lack of access to basic consumption needs
like food, clothing and shelter.
Obadan (1997) identifies inadequate access to
employment opportunities, insufficient
availability of factors of production like land,
capital and lack of access to credit as the cause
of poverty. Poverty has some devastating
consequences in its victims.Von Hauff and
Kruse (1994) observe that poverty causes
inadequate nourishment, lack of good health
care, education, that leads to physical and
psychological trauma. At the national level,
poverty leads to formation of slums in the cities
and ecological problems arising from the
indiscriminate felling of tress by the poor for
cooking purposes.According to Narayan et al
(2000), most families are near breaking point
due to the harsh effect of poverty, as the men
who are naturally the bread-winners have taken
to alcoholism and domestic violence.According
Page 3 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 01
January 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 143
to the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS)
(2000), a person is said to be poor when he
does not spend up to 23,733.00 per annum.
3.0 AGOA and Poverty Reduction in
Nigeria
The original intention of AGOA is to help to
diversify the economy of Nigeria away from
oil. It is expected to catalyze and stimulate the
growth of the non-oil sector, which has the
capability to boost job creation. And when
people have jobs, poverty will reduce. But
unfortunately, the 15 years of AGOA
implementation in Nigeria has not seen that
happen. The oil sector still enjoys an
overwhelming preponderance of Nigeria’s
exports to the United States. According to Ate,
(1983), oil accounts for an average of 82-93
percent annually of the country’s revenue; over
90% of total export and about 90% of foreign
reserves. This is so much so that the economic
wellbeing of most Nigerians has come to be
tied to oil income.Until recently (2013), the
U.S market absorbs more than half of Nigeria’s
oil export. Thus, giving the U.S the power to
drastically influence the demand for Nigerian
Oil. This has placed the U.S in a position to
manipulate the Nigeria’s economy to suit her
purposes.
And as long as oil continues to drive the
Nigerian economy, the hope of job creation in
the country would be forlorn. Naanen(2015)
notes that the upstream sector of the oil
industry, by its technically intensive nature
does not create employment, like the
manufacturing and service sectors. Once the
oilfields and pipelines have been put in place,
they require very few workers to run them. In
2013 for instance, SPDC which produced
41percent of Nigeria’s oil and its contractors
employed 4000 and 20000 staff, respectively.
And the entire oil and gas industry employed
about 250,000 workers(Naanen,2015). This
contribution is not significant vis-a-vis the fact
that the sector contributes about 34percent of
Nigeria’s GDP and more than 80 percent of its
foreign exchange. When you juxtapose this
with the case of South Africa where in 2011 the
mining sector contributed 19 percent of GDP,
50 percent of merchandise exports, but
generated about one million jobs, then one can
understand that Nigeria has not benefitted from
AGOA in terms of jobs creation.
The non-oil sector, which amongst other sub- sectors comprises agriculture and textile, which
has the potential to boost job creation, and thus
reduce poverty has not shown any significant
growth under AGOA, as table 1 below shows.
Table 1
BILATERAL TRADE BY SECTOR: UNITED STATES – NIGERIA
VALUE (‘1000’) /YEAR TO – DATE (YTD) IS JANUARY TO MARCH
S/N SECTOR 2010 2011 2012 2012 YTD 2013YTD 2014 2015
1 Agricultural
product
Exports by the US 969,501 1,362,903 1,084,896 284,926 294,042 887,847 696,262
Imports by the US 58,788 83,903 80,836 19,501 25,567 85,551 37,893
