Page 1 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 347

Theoretical Perspectives of Public

Expenditure in India.

Jyoti Sood

Asst.Prof in Economics. GTB National College, Dakha.

Abstract:

The paper aims to study the importance of public expenditure in economic development of

developing countries like India. In this direction, a paper attempts to study the theoretical

perspectives which have been drawn from various studies signifying the importance of social

economic services for development goals of developing countries. However the analysis and

findings of various studies pertaining to the pattern & composition of public expenditure of

government of India pointed towards the fact that Public Expenditure is not supporting to capital

formation a key to economic development.

Keywords: Public Expenditure, Social Economic services, Capital Formation, Economic

Development.

Introduction and Theoretical Background

Historically public finance has not given

much importance to public expenditure. This

is because the classical economists had a

firm believe in policy of “Laissez-faire” as

such during 18th and 19th century functions of

the states (Govt.) were only of regulatory

nature such as:- maintenance of law and

orders, defending against external

aggression and running public utility

services, “Adam Smith” the founder of

classical economics advocated that

government expenditure was normally as a

waste and by supporting ‘Sir Henry

Parnell”, he asserted that, “Money would

fructify more in the hands of the people than

in those of the state or every particle of

expense that is incurred beyond what is

absolutely required for preservation of social

order and for protection against foreign

attack is waste and unjust and oppressive

imposition upon the public”. Thus, during

18th and 19th century public expenditure

remained neglected.

However, Adolf Wagner, a famous German

fiscal theorist of 19th century, unlike classical

English economists had propounded now

much famous, “law of increased activities of

state” in these terms, “comprehensive

comparisons of different countries and

different times shows that among

progressive people with which alone we are

concerned an increase regularly take place in

the activity of both the central and local

governments. This increase is both extensive

and intensive; the central and local

governments constantly undertake new

functions, while they perform both old and

new functions more efficiently and

completely”. The basic gist of this law in

simple words highlights functional cause

and effect relationship between growth of an

economy and relative growth of public

sector in other words it shows a positive

proportional relationship between economic

development and public expenditure.

According to this law of Wagner scope of

government activities would continue to

increase both absolutely and relatively to

national income for many years into the

twentieth century and this would be the

natural result of economic growth and the

continued pressure for social progress

because economic development carries with

it larger population and larger needs for

urbanizations and technical change etc.

which may call for increased government

activity. Further economic development also

Page 2 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 348

means a greater division of labour, the rise

of larger business organization, and in

general a more complex set of economic

relationship among people. It is not

unreasonable to expect a rise in government

activity.

But however, it was 20th century that marked

a turning point and brought a new revival in

the concept of public expenditure. Say’s law

of market one of main standing pillar of

classical economics, the basic gist of which

states that, “supply creates its own demand

was falsified by the onslaught of the “Great

Depression” of 1930s. Whereby automatic

adjustment mechanism of classical’s failed

to uplift the economy from the clutches of

depression under these circumstances “J.M.

Keynes appeared with the penetrating

analysis and asserted that the basic cause of

the ills of a developed market economy was

the deficiency of effective demand which

was caused on account of low marginal

propensity to consume coupled with a low

marginal efficiency of investment. He,

therefore, advocated a continuous injection

of additional purchasing power in the market

through stimulation of investment and

consumption activities and through direct

public investment. This direct investment

was a part of the public expenditure. Such a

public expenditure was meant to directly add

to the effective demand in the market and

generate a high-value multiplier by

distributing income to those sections of the

population which had a high marginal

propensity to consume. The addition to

demand by such sections would also

stimulate investment activity and thus,

through an all-round increased demand, the

depression could be overcome. It is to be

noted that though basically Keynesian

prescription was directed towards curing a

state of depression. But the logic of the

argument can also be extended to that of

curing an inflationary situation. Thus, it is

argued that Keynes was the first to

formulate convincingly that, “the govt. has

not only ability but the responsibility to use

its power to increase production incomes

and jobs.”

With this recognized and proved importance

of public expenditure, in a period following

great depression and particularly of World

War II there has been extensive and

intensive increase in activities of states

consequent upon which there had been

upward trends in public expenditure in all

countries exactly consistent with Wagner’s

hypothesis. For instance: in USA in 1975 it

expenditure as a percentage of GDP was

35.1% in Germany for the same period of

public expenditure GDP ratio was even

greater than USA as it was again great than

that of Germany USA i.e. it was 45.9%.

