Page 1 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 190
A Comparative and Relevant Study Of Circumstances For Winding Up Of Companies
Between The Companies Act 1956 & 2013
Rama Kant
Research Scholar- Faculty of Law, University of Allahabad, Allahabad
Introduction
The word „Company‟ generally means a group of persons associated for some common
purpose with mutual goals such as business, research etc.; here „Company‟ has been used in
legal sense i.e. a company incorporated or registered under the companies Act. Here, a
company is an artificial person created by a legal process which known as incorporation.
Therefore events affecting individual member such as death, insolvency etc. do not affect the
existence of the company or the last stage in life of the company. Winding up is a term
commonly associated with the ending of a company existence. By this process life of the
company is ended and its property is administered for the benefit of its creditors and
members.
Definitions of Winding up
Professor Grower defined “liquidator or
winding up of a company is the process
whereby its life is ended and its property is
administered for the benefit of its creditors
and members. An administrator, called a
liquidator, is appointed and he takes
control of the company, collects its assets,
pays its debts and finally distributes any
surplus among the members in accordance
with their rights”1
Halsburry’s law of England defined
winding up of a company as “winding up
is a proceeding by means of which the
dissolution of a company is brought about
& in the course of which its assets are
collected and realised; and applied in
1
Gower’s Principles of Modern Company Law
payment of its debts; and when there are
satisfied, the remaining amount is applied
for returning to its members the sums
which they have contributed to the
company in accordance with Articles of
the company”.
In the words of A. Rammaiya, “winding
up is a means by which the dissolution of a
company is brought about and its assets
realised and applied in payment of its
debts, and after satisfaction of the debts,
the balance, if any, remaining is paid to
the members in proportion to the
contribution made by them to the capital of
the company”.2
Thus in the words of Pennington, “winding
up or liquidation is the process by which
2
A Guide to the Companies Act.
Page 2 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 191
the management of a company affairs is
taken out of its director’s hand, its assets
are realized by a liquidator, and its debts
and liabilities are discharged out of the
proceeds of realization, and any surplus of
assets remaining is returned to its
members or shareholders. At the end of
winding up the company will have no
assets or liabilities, and will therefore be
simply a formal step for it to be dissolved,
that is its legal personality as a
corporation to be brought to an end”
Kinds of Winding up of the Companies as
comparative study
Section 270 of the companies Act, 2013
(section 425 of the companies Act, 1956)
envisages two kinds of winding up.
(1) The winding up of a company may be
either,
By the tribunal; or
Voluntary
(2) not withstanding anything contained in
any other Act the provisions of this Act
with respect to winding up shall apply to
the winding up of a company in any of the
modes specified under sub-section(1)
While corresponding provisions of the
company Act, 1956 envisage three kinds
of winding up, By the court, Voluntary, or
Subject to the supervision of the court
Where word „Court‟ and „or‟ substituted
by the Companies Second Amendment
Act, 2002 and „Subject to the Supervision‟
of the court omitted by the Companies
Second Amendment Act, 2002.
Further section 270 of this act substituted
by Act 31 of 2016 as winding up by
Tribunal- the provision of Part I shall
apply to the winding up of a company by
the Tribunal under this Act. And also Part
II Voluntary winding up omitted by Act 31
of 2016 which dated 15th November,
2016.Winding up of a company under the
order of the national company law
Tribunal is also known as compulsory
winding up.
Compulsory winding up is a court based
procedure under which the assets of
company are realised and distributed to the
company‟s creditors. The procedure is
started by the filing (or “Presenting”) of a
petition at court. A judge then decides at a
court hearing whether it is appropriate to
make a winding up order. The most
common reason for a winding up order is
that the company is insolvent. At the end
of the winding up the company is
dissolved.
3
Compulsory winding up has several
grounds under English, Australian and
Indian law. There are certain facts and
circumstances which are to be taken as a
test, or as evidence of a company being is
a state in which the winding up order
3
The insolvency Act 1986 and the insolvency
(England and wales Rules 2016)
Page 3 of 9
Journal for Studies in Management and Planning
Available at
http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/
ISSN: 2395-0463
Volume 04 Issue 03
March 2018
Available online: http://edupediapublications.org/journals/index.php/JSMaP/ P a g e | 192
ought to be made. Such type of acts or
circumstances is different in different
places, viz.
The most common ground for winding up
a company is that it is unable pays its
debts.
In English law a company may be wound
up compulsorily or any of the grounds,
namely, special resolution, reduction in
membership below the legal minimum
failure to commence business within time,
default in filing statutory report, or holding
statutory meeting, inability to pay debts
and just and equitable grounds.
4
.
In the Australian law differs from the
English law as regards the grounds for
compulsory winding up. The court may
order the winding up if directors have
acted in the affairs of the Company in their
own interest rather than in the interest of
the members as a whole or in any other
manner whatsoever which appears to be
unfair or unjust to other members.
5
and if
an inspector appointed under section 169
or 170 or 173 has reported that he is of
opinion that it‟s in the interest of the
public, or of the shareholder or of the
Creditors that the company should be
wound up.
6
4
section 222 of the English Act, 1998
5
s.222(1)(P) of the(Australian) companies Act 1961
6
section 222 (1) (g) (ii) of the companies Act 1961
it is not so under the English law section 222 of the
companies Act, 1948
The Indian position is similar to English
positions under Indian law the
circumstances for winding up, have several
grounds. Section 271 of the companies Act
2013 [section 433 of the companies Act
1956] circumstances in which may be
wound up by the tribunal lays down the
following grounds.
Unable to pay its debts
Special resolution
Acted against the interest, sovereignty
and integrity of India.
Tribunal has ordered under Chapter XIX
Conduct in fraudulent manner
Default in filling its financial
statement
Just and equitable
The relevant provisions of companies Act,
1956 vis-a-vis companies Act, 2013
judgement under section 433 and 434 of
the 1956 Act will continue to be relevant
for the purpose of section 271 of the 2013
Act, under which the above sections of the
1956 Act are consolidated, except insofar
as they relate to winding up by the court,
now vests with the Tribunal and (ii)
Section 433 (b), (c) and (d) companies Act
1956 which has been deleted under the
2013 Act and also there is no provision for
“subject to the supervision of the court” in
the 2013 Act. Apart from this additional
grounds have been incorporated under
clause (c), (d) and (e) of subsection (i) of
