Page 1 of 6

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 441

Plea Bargaining In India: A Critical Analysis

Vishal Sihag

LLM, Department of Law, OPJS University, Churu, Rajasthan

Abstract

Plea bargaining is a system, where both parties namely the accused and the prosecutor along

with the victim sit and make an agreement after assessment of the crime that has been

committed, the damages suffered, and the compensation justified. The system makes sure that

no one loses and no one is a winner, it takes care of both sides of the argument without any

actual arguments in trial. Plea bargaining is an alternate method of resolution of cases, used

to avoid long trials. It has long been used in various criminal justice systems around the

world. As per the National Crime Records Bureau in 2011, the number of inmates housed in

jails was almost 50,000 more than their capacity. It was estimated that 65.1% of all inmates

were under-trials and of these 0.6% had been detained in jail for more than five years at the

end of 2011. The idea of plea bargaining or mutually satisfactory disposition is to avoid

expenses, unpredictable trials and the potential for harassment in all the small and medium

crimes. It reduces the flow of criminal cases in the system and save the time, resources and

energy of the system managers to deal with serious crimes, which threaten the national

security and may cause large-scale damage to life and property.

Keywords: Plea Bargaining, Crime, Property, Harassment, Criminal Justice,

Introduction

In the context of the administration of criminal justice system, it has a dual significance as

because 'justice delayed is justice denied' or 'delayed justice is an infliction of injustice in the

name of justice'. In our country justice is always delayed due to procedural drawbacks. This

article attempts to set out the effective use of plea bargaining to disposal of cases expediently.

It emphasizes the need for effective implementation of plea bargaining in criminal justice

system. Plea bargaining may be defined as an agreement between the accused and the

prosecution through which the accused can get lesser sentence by admitting his or her guilt.

There are three main players in a plea bargaining: the prosecutor, the accused and the judge.

Bevier Law Dictionary defines it-“as to make an agreement in which the defendants plead

guilty to a lesser charge and the prosecutors in return drops more serious charges”.

Page 2 of 6

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 442

Some of the salient features of Plea Bargaining are as follows:

1. Application of offences for which punishment is up to a period of 7 years.

2. Not applicable to socio-economic offences and offences committed against a woman or a

child below the age of 14 years.

3. After passing the order no appeal shall lie to the (any) court against it.

Kinds of Plea Bargaining

(a) Charge Bargaining

The accused pleads guilty in exchange of the promise made by prosecutors to reduce or

dismiss some of the charges brought against him.

(b) Sentence Bargaining

Accused pleads guilty in exchange of a promise by the prosecutor to recommend a lighter or

alternative sentence.

(c) Fact Bargaining

The least used negotiations involves admission to certain facts in return for an agreement not

to introduce certain other facts into evidence

Plea Bargaining in India:

It is the result of modern judicial thinking the concept of plea bargaining was not recognized

in jurisprudence in India. However, accused used to plead guilty only for petty offences and

pay small fine whereupon the case is closed. The Law Commission of India advocated the

introduction of Plea Bargaining in the 142nd (1991), 154th (1996) and 177th (2001) reports. It

was recommended as the alternate method to deal with huge errors of criminal cases by

154threport. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Kachhia Patel ShantilalKoderlal v. State

of Gujarat and Anr. 1980 strongly disapproved the practice of plea bargaining. The apex

court held it unconstitutional, illegal and would tend to encourage corruption, collusion and

pollute the pure fount of Justice. More recently in State of U.P. v. Chandrika, the apex court

held that it is a settled law that on the basis of plea bargaining court cannot dispose the

criminal cases. The court has to decide it on merits. If the accused confesses its guilt,

appropriate sentence is required to be implemented. It also helps that mere acceptance of guilt

does not result in reduction of sentence. Despite this, the government passed the Bill and

finally section-265A to section -265L was added to Criminal Procedure Code.

Definition of Plea Bargaining

Page 3 of 6

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at

http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 443

According to Oxford Dictionary, the word ‘Plea’ means appeal, prayer, request or formal

statement by or on behalf of defendant and the word ‘Bargain’ means negotiation, settlement,

deal, covenant, barter or pact.

Robert E. Scott and William J. Stuntz define Plea Bargaining as a contractual agreement

between the prosecutor and the defendant concerning the disposition of a criminal charge.

Gerald D. Robin defines Plea-bargaining (sometimes also referred to as plea negotiation or

copping a plea) is a process of discussion or negotiation between the define counsel and

prosecutor, aimed at reaching an agreement whereby the prosecutor use discretion to obtain a

lighter sentence in exchange for the defendant’s entering a guilty plea.

The Wikipedia Encyclopedia defines it as to make an agreement in which the defendants

pleads guilty to a lesser charge and the prosecutors in return drop more serious charges.

According to Guidorizzi a proper definition of Plea Bargaining must encompass the broad

range of practices that constitute plea bargaining and must include both explicit plea

bargaining and implicit plea bargaining.

History of plea bargaining in India

Plea-Bargaining in Vedic Period

The concept of plea-bargaining in India has been in vogue since ancient times. Various

ancient treatises and texts reveals that the practice of plea-bargaining in vogue as a means of

self-purification by reducing or removing the effects of sin of committing offence. In Hindu

jurisprudence the researcher find that much care was taken to avoid delay. Delayed justice

was considered most dangerous to the state.

Plea-Bargaining in Post-Vedic Period

Kautilya stated certain situation where the accused could be exempted from punishment. In

one of the episodically even, one can trace out the existence of the practice of plea-bargaining

in Maurya’s period. Kautilya came to know through his secret spy that seith Chandan Das has

given shelter to the family of accused Amatya who had made conspiracy against the King

Chander Gupta Maurya. Kautilya then used bargain as a tool to conciliate or resolve the

dispute. He offered Seith Chandan Das that his offence of helping the accused. Amatya could

be pardoned by the King if he handovers the accused’s family to the King.

Plea Bargaining during British Rule