Primary objectives

The primary objective of the study is to

study the theoretical perspectives of public

expenditure in India and also studies

whether public expenditure forms capital

formation or not.

Research Methodology

The methodology is one of the important

aspects of a research paper which signifies

the strength and extent. In this regard this

paper is based on secondary data and from

studying the review of literature in India and

World the analysis has been made for the

trend and structure of Public Expenditure in

India.

Perception regarding public

expenditure in World

The literature shows that public

expenditure plays a very important role in

economic development of developing

economics not only for the reasons that

market failure is comparatively strong in

these economics but also for the reason that

public expenditure in these economics is

wanted for the need of capital formulation as

a key to economic development. Economics

development is a multi-dimensional process

which involves progressive changes in

socio-economic structure and is a costly

affair and requires as such huge capital

formation and is not sufficient for

development, reliance on public expenditure

Page 3 of 8

Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/

ISSN: 2395-0463

Volume 04 Issue 03

March 2018

Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 349

is greater because of the fact that in these

economics public expenditure infact act as a

public investment further literature has also

shown that though there is link between

public expenditure and economic

development but that conditioned on the

composition of public expenditure i.e. public

expenditure in these economics helps to

faster developing only if it is incurred on

those components which are directly growth

promoting. The various studies in that

context and the components identified by

them are given as follows:

Lewis (1955) saw that the state as a catalyst

for development by creating the appropriate

institution and incentives to stimulate the

growth of a productive capitalist class

capital accumulation depends on the

institution, values and beliefs of the

society.Lewis (1955;57) observes that

“institutions promote or restrict growth

according to the protection they accord to

effort according to the protection they

accord to effort, according to the

opportunities they provide for specialization

and according to the freedom maneuver

they permit”. Lewis regarded the safe

guarding of property rights as a condition

for capital formation. It was therefore

necessary to protect private property from

public abuse. He argues that without

property. “The human race would have no

progress what so ever, since there would

have been no incentive to improve the

environment in which one lived”. Lewis

(1955; 376-77) list nine (9) functions of

govt. which are relevant for economic

growth and development. They are as

follows: maintaining public economic

influencing attitudes, shaping economic

institution, influencing the use of resources,

influencing the distribution of income,

controlling the quantity of money,

controlling fluctuations, ensuring full

employment and influencing the level of

investment. Andros-Gregoriou and Sugata

Ghosh: of Brunel University in their study

investigate the impact of govt. expenditure

on economic growth, in a heterogeneous

panel for 15 developing countries. Using

GMM technique, they show that countries

with substantial govt. spending have strong

growth effect. Zaidi Sattar: in his study has

revealed that though govt. size has no

impact on the economic performance of

industrial countries but for low income

economies. Though evidences are mixed

points towards a positive impact of govt. on

economic performance. Stefano

Paternostro, Erwin R. Tiongson and

Anand Rajaram in March 2005 in world

banks policy research working paper no.

3555 have shown that composition of public

expenditure has become a key instrument by

which development agencies seek to

promote economic development. In recent

years, the development assistance to heavy

indebted poor countries (HIPCS) has been

made conditional on increased expenditure

on categories that are thought to be pro- poor. Anton Belgrave and Roland

Craigewell: in their study, “the impact of

govt. expenditure on economic growth in

‘Barbadoos’- a disaggregated approach by

using analytical framework of Devrajan et.

Al. 1994 try to determine which type of

govt. spending capital or current have more

effects on economic growth their result

shows that there is a positive and

statistically significant relationship between

economic growth and capital spending i.e.

agriculture, transport, health etc. By contrast

the relationship between current components

of public expenditure and economic growth

is negative. M. Emranul Haque and

Densie R. Osborn: in their study concluded

that capital expenditure is positively related

and current expenditure is negatively related

to economic growth and in a disaggregated

analysis of public expenditure education

spending are the only outlays that are

significantly associated with growth. Stiglitz

1996: sees that role of govt. in developing

countries as establishing infrastructure in its

broadest sense to allow market to fulfil their

central role in increasing wealth and living