Page 1 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 347
Theoretical Perspectives of Public
Expenditure in India.
Jyoti Sood
Asst.Prof in Economics. GTB National College, Dakha.
Abstract:
The paper aims to study the importance of public expenditure in economic development of
developing countries like India. In this direction, a paper attempts to study the theoretical
perspectives which have been drawn from various studies signifying the importance of social
economic services for development goals of developing countries. However the analysis and
findings of various studies pertaining to the pattern & composition of public expenditure of
government of India pointed towards the fact that Public Expenditure is not supporting to capital
formation a key to economic development.
Keywords: Public Expenditure, Social Economic services, Capital Formation, Economic
Development.
Introduction and Theoretical Background
Historically public finance has not given
much importance to public expenditure. This
is because the classical economists had a
firm believe in policy of “Laissez-faire” as
such during 18th and 19th century functions of
the states (Govt.) were only of regulatory
nature such as:- maintenance of law and
orders, defending against external
aggression and running public utility
services, “Adam Smith” the founder of
classical economics advocated that
government expenditure was normally as a
waste and by supporting ‘Sir Henry
Parnell”, he asserted that, “Money would
fructify more in the hands of the people than
in those of the state or every particle of
expense that is incurred beyond what is
absolutely required for preservation of social
order and for protection against foreign
attack is waste and unjust and oppressive
imposition upon the public”. Thus, during
18th and 19th century public expenditure
remained neglected.
However, Adolf Wagner, a famous German
fiscal theorist of 19th century, unlike classical
English economists had propounded now
much famous, “law of increased activities of
state” in these terms, “comprehensive
comparisons of different countries and
different times shows that among
progressive people with which alone we are
concerned an increase regularly take place in
the activity of both the central and local
governments. This increase is both extensive
and intensive; the central and local
governments constantly undertake new
functions, while they perform both old and
new functions more efficiently and
completely”. The basic gist of this law in
simple words highlights functional cause
and effect relationship between growth of an
economy and relative growth of public
sector in other words it shows a positive
proportional relationship between economic
development and public expenditure.
According to this law of Wagner scope of
government activities would continue to
increase both absolutely and relatively to
national income for many years into the
twentieth century and this would be the
natural result of economic growth and the
continued pressure for social progress
because economic development carries with
it larger population and larger needs for
urbanizations and technical change etc.
which may call for increased government
activity. Further economic development also
Page 2 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 348
means a greater division of labour, the rise
of larger business organization, and in
general a more complex set of economic
relationship among people. It is not
unreasonable to expect a rise in government
activity.
But however, it was 20th century that marked
a turning point and brought a new revival in
the concept of public expenditure. Say’s law
of market one of main standing pillar of
classical economics, the basic gist of which
states that, “supply creates its own demand
was falsified by the onslaught of the “Great
Depression” of 1930s. Whereby automatic
adjustment mechanism of classical’s failed
to uplift the economy from the clutches of
depression under these circumstances “J.M.
Keynes appeared with the penetrating
analysis and asserted that the basic cause of
the ills of a developed market economy was
the deficiency of effective demand which
was caused on account of low marginal
propensity to consume coupled with a low
marginal efficiency of investment. He,
therefore, advocated a continuous injection
of additional purchasing power in the market
through stimulation of investment and
consumption activities and through direct
public investment. This direct investment
was a part of the public expenditure. Such a
public expenditure was meant to directly add
to the effective demand in the market and
generate a high-value multiplier by
distributing income to those sections of the
population which had a high marginal
propensity to consume. The addition to
demand by such sections would also
stimulate investment activity and thus,
through an all-round increased demand, the
depression could be overcome. It is to be
noted that though basically Keynesian
prescription was directed towards curing a
state of depression. But the logic of the
argument can also be extended to that of
curing an inflationary situation. Thus, it is
argued that Keynes was the first to
formulate convincingly that, “the govt. has
not only ability but the responsibility to use
its power to increase production incomes
and jobs.”
With this recognized and proved importance
of public expenditure, in a period following
great depression and particularly of World
War II there has been extensive and
intensive increase in activities of states
consequent upon which there had been
upward trends in public expenditure in all
countries exactly consistent with Wagner’s
hypothesis. For instance: in USA in 1975 it
expenditure as a percentage of GDP was
35.1% in Germany for the same period of
public expenditure GDP ratio was even
greater than USA as it was again great than
that of Germany USA i.e. it was 45.9%.
Primary objectives
The primary objective of the study is to
study the theoretical perspectives of public
expenditure in India and also studies
whether public expenditure forms capital
formation or not.
Research Methodology
The methodology is one of the important
aspects of a research paper which signifies
the strength and extent. In this regard this
paper is based on secondary data and from
studying the review of literature in India and
World the analysis has been made for the
trend and structure of Public Expenditure in
India.
Perception regarding public
expenditure in World
The literature shows that public
expenditure plays a very important role in
economic development of developing
economics not only for the reasons that
market failure is comparatively strong in
these economics but also for the reason that
public expenditure in these economics is
wanted for the need of capital formulation as
a key to economic development. Economics
development is a multi-dimensional process
which involves progressive changes in
socio-economic structure and is a costly
affair and requires as such huge capital
formation and is not sufficient for
development, reliance on public expenditure
Page 3 of 8
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 349
is greater because of the fact that in these
economics public expenditure infact act as a
public investment further literature has also
shown that though there is link between
public expenditure and economic
development but that conditioned on the
composition of public expenditure i.e. public
expenditure in these economics helps to
faster developing only if it is incurred on
those components which are directly growth
promoting. The various studies in that
context and the components identified by
them are given as follows:
Lewis (1955) saw that the state as a catalyst
for development by creating the appropriate
institution and incentives to stimulate the
growth of a productive capitalist class
capital accumulation depends on the
institution, values and beliefs of the
society.Lewis (1955;57) observes that
“institutions promote or restrict growth
according to the protection they accord to
effort according to the protection they
accord to effort, according to the
opportunities they provide for specialization
and according to the freedom maneuver
they permit”. Lewis regarded the safe
guarding of property rights as a condition
for capital formation. It was therefore
necessary to protect private property from
public abuse. He argues that without
property. “The human race would have no
progress what so ever, since there would
have been no incentive to improve the
environment in which one lived”. Lewis
(1955; 376-77) list nine (9) functions of
govt. which are relevant for economic
growth and development. They are as
follows: maintaining public economic
influencing attitudes, shaping economic
institution, influencing the use of resources,
influencing the distribution of income,
controlling the quantity of money,
controlling fluctuations, ensuring full
employment and influencing the level of
investment. Andros-Gregoriou and Sugata
Ghosh: of Brunel University in their study
investigate the impact of govt. expenditure
on economic growth, in a heterogeneous
panel for 15 developing countries. Using
GMM technique, they show that countries
with substantial govt. spending have strong
growth effect. Zaidi Sattar: in his study has
revealed that though govt. size has no
impact on the economic performance of
industrial countries but for low income
economies. Though evidences are mixed
points towards a positive impact of govt. on
economic performance. Stefano
Paternostro, Erwin R. Tiongson and
Anand Rajaram in March 2005 in world
banks policy research working paper no.
3555 have shown that composition of public
expenditure has become a key instrument by
which development agencies seek to
promote economic development. In recent
years, the development assistance to heavy
indebted poor countries (HIPCS) has been
made conditional on increased expenditure
on categories that are thought to be pro- poor. Anton Belgrave and Roland
Craigewell: in their study, “the impact of
govt. expenditure on economic growth in
‘Barbadoos’- a disaggregated approach by
using analytical framework of Devrajan et.
Al. 1994 try to determine which type of
govt. spending capital or current have more
effects on economic growth their result
shows that there is a positive and
statistically significant relationship between
economic growth and capital spending i.e.
agriculture, transport, health etc. By contrast
the relationship between current components
of public expenditure and economic growth
is negative. M. Emranul Haque and
Densie R. Osborn: in their study concluded
that capital expenditure is positively related
and current expenditure is negatively related
to economic growth and in a disaggregated
analysis of public expenditure education
spending are the only outlays that are
significantly associated with growth. Stiglitz
1996: sees that role of govt. in developing
countries as establishing infrastructure in its
broadest sense to allow market to fulfil their
central role in increasing wealth and living